4 ms·
Also for people who don't have mobile phone signal at home (hello us), it's almost impossible to use these 2FA systems. There are a few systems including the U
by rwmj 7y ago
Also for people who don't have mobile phone signal at home (hello us), it's almost impossible to use these 2FA systems. There are a few systems including the UK government's own "Verify" scheme for submitting tax returns that I quite literally cannot use.
Not that mobile phone 2FA is actually secure. Fraudsters in the UK have discovered that it's possible to take over phone numbers rather easily because that relies on the phone companies' own systems which are (predictably) insecure.
- spullara 7y agoA lot of carriers support wifi calling. You should see if yours done and turn it on.
- jen729w 7y agoI still don’t think an actual SMS would be received. SMS is old-school. That thing is going via the tower or it’s not going at all. (This is just a hunch. Happy to be told I’m wrong!)
- wiml 7y agoMy understanding is that "WiFi Calling" involves having your phone set up an IPsec tunnel (authenticated by your SIM) with your carrier, and then transferring essentially the same packets over that as would be transferred to the cell tower. I think that includes SMS traffic along with everything else. (IIRC, the 3G and LTE versions of the tunnel carry traffic at different layers of the protocol stack, but in both cases being able to handle SMS and similar non-Internet features is part of the goal. As is being able to handoff between wifi and cellular transports in the middle of a call — I have no idea how well that works in practice.)
- spullara 7y agoSMS will be received. It is just like being on the normal cell network.
- robin_reala 7y agoSome Verify providers have a provision for token based 2FA. I used the Post Office for my account with standard TOTP.
- fiblye 7y agoOr people who change phone numbers for any reason or even travel. If 2FA decides to kick in then, your account is effectively dead with most companies until you regain access to your old phone number.
- kalleboo 7y agoI lost my Uber account to this after I logged in on a prepaid SIM while traveling and didn't reset it before tossing the SIM