3 ms·
That is not a blunder of the Constitution itself, but rather the result of being run under a hostile interpreter. That cannot be prevented, only mitigated. The
by mindslight 7y ago
That is not a blunder of the Constitution itself, but rather the result of being run under a hostile interpreter. That cannot be prevented, only mitigated.
The real blunder was not focusing on ways to escape undesirable outcomes justified by the Constitution. A real simple escape hatch for interstate commerce would be to say that the federal government could only intervene if the specific states could not agree themselves.
The Civil War was one of the best chances at pushing back against generally accreting federal power. Had it gone the other way with states being able to withdraw from the union, nonsensical tripe like Wickard v Filburn could have never stood. But like every other tooth in the totalitarian ratchet, we gained an immediate good at the expense of a long term cost.