5 ms·
Law doesn't come from (or shouldn't come from) unqualified legislators guessing about what the future will be like and what problems will be there. Law comes fr
by whatshisface 7y ago
Law doesn't come from (or shouldn't come from) unqualified legislators guessing about what the future will be like and what problems will be there. Law comes from when somebody has a grievance against somebody else, and society steps in to resolve it.
Could you imagine how bad it would be if Congress got excited about the potential for internet crime in 1985, tried to guess the form of the problems that would arise, and then wrote laws banning and permitting things that they thought would lead to trouble? There is no way somebody back then could predict which situations would lead to trouble decades later.
The best way to deal with space would probably be to let judges stretch earth law (property rights, whatever) to produce as much justice as possible, and then modifying the laws once the lessons had been borne out.
- nerdponx 7y agoIsn't that pretty much what the US Constitution was?
- whatshisface 7y agoIt would have been if the US was the first country.
- taejo 7y agoThe United States Constitution wasn't even the first constitutive document of the United States! It was very much informed by the experiences, not only of other countries, but also very much of the Articles of Confederation.
- BeefySwain 7y agoSo this sounds great in theory, but there are a number of ways that I can think of where it falls short. Tragedy of the commons issues are ones that often largely too late to easily solve by the time enough public pressure has built up to force legislative oversight. Social injustice issues are the same. That being said, I agree that overzealous legislators making pot shots at potential issues is not a good solution either. My thought would be meet halfway with predictive laws with sunset clauses? That way, if a mistake is made, it will be undone in a predictable timescale without the need to get an oft deadlocked congress to take action.
- whatshisface 7y agoLaws aren't so easy to sunset even if they have sunset clauses. Whoever benefits from the legislative mistakes will grow to be more powerful than whoever is being pinched by them, and then they'll lobby like nothing else to keep the laws the same. One example would be H&R block, which was created by a complex tax code and works very hard to keep it that way. As for the tragedy of the commons, if your mining operation negatively impacts mine by messing up a shared resource, I can sue you right away. The lack of a legal framework doesn't mean that everything is legal, at least under US tradition; it means that the civil courts decide.
- throwaway2048 7y agoWho do i sue over global warming?
- ajmurmann 7y ago> As for the tragedy of the commons, if your mining operation negatively impacts mine by messing up a shared resource, I can sue you right away. The lack of a legal framework doesn't mean that everything is legal, at least under US tradition; it means that the civil courts decide. This is only true though for direct damages that ideally are measurable in a monetary value. Are there cases where it helped keeping goods in the commons. I for one would love to sue everyone who fishes in the ocean because I'd rather watch the fish and sleep well at night knowing the ocean isn't being ruined. Simpler and less controversial example would be pollution of the air we are all breathing.
- ls612 7y agoThe good news is that most of these commons issues are related to ecosystems on earth, which are blissfully absent in space.
- ajmurmann 7y agoI'm curious to see if or how long that will hold true. We already have been seeing outcry over light pollution caused by SpaceX massive satellite formation.
- milesskorpen 7y agoJurisdiction might prove a challenge here (state/federal courts?) but we already deal with this kind of things on oceans so I'm sure we'll muddle through like we usually do.
- kuschku 7y agoThat’s one legal concept, and one that’s consistent with common law: law is made through court rulings and decisions. But it’s not the only legal concept, nor the most dominant or best, and in civil law systems, it’s required that all law be available and readable for free for the public, which means law has to be written into laws, and can’t be defined through court rulings.
- staticautomatic 7y agoThe U.S. has both statutory and common law. They're not mutually exclusive.
- kuschku 7y agoTrue, but in civil law systems, with minor exceptions, only statutory law counts. Why should the US system dominate in space? Another question is: why should the US decide what happens in space? That’s quite an imperialistic view on the world.
- why_only_15 7y agostaticautomatic isn't saying the US system should necessarily be dominant, they're just pointing out that the two systems aren't mutually exclusive.
- kuschku 7y agoI’m not saying they are, but it is a question that presents itself given the context.
- staticautomatic 7y agoI'm not saying it should. I'm just saying that we don't face a choice between one or the other.
- simonh 7y agoFrom a practical point of view, it's likely that much space law will be decided by the countries that send stuff into space. That seems reasonable since they have a clear vested interest in protecting their citizens, the possessions of their citizens and regulating the activities of their citizens. That's not really imperialism, just a matter of responsibility. Clearly the US and any other space going nation should be held responsible for the activities of it's citizens and enterprises in space as elsewhere, and has responsibilities towards them as well. Where that line of reasoning reaches the end of it's tether is when we come to consider property rights over pre-existing assets and territory in space.
- rhcom2 7y ago> Could you imagine how bad it would be if Congress got excited about the potential for internet crime in 1985, tried to guess the form of the problems that would arise, and then wrote laws banning and permitting things that they thought would lead to trouble? Didn't they try to do that with 1984's Computer Fraud and Abuse Act?
- moftz 7y agoBreaking into computer systems was already something that was happening then. Maybe they went a little overboard with the wording but it's not like Congress invented hacking.
- DuskStar 7y agoInstead, they outlawed visiting google.com (by a strict reading of "unauthorized access")
- bpchaps 7y agoA little overbroad is somewhat of an understatement..
- wyldfire 7y ago> Maybe they went a little overboard with the wording but it's not like Congress invented hacking. Believe it or not but CFAA would likely have not come about if not for the classic film "WarGames" [1]. [1] https://books.google.com/books?id=7rBLCZuEOswC&pg=PA38&lpg=PA38 https://books.google.com/books?id=7rBLCZuEOswC&pg=PA38&lpg=P...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- stcredzero 7y agoCould you imagine how bad it would be if Congress got excited about the potential for internet crime in 1985, tried to guess the form of the problems that would arise, and then wrote laws banning and permitting things that they thought would lead to trouble? About as well as Korea's government picking the crypto businesses should use in 1996: https://www.forbes.com/sites/elaineramirez/2016/11/30/south-koreas-online-banking-system-is-stuck-in-1996/#7e889584527c https://www.forbes.com/sites/elaineramirez/2016/11/30/south-...
- T-A 7y ago> The best way to deal with space would probably be to let judges stretch earth law Step 0: Which ones? US judges? Chinese judges? Maybe Saudi ones?
- dd36 7y agoIs it much different than the laws of the sea? Sometimes laws spur innovation. If the law is: first one to establish a base owns it then there will be a lot of effort put into establishing a base.
- elihu 7y agoThen the question becomes: what counts as a "base" and how much of the surrounding land or other relevant resources are deemed to belong to the base? Personally, I think land ownership claims around unmanned probes, rovers, and stationary facilities should be kept small, and claims around manned homesteads should not be more than about a mile radius or so, probably less. In the beginning, I think it's good to have policies that encourage settlements with different owners to be located close together, without anyone becoming a real-estate baron. The best land should go to those who have the ability to actually use it, not real-estate speculators. See also: https://xkcd.com/2125/ https://xkcd.com/2125/ as an example of how land claims shouldn't work.
- dd36 7y agoYea, I would say continuous occupation by natural persons for a certain amount of time.
- fuzzfactor 7y agoAccording to one of the earliest space lawyers in the '80's, maritime law is largely the foundation.
- crsv 7y agoCould you imagine how bad it would be if Congress got excited about the potential for internet crime in 1985, tried to guess the form of the problems that would arise, and then wrote laws banning and permitting things that they thought would lead to trouble? There is no way somebody back then could predict which situations would lead to trouble decades later. You mean like everyone who's talking about AI policy right now?
- themacguffinman 7y agoIt's just as ridiculous to do so in AI.
- JoeSamoa 7y agoThere have been people who have predicted exactly the direction we are headed like Richard Stallman. I think though that the number of people with that kind of vision and foresight are few.
- dahfizz 7y ago> I think though that the number of people with that kind of vision and foresight are few. It also often comes from domain experts, and almost never from politicians.
- m463 7y agoIt might be interesting to see what RMS is predicting right now. I have a friend who participates in superforecasting. I should pay more attention.
- chromeguy66 7y agoThis seems like the classic case of common law against civil law.
- m463 7y ago> let judges stretch earth law (property rights, whatever) Time to churn out those cornucopia machines.