9 ms·
Amateur radio digital communications 44.0.0.0/8 partial sell-off
- farisjarrah 7y agoI am not familiar with this domain, anyone mind answering: What does this mean for amateur radio practitioners, and what does this mean for the greater internet/communications industry?
- wmf 7y agoAll questions are answered at https://www.ampr.org/amprnet/ https://www.ampr.org/amprnet/ (which was submitted several times but didn't make the front page).
- markovbot 7y agoSeems like that site is down. Here's the archive.org link for those interested: https://web.archive.org/web/20190719150143/https://www.ampr.org/amprnet/ https://web.archive.org/web/20190719150143/https://www.ampr....
- amingilani 7y agoEven this link isn't working for me, unfortunately. Something's up with archive.org.
- colechristensen 7y agoThey had a /8, out of that they sold a /10 to probably one of the big 5. They never got close to using the whole /8 and currently allocated about a third of it. They are using the money for grants and scholarships and perhaps an endowment to fund them perpetually (and just being cynical, probably paying the board who made this decision some of that money as well) IPs and blocks have been allocated for decades to people for amateur radio related things and will continue to do so without any changes.
- grendelt 7y ago> They are using the money for grants and scholarships and perhaps an endowment to fund them perpetually But that's outside the scope of what most in the amateur radio community would expect from caretakers of AMPRnet.
- jlgaddis 7y ago> ... they sold a /10 to probably one of the big 5. Yep, the last /10 went to AWS.
- cm2187 7y agoWhat sort of money are we talking about here?
- wmf 7y ago$80M?
- dylz 7y agoMarket rate is 60-90 million. $25+/IP is reasonable given that it's a contiguous block, legacy, etc.
- Bluecobra 7y ago44.192.0.0/10 was sold which equals 4,194,304 IP addresses. At $20.00/address that comes out to a cool $83,886,040. Using this to base the IP address cost: https://auctions.ipv4.global/prior-sales https://auctions.ipv4.global/prior-sales
- virtuallynathan 7y agoNone of the big guys are paying this much, especially for blocks this size. $5-10/IP.
- throwaway2048 7y agoNice to see they get backroom deals for about 0.15% of the ip addresses on the internet, AND massive discounts.
- billh 7y ago>These days, less than one third of the address space is assigned and in use. Large chunks of it have almost never been used This part probably angers me the most as I (and I'm sure many others) have asked for an allocation in this address space and after waiting months without reply was eventually denied the request.
- dev_dull 7y agoIt’s frustrating that they paint the unused space as evidence of of abandonment, but the reality is that it’s been impossible to use any of this address space!
- entropea 7y agoI didn't even know about it until yesterday! It's kept quiet and secret I guess. As a ham for 10 years now, I totally would've used this for projects if I could've got allocated space. I believe http://hamwan.org/ http://hamwan.org/ is on 44.0.0.0.
- dev_dull 7y agoHanlon's razor says to give this organization the benefit of a doubt, but to see this space go up for sale makes me sad.
- cstejerean 7y agoWell it’s not too late, they only sold a /10 of the /8
- mac01021 7y agoAs someone who does not know any more about ham radio than can be inferred from "Contact" and "Stranger Things", I'm curious to know what kind of projects you would have used it for.
- TrueDuality 7y agoThere are a lot of digital interconnect systems operating on HAM bands. Personally for me I've been part of the ARES (Amateur Radio Emergency Services) network for a while. A lot of that volunteer work is getting communication up and running to people in places that have been hit by natural disasters. Normally this involves HAM with mobile rigs driving into the affected areas and acting as a hub to get messages out. Currently this is a voice service "Hey WXXX, I've got a message for the Adam Smith at phone number 555-555-1234. Jane and her family made out of the flood and are unharmed. They're going to try and find a ride to your home in the next couple of days." This is very error prone and would likely benefit from having a reliable digital service available. It would be valuable at least IMHO to have repeaters that operate as part of the ARES network be vetted and given a tunnel to a public address like this. It's not much but having a recognized digital presence that could be used as an identifier not only for contacting loved ones in distress but also by organizations such as FEMA to distinguish random emails from volunteers on the ground trying to get specific assistance might be useful. This was kinda just my first wish list item when I thought of how I could use some public space so maybe there are better ideas out there.
- yufrv 7y agoDown with the legacy /8s.
- z3ugma 7y agoWow, this sounds crazy to an outsider. I highly recommend reading deep into the mailing list conversation from the link. It really does sound like a private organization "squatted" on a public resource, went under the radar for a long time, and then cashed out on their adverse possession. My outsider perspective on this is ARIN needs to provide a transparency report on the number of complaints it received from legitimate ham operators who attempted to register addresses in this block but were denied by ARDC, and a general oversight review of the characteristics of ARDC as a community steward of this space.
- scroot 7y agoAMPR was one of the first organizations to register with the DNS in the early 80's. It was an original player on the ARPANET before it was "the Internet." In fact, they tried to register in 1987 using their own TLD (.AMPR) because, according to them, they were a "mobile" network (didn't fall under the ccTLDs) and did not fit into any of the existing gTLD categories. After some deliberation the NIC ultimately registered them under .ORG in 1988.
- icedchai 7y agoARDC had administrative control of 44.0.0.0/8 for decades. It's not squatting... It's their space. There aren't enough active Hams in the world to use all of it, so nothing is lost. We'll all benefit more from Amazon and their customers making use of some of it.
- throwaway2048 7y agoARDC is supposed to be controlling it on behalf of amateur radio operators throughout the world, not selling it off to amazon. A mission that they have completely ignored for years and years at a time mind you, it has been nearly impossible to get allocations out of them for extended stretches of time.
- nullbyte 7y agoI don't like mega-corporations stealing away the "public land" of the RF spectrum. This is like having a nice public park in your neighborhood get replaced with a Goldman Sachs corporate building.
- dang 7y agoA small earlier thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20475855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20475855.
- EE84M3i 7y agoI wrote about this block earlier last year: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16912496 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16912496 Note that this is also the block used for the UCSD CAIDA "Internet Telescope": https://www.caida.org/projects/network_telescope/ https://www.caida.org/projects/network_telescope/
- jlv2 7y agoInformative thread, with some details on the 501(c)(3) being funded with the profits: https://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/2019-July/102138.html https://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/2019-July/102138.h...
- syn0byte 7y agohttps://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-tege/rp1995-48.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-tege/rp1995-48.pdf I'll bet you it still just vanishes...
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoThe money involved in IPv4 allocations - and name allocations too - really sickens me. It's a blemish on humanity and a testament to the limitless nature of human greed. IANA (and ICANN as a whole) is a corrupt, captured organization that I think represents the worst of the internet when it should have been the best of it. Removing price caps on .org, gold rushing outrageously priced gTLDs to anyone with the money (private corps), and the ridiculous marketplace of IPv4 subnets - I'm ashamed to have anything to do with this community. I'm loathe to extend my contempt to capitalism as a whole but it's crap like this which makes me wonder if the humanity of future centuries will look back at our greed-powered society with disdain.
- amingilani 7y agoI'm confused. You're blaming humanity because a marketplace developed following the scarcity of a commodity? Why was any of this bad behavior? I'm genuinely confused.
- MereInterest 7y agoHe's blaming humanity for maintaining a commodity as scarce, rather than working to alleviate the scarcity.
- mbesto 7y agoHere's my take - creating a marketplace where a sole actor has control over a scarce resource (IP addresses) is exactly why anti-trust exists. A true marketplace assumes there is competition. How do you have competition when the underlying resource (1) has a clearly understood finite number (2) is controlled by one entity and (3) can't be differentiated in any way (e.g. 10.0.0.0/8 has no differentiated intrinsic or extrinsic value over 11.0.0.0/8).
- tlrobinson 7y agoI don't really have a problem with selling off parts of 44/8 that are unlikely to ever be used. I do have a big problem with the ARDC unilaterally doing this without any public discussion or real accountability. They should have created a new foundation with board members from various amateur radio organizations (ARRL, AMSAT, IARU, TAPR, etc) in order to manage the (rumored $50 million) funds.
- JorgeGT 7y agoInteresting to look at the usage of the block in the context of the entire IPv4 space (2018): https://benjojo.co.uk/internet-2018.png https://benjojo.co.uk/internet-2018.png
- fragmede 7y agoXKCD's rendition: https://xkcd.com/195/ https://xkcd.com/195/ I feel it's slightly more readable, if out of date.
- echelon 7y agoWhat are Ford and Prudential doing with their allocation? It seems unnecessary for them to have so much space.
- JorgeGT 7y agoI guess that at some point Ford though they could have an IP for each car? Out of curiosity I looked at the headers of an email I got from them and sure enough it came from an IP in their allocation! However, the same was not true for emails from Daimler...
- halter73 7y agoI would have more faith that the ARDC will use the proceeds from the sale for the benefit of the ham community at large if they engaged the community beforehand. It seems to me that they saw the opportunity to make a lot of money, and figured having a lot of money is a good problem to have and they could figure out what to do with it later. The fact that they have no specific public plans for the money is telling. They mention vague plans for grants, scholarships and a perpetual endowment, but how do we know they won't keep most of it in the endowment and use most of the interest to pay board member salaries? If the board decided to do that, who could stop them? Who elects the board? I particularly don't like this response: > This makes me one of a VERY small group of people with any arguable personal property interest in network 44. And yes, 25% of this space, which is VERY unlikely to ever be used by hams, has been sold to Amazon. > Rather than try to personally profit from this, we all readily agreed to place the entire proceeds of this sale into a 501(c)(3) charity chartered to support amateur digital radio and related developments. No one is buying a yacht or a mansion. https://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/2019-July/102138.html https://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/2019-July/102138.h... I'm not saying I expect the board will use the money to buy a yacht or a mansion, but the whole tone of that email makes it sound like they feel entitled to do so, and it was only their own magnanimity that caused them to give the proceeds to a 501(c)(3). I'd much rather the board of the organization see themselves as stewards who are not personally entitled to the money. Otherwise you end up with "charities" like the Trump Foundation.
- ds 7y agoWould be interesting to know the salary of the board will be in the future. It looks and smells like a cash grab to benefit those at the top with cushy jobs to be a pseudo VC under the guide of giving "grants". If they were being honest with themselves, they would donate the entirety to the EFF instead of this bullshit maneuver. Just to add, even if they dont get a salary at all (I would be shocked), the responsible thing for them to do would be to give the money away to the EFF or another org who knows how to best put the money to use. The idea we are entrusting a group thats financial statement going back the past few years show just 5k-10k in assets with a 100 million dollar windfall is insane. If they dont fuck it all up within the first 6 months I will be shocked. More likely though will be some lawsuits which delays any use of the funds.
- PunksATawnyFill 7y agoWhat does that mean?
- jrockway 7y agoI hate to be a downer, but nobody even knew about this space until it was mentioned here. I've been a ham for almost 10 years and this is the first I've heard of it. The Internet and ham radio don't mix. The rules of the modern Internet are "encrypt everything and trust nothing." The laws of ham radio are literally "you must not encrypt anything". It wasn't meant to be, unless you want to change the laws in every ITU member state. By the time that's done, we will all be accessing the Hypernet with IPv20 from our personal space stations. Selling off this IP space to Amazon so that some people can get grants is going to make way better use of this resource than than the ham community ever did. (I like all the people on the nanog list trying to derail it. "Some of the board members don't have ham licenses!" Not actually a requirement to manage a ham radio organization. Only a requirement to transmit a signal. "There is an antique router configuration out there that creates a peering arrangement between the University of California and Amazon that's not authorized!" Guess what guys, they'll probably shut down the arrangement. They're not going to say "welp, there is no way to fix this, here's your money back Amazon!" The thought that that's a possible outcome is making me laugh. I am sure Amazon can find a transit provider if they need one.)
- nexuist 7y ago> The laws of ham radio are literally "you must not encrypt anything" Wait, really? Why is this the case?
- tesseract 7y agoTo enable enforcement of amateurism.
- pmlnr 7y agoSimilarly why gopher is not encrypted: https://gopher.floodgap.com/gopher/gw.lite?gopher://tilde.team:70/0/~rain1/phlog/20190608-encrypting-gopher.txt https://gopher.floodgap.com/gopher/gw.lite?gopher://tilde.te...
- fragmede 7y agoThe FCC, which has explicit purview over how radio frequencies are used, details the rules for amateur radio in part 97. In particular, "Amateur" is explicitly defined there to not allow commercial interests to use those radio waves. The US government allocated portions of the radio spectrum for use by (licensed) amateurs, kind of like the national parks. I'm not allowed to cut down trees in Yosemite and run my own private road so I can make a shortcut and drive right up to Half Dome. The prohibition against encryption comes from a similar place. If you're looking for privacy, ham radio is not the medium to use. FCC part 97 covers amateur operation (in the US), and the relevant part is §97.309 (4)(b), which states "data emissions using unspecified digital codes must not be transmitted for the purpose of obscuring the meaning of any communication." The intent of the "unspecified digital code" matters. My reading of this is that unspecified codes for authentication are allowed. I've always wanted to build telnet with authentication - if interested, others could to watch what I'm doing, but not be able to impersonate me.
- rexarex 7y agoWe were supposed to run out of space in the 90s, but NAT was a temporary bandaid that turned into the status quo. Not the original intent, and it’s used as a de facto firewall with really mixed results. I say, exhaust it and force people into IPv6 like we should all be on.
- rohan1024 7y agoThere's no incentive for migrating to ipv6 for corporations. I have said this previously NAT breaks the Internet [0]. Without setting an expiration date for ipv4 NAT is going to get dragged to 2050. [0]:https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20253427 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20253427
- londons_explore 7y agoIpv6 adoption is slowly creeping up, and if you were to put grandma's broadband on ipv6 only, she would still be able to use Facebook, Twitter, and all the other major big sites. I'd say the day some ISP's stop provisioning ipv4 (especially for 'social networks only' plans) might be getting close.
- vwdhx 7y agoMaybe NAT breaks the Internet of twenty years ago. But we've already worked around it. I'm using a computer which is behind a NAT which is behind a CG-NAT and everything works fine. Sure, people can't connect to me directly, but why would I want that to happen? If anything, that makes my computer more secure. I know this sounds like trolling, but let's be pragmatic.
- fragmede 7y agoSome users do want people to be able to connect to them directly though, hence Universal Plug and Play (UPnP), which can open ports on your router. You may disagree with the wisdom of automating the port forwarding process for people who don't understand networking concepts but there are people that do want other people to be able to connect to them directly, even if you don't. Generalizing that one use case will suits everybody, fits about as well as one-size-fits-all clothing. Which never fits right.
- DonHopkins 7y agoI know somebody who basically stole a class A IP network many years ago. (He wouldn't tell me which one. ;) The company that owned it went out of business, so he registered their domain name, and sent in an email to authorize the transfer. Once you've got a hot class A network on your hands, but don't have 16,777,216 computers to use it, what can you possibly with it? It's not as if you can hide it in your garage, file the serial number off, repaint it, and put it up for sale on the black market! He ended up trading it under the table to a company that could use it, in exchange for the promise of free service for life. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_assigned_/8_IPv4_address_blocks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_assigned_/8_IPv4_addre...
- icedchai 7y agoI can believe this about a class B or C. Class A is too large to go unnoticed.