3 ms·
I really don't like the idea that some third forces would interfere with internal politics of my country. Browser should work according to technical standards,
by vbezhenar 7y ago
I really don't like the idea that some third forces would interfere with internal politics of my country. Browser should work according to technical standards, not according to what US citizens decided to be good or bad. If Firefox wants to forbid locally installed roots, I'm all for it, but implement it for everyone.
That said, I don't see how government would step back. People are uninformed and generally passive, they wouldn't care enough. So, sadly, it might be the only way to push back that decision. But I still don't like it.
- oytis 7y agoPrivacy is not 'what US citizens decided to be good', it's fundamental human right. I'm not a Kazakh, I'm Russian, but our politics has a lot in common. And I would say, third forces interfering with politics is not as bad (if at all), as local governments interfering with people's privacy.
- pornel 7y agoEncryption is political. The technical standards around HTTPS are politically motivated. The push for HTTPS everywhere, de-facto required TLS in HTTP/2, eSNI & DoH, were largely a response to the US government's mass surveillance. However, who makes these changes is interesting. It happened to be mostly developers in Five Eyes' countries acting against Five Eyes. Do we need to have elected representatives in browser vendors and encryption standards bodies? Or given that the elected representatives are for mass surveillance, would that be any good?
- martingxx 7y agoI disagree that encryption is political. Fundamentally, it's a privacy and security mechanism and on its own it's no more political than locks, safes, paper shredders or curtains. Because of the complex, un-intuitive nature of encryption, it mixed particularly badly with politics, and we're still suffering from the fallout of that now. (crypto wars 1) Firefox and other application vendors who use those standards do end up being unavoidably slightly closer to politics (as demonstrated in this particular issue now), but I think Mozilla would do well to keep their goal simple - Protect user privacy where they can and explain to users when they can't. A notice to the user like "You are using a key known to allow access to third parties" is just a fact and no more political than "the site you are visiting uses weak crypto standards" or similar.
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y agoPrivacy is political.
- salawat 7y agoPrivacy is apolitical. In fact, it is built into the very fabric of how the world works. Does the grain of sand on a beach in Japan know whether or not I've just sat down in America? No. Does the merging black hole/neutron star somewhere in the universe know that it will have consequences for small bags of carbon and water somewhere in the universe? No it does not. Do you know what your child is actually thinking when you harangue them for the umpteenth time? No, you don't. Lack of privacy/privileged access to information has always been the byproduct of active human effort. The natural state of things, is for information to only effect it's immediate locality. I.e. privacy. Lack of privacy; therefore is the political subject. Subtle difference, granted, but that subtlety belies the consequences of letting things get out of hand. Excessive "awareness" is a problem. There are those that relish the thought for the power such systems confer; they chant "I can make you safer!" "You lose nothing!" "There is no danger in this!" "It is just the sacrifice a Good Citizen should be expected to make for the Greater Good!" However, once the check is written, does the government ever relinquish it's right to privacy? Nay. National Security. Just trust us. Never mind that the assertion that led to the sacrifice of the initial liberty was that there were those amongst us who couldn't be trusted. Nay, sir, I agree with GP. The breach of fundamental rights (or imposition of obligation) is the matter of politics, and very infrequently do I see any credible case made where something as fundamental as breaking the confidentiality of the most efficient means of communication anything but a power grab, and eventual tool of tyrannical oppression.
- evrydayhustling 7y agoConsistently applied standards are good. But if a developer change can interfere with a country's politics, it's because political actors have coopted the developers' work for leverage in their own system. Dev teams like Mozilla's are under no obligation to give a stable platform to anybody's political goals.
- Jwarder 7y agoI also think there is a risk that Mozilla if blocks the government certs then that would turn all Firefox users in the country into criminals. I'm all for security and privacy, but it is a rough choice between protecting users from surveillance by their authoritarian government or trying to make sure users can follow local laws.
- vbezhenar 7y agoI don't think that we are there. There are no laws to circumvent the bans and in fact a lot of users are using VPNs. The only measures our government is doing is technical ones: ban websites, install DPI, now they apparently plan to MITM on some (or all) connections. But I've never heard about anyone convinced of circumventing those measures. In fact I'm not aware that any similar law exists. We could be there one day. But now the fight is purely technical. I'm, personally, going to set up dedicated server on online.net and setup proper and fast VPN for all my relatives and friends. I hope that other people would do the same.