4 ms·
You may cite me on this - 1. first of all to ban the idea you will have to be specific enough in describing the idea in a law that can be referenced so that wh
by bryanrasmussen 7y ago
You may cite me on this -
1. first of all to ban the idea you will have to be specific enough in describing the idea in a law that can be referenced so that when people think they are encountering the idea they may reference the law to be sure. Any one who can reference that law will be exposed to the idea.
2. ideas are not static expressions, perhaps we can think of them as nodes in a directed graph of all human thought, if you want delete the node you should direct all the nodes with arrows pointing at that node or someone is going to notice hey there are a lot of arrows pointing over here at this node that is gone and come up with the idea all over again by what is implied by the arrows.
3. if we think of ideas instead of how memetics would describe them we have a similar problem to number 2, that idea evolved from other ideas, and it is evolving into other ideas as we speak. Perhaps at some point we will have the technology to get rid of a memetic infection but not yet. And considering how well we've done on getting rid of measels I doubt it.
4. Probably the closest we can come to killing off an idea is the destructions of heresies in the middle ages, for example the Adamite heresy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adamites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adamites however the ideas still exist as evidenced by the Wikipedia page, just nobody cares enough to embody the idea.
So, instead of killing facial recogniton if a similar thing were done with facial recognition that was done with the ideas of the Adamites we should kill a lot of facial recognition researchers and people building facial recognition tools, and then hope that nobody new will care to do any facial recognition stuff (if you get brutal enough that just might be).
Making the idea unpopular might work, but I doubt it, because the utility and power the idea promises would be too great a temptation. Do you need a citation on the too great a temptation statement?
- vangelis 7y agoCounterpoint, the ATF's gun database. The technology exists, and yet it's not digitized. It's purely a policy issue.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agowhat does the ATF's gun database have to do with banning an idea? The database may be used to ban guns, but probably not every gun in existence, and as such it will not do anything about banning the idea that you can shoot metal projectiles out of a small handheld device with a cylinder for shooting the projectile s out of (so as to provide aiming capabilities and speed) in a way that these small handheld devices can be used as effective people killing tools.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThe database itself is the idea that's been banned, or at least any computerised form of it. By the the Firearm Owners Protection Act (1986) a/k/a FOPA, 18 U.S.C. 926 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/926 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/926 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firearm_Owners_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firearm_Owners_Protection_Act Which is why ATFs National Tracing Center remains paper-based: https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-atf-guns-trace-center-20160728-snap-htmlstory.html https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-atf-guns-trace-center-2...
- dredmorbius 7y agoA similar assertion was made earlier today on Reddit. A few examples of technologies and concepts which have been banned or restricted, to greater or lesser effect: https://old.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/cewumq/opinion_dont_regulate_facial_recognition_ban_it/eu6so9z/ https://old.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/cewumq/opinion_don...
- bryanrasmussen 7y agowait - so you mean you can go to that site and read what the idea was that was banned!?! please refute my point #1 given this detail - an Idea which can be looked up online has not been banned, it has been disseminated.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThat is a list of banned technologies I'd compiled myself, as should be clear from reading the linked comment.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoThis original subthread started off as a response to statement you can't ban an idea and someone wanting a citation on that. I never said you can't ban a technology or an implementation of an idea, I said that it is logically impossible to ban an idea (point 1 - because you have to have an accurate enough description of the idea for people to reference when they encounter it in order to enforce the ban). To reiterate an earlier example in as concise a way as possible - you cannot ban the idea of a gun but you can ban guns - of course people will still make guns but at much reduced numbers but the idea of gun will probably not be especially affected by the ban. Yet in response I've gotten a lot of examples how people can ban implementations of ideas.