3 ms·
And somehow, as if by magic, anyone from a working-class background will turn out to have been a "jerk", and those who went to the right schools and are friends
by lmm 7y ago
And somehow, as if by magic, anyone from a working-class background will turn out to have been a "jerk", and those who went to the right schools and are friends with the right people will turn out to have been "living our values". And one more slice of that pesky social mobility will go away.
- alttab 7y agoWhat are the values? How well are they defined? It's a popularity contest which just creates a new type of politics unless its super well defined and easily demonstrable and measurable. This seems like a great way to push out your brilliant people who won't tolerate bullshit or sacrifice their point for the sake of social cohesion.
- marcinzm 7y ago>This seems like a great way to push out your brilliant people who won't tolerate bullshit or sacrifice their point for the sake of social cohesion. Why do you believe such people shouldn't be pushed out? Social cohesion is important in any group of people working on a common goal and a company is made up of groups of people working together on common goals. Likewise, there's always bullshit in larger companies and those who don't "tolerate" it usually just force others to deal with twice as much.
- cousin_it 7y agoSure, many companies suffer from the "herding cats" problem and could use more cohesion. But there are also many companies that suffer from excessive groupthink, and would be better off with more people going against the grain. You can't say that one advice is universally better than the other, you need to look at the specific company.
- Nasrudith 7y agoBecause brilliant people move things forward by leaps and bounds. And anti-intellectualism has a proven track record of accepting failure in exchange for social control. Up until they get their asses kicked trivially when they try to push someone who hasn't slacked off. Why should bullshit be tolerated when it leads to waste and stagnation? That sort of attitude is why Detroit fell so hard along with many post industrial wastelands. They scorned higher education or going another direction and then their keystone economies collapsed.
- jacques_chester 7y agoThere are no brilliant jerks in the upper class? I dunno about that. Sometimes I run into folks who went to "a small school outside of Boston", and well...
- lmm 7y agoYou'd think that. But somehow these subjective assessment criteria always turn into a way to include the upper class and push out the riff-raff. (Of course it's probably mostly a question of what class the person doing the assessing is from).
- dragonwriter 7y ago> There are no brilliant jerks in the upper class? The upper class in a capitalist society are capitalists and not laborers and, as such, are not subject to employee performance reviews. So changing such a process to punish “brilliant jerks” has no adverse impact on brilliant jerks in the upper class. If brilliant jerks are the people most likely to be able to move upward in class if not actively sulpressed, then suppressing them via employee performance review process may be an effective means of suppressing upward class mobility, though the evidence that this is the actual effect or motivation here seems to be missing. Though I think that it may be that the reference to the working class was somewhat imprecise and the real boundary-enforcement that the concern addresses here is between the non-intelligentsia portion of the proletariat and a group comprised of the proletarian and petit bourgeois intelligentsia.