4 ms·
> Despite the app's success, some executives worried that it wasn’t sustainable and that the company needed to diversify by creating LGBTQ content to diversify
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
> Despite the app's success, some executives worried that it wasn’t sustainable and that the company needed to diversify by creating LGBTQ content to diversify beyond hookups and one-night stands.
Men wanting to fuck is not sustainable?? TBH, this whole article strikes me as after-the-fact hand-wringing and blame-gaming about how Grindr "never achieved its vision", a vision I guarantee 99% of its users couldn't care less about. Grindr was always about men finding other men to fuck (and sure, sometimes to go out on a date with or hang out and chat with), but the idea given in the article of it morphing into some sort of "queer Atlantic" has all the hallmarks of a completely out-of-touch and delirious exec.
- davesmith1983 7y agoMany websites now want to play at social engineering the populace. They forget what their users want, try socially engineering those users which a great number of them reject and users move elsewhere when something better turns up.
- criley2 7y agoI think it is less about wanting to social engineer, as it is becoming indebted to early investors who invest not in a small, simple and useful service but in the vision of this service being a huge profitable thing. I'd wager that many of the worst 'social engineering' pivots by websites/apps are either because they're struggling to keep up with early investor expectations, or because they've gone big and are struggling to keep up with growth and profitability at scale. Facebook didn't just wake up one day and let foreign governments undermine elections with advertisements, but, profitability is undoubtedly why they got there.
- davesmith1983 7y agoThat doesn't fit in with what we have seen. Many sites start socially engineering when they think they are big enough to dominate. I am not an expert on dating apps (especially ones for homosexuals), however the language quoted about "creating a better place" etc. Is exactly the same language I've seen by other sites that want to socially engineer. It cannot be a coincidence that many of the companies use a lot of the same phrases and language.
- duxup 7y agoIt's an interesting way to look at it just from a perspective of if something is "successful" (let's just use that term very generically). At one point an app could arguably very popular and: Users: This app is great! Company: This app is yet to reach our goal X. Parent Company: This app should do Y. So then what is the next step? Is some sort of self destruction inevitable?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIn a perfect world, someone with some backbone in leadership should be able to identify that the product isn't going to meet the company's goals, and a new sponsor should be spun off or selected to inherit the product. Examples I would point to would be Flickr finding a welcoming home (SmugMug) after being tossed from one useless org (Yahoo) to another (Oath). Or what Delicious might have been (Yahoo again). It's unlikely such a world will ever exist, but I'm a dreamer. Don't kill what has value if it can be self-sustaining somewhere.
- duxup 7y agoOh man I didn't even know Flickr found a good place... that saga has been endless. Yeah I see a lot of purchases that make no sense, not going to get along with their parent company.... and they just trash something that might be worthwhile.
- cambalache 7y agoHeh, even if not that small (2%-5% of the population?) I think homosexual men would be an interesting "niche" market to cater, but I wonder besides Grindr and some night clubs what other kind of business have a proposition which would only be of interest to gay men.
- sprafa 7y agoIt’s hard to believe they felt like Grindr was “unsustainable”. It’s completely ubiquitous in the gay scene across every country I’ve ever been in. I mean there’s a lot more variety now, lots of competing apps, but for years Grindr ruled the day for tens of millions of people! The stories about them sharing HIV data with the Chinese government is horrific. Pretty sure they could microtarget that into individuals.