3 ms·
make widening our understanding of the universe into religion, problem solved. (i thought about making the scientific method into a religion, but it doesn't mak
by baq 7y ago
make widening our understanding of the universe into religion, problem solved. (i thought about making the scientific method into a religion, but it doesn't make any sense :))
- merpnderp 7y agoEveryone takes things on faith. For instance most could quite trivially prove PV=nRT, but most just take someone else’s word on faith. In a universe where you can never really know something unless you’ve proven it yourself, you take nearly everything on faith from someone else who claims to have proven it.
- aeorgnoieang 7y agoI don't think 'faith' covers both things. Yes, a lot of people accept lots of things as being true on the authority of others, but there's lots of other evidence that those authorities are trustworthy. The details, i.e. the specific differences, of religious claims aren't correlated with any other evidence, or even possible evidence, which is why it's so much easier for so many different creeds to exist even given that they make different, and often contradictory claims. As an example, most people haven't directly carried out all of the relevant experiments needed to discover the laws and theories of electromagnetism, but the evidence of TV, radio, telegraphs are easy enough to perceive and thereof trust. There doesn't seem to be nearly anything similar for religious beliefs, that would make any specific religion more likely than any other. Most of the evidence that does exist for religions seems to be common to any or all of them, e.g. the benefits of group cohesion, common morality, etc..
- magduf 7y ago>For instance most could quite trivially prove PV=nRT, but most just take someone else’s word on faith. No, that's not faith, not in a religious sense. People accept stuff like that because they believe that other people have followed all the proper procedures to prove this is true (within tolerance of error, etc.), and that they aren't making it up or lying for some reason, and most importantly, that it is independently reproducible and verifiable. Religious faith has no such element of verifiability. So this isn't "faith" at all.
- JorgeGT 7y agoThis is actually similar to the rationale behind the Vatican Observatory, which does some serious science: http://www.vaticanobservatory.va/content/specolavaticana/en/research/research-highlights.html http://www.vaticanobservatory.va/content/specolavaticana/en/...
- SkyMarshal 7y agoIsaac Asimov explored that idea in the Foundation series. At one point science became a religion and even had priests. One notable aspect of the religion of science is that it actually works (prayers are answered, etc), which made for some interesting story telling. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_of_Science https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_of_Science
- magduf 7y agoSounds interesting, but I can see that the problem with a society like that is that by restricting the practice of science to a select group of elites, you're holding back progress because people who aren't in that group, who have a great talent (or determination) for scientific work, are presumably being prevented from entering the field. Imagine if we went back in time to 1980, and made it so that the only people who could write computer programs had to attend special schools and go through an expensive licensing process, and no one was allowed to do it on their own, schools weren't allowed to establish their own programs, and people couldn't even write a simple shell script without going to jail. We wouldn't have the technology we have today.