5 ms·
I don't want to get too political here, but the propagation of Alex-Jones-esque conspiracy can be very influential to a larger-than-it-should-be percentage of t
by tombert 7y ago
I don't want to get too political here, but the propagation of Alex-Jones-esque conspiracy can be very influential to a larger-than-it-should-be percentage of the population, who will vote in demagogues who perpetuate these narratives.
- bijsv 7y agoThe opposite of Alex Jones is not virtue and knowledge, but Alex-Jones-of-the-opposing-political-side
- bastawhiz 7y agoSorry, what's the opposing-political-side of "Sandy Hook was a hoax"? Or "Hillary Clinton is a pedophile operating out of the basement of a pizza restaurant"? The notion that all speech has an opposite but equally-biased counterpart is simply not correct.
- bijsv 7y agoI'm not American but I've read laughable things like "trump is a russian agent", "children are being kept in concentration camps at the border", and more I can't be bothered to remember. You have to understand that these beliefs (the ones you and I have described) are held by almost nobody. And only very crazy people are going to act violently about them. And they would eventually find any other excuse to act violently.
- fzeroracer 7y agoExcept we literally are holding children in squalid conditions at our borders. This is well documented. Whether or not they're concentration camps depends on how strongly you feel about child abuse.
- FakeComments 7y agoThe argument is legitimate media is no better: - Supporting Jussie Smollett - Supporting the Antifa ambushes on Andy Ngo and ICE in the NW - Defaming the Covington kids All cases in recent history, where the media has either supported terrorism or been reckless in their reporting. You want to talk about conspiracy theories, while the media perpetuates racist hoaxes and armed terrorism? Why shut down Alex Jones, and his nutty claims, just to support that kind of media? Who gets to decide that Alex Jones should be an unperson, but beating Andy Ngo is okay? Is it Google? The traditional media? Whatever harm the conspiracies cause, fighting against the social engineering lies from traditional media is a higher priority.
- ralusek 7y agoIf you have such little faith in your fellow citizens' decision making capabilities, isn't your argument really just a criticism of democracy? You only trust them to vote, if they're going to vote according to a narrow band of acceptable thought. At that point, you're really just tyrannical, the democracy is an illusion.
- sabertoothed 7y agoDemocracy requires a functional education system. It's not about "a narrow band of acceptable thought". The truth matters.
- ralusek 7y agoI didn't realize the truth was so simple, and a matter of education. Is an unborn fetus a person or a cluster of cells? Is a transgender woman a woman or a man approximating phenotypical gender characteristics of a woman? Is sex under 18 capable of consent? Under 16? Under 14? In Spain it was 13 until only a few years ago, where is "the truth?" Prostitution, gambling, drugs? Truth? Almost all of the most contentious issues are not unresolved because of a lack of education, they're unresolved because of inherent moral conflicts worthy of negotiation. (Age of consent isn't really contentious, I just wanted to show something that most people consider to be obvious or a given not being necessarily resolvable). If we were to simply convince more people that a woman's right to bodily autonomy supercedes the unborn's right to live, or vice versa, we would have only really succeeded in indoctrination. Neither position is "truthful," it's always just an arbitrary moral elevation of one violation of consent over another. I think the only issue even close to approximating the simplicity you've described would be climate change, but even then there is a wide chasm between the role people believe that the state should play.
- buildzr 7y agoThat's their choice then. We have to have believe that a majority of our fellow citizens are by and large capable of overcoming such views otherwise democracy itself is a failed concept. Censoring their content to bias their political views in a way you like is... extremist at best.
- tombert 7y agoOk, I'm a little tired of this constantly coming up; it's not a political position to rebut something that is objectively incorrect. If Party A bases its platform on the idea that "All Circles Are Secretly Squares", this is objectively false, and me saying so isn't me "biasing their political views in a way I like", it's a simple matter of fact. The earth is not flat. This is relatively easy to prove, but people can be influenced by the right rhetoric, and they vote. I'm not saying that people shouldn't be allowed to believe in dumb things from a legal perspective, I just don't think they're entitled to a platform. Would you apply this logic to ISIS recruitment videos? "It's their choice! YouTube shouldn't pull their videos because if they do democracy has failed as a concept!"
- buildzr 7y ago> I'm a little tired of this constantly coming up Perhaps then you shouldn't have made it into a political position by suggesting that they'd all vote for a specific candidate. > This is relatively easy to prove, but people can be influenced by the right rhetoric, and they vote. It's a bit of a trusting trust exercise - you can prove it in a way that satisfies you, but that doesn't necessarily satisfy everyone. > Would you apply this logic to ISIS recruitment videos? Much more debatable because ISIS videos encourage outright violence.
- tombert 7y agoI didn't say they'd all vote for a specific candidate, but based on what you're telling me, this is the logical conclusion: 1) People don't vote based on their beliefs, 2) Beliefs can't be wrong, 3) A vote based on a wrong belief can't lead to an undesirable candidate.