5 ms·
I think people think the "Merry Christmas $name" email is not spam (it looks like a message from a friend), so they open and read. "Happy Holidays" is somethin
by jrockway 16y ago
I think people think the "Merry Christmas $name" email is not spam (it looks like a message from a friend), so they open and read. "Happy Holidays" is something that only people trying to sell you something say, so you mentally filter that email.
The conversion rate is just a depressing example of how people will buy anything you tell them to. Once you get people to read your email, you'll much more likely to convert. (You get Viagra spam because somebody clicks it and buys.)
This is basically why I give everyone a unique email address, and /dev/null the address after I stop needing it. People like the author of this post try to abuse my attention, and that is not OK with me.
- jordan0day 16y agoWhile I very much agree with your sentiment (email marketing is usually a bad thing), this article seems like a small example of "psychological hacking" and I hate to admit how interesting this sort of thing really is. It frightens me to know that there are people who spend as much time optimizing the performance of their marketing messages as we do on algorithms. The key difference (at least this is what I tell myself) is that while my work improves the actual product, the marketers work does no such thing.
- space-monkey 16y agoTwo thoughts: For many consumer products, the value of the product is the experience created by the product in conjunction with the marketing. I think hackers tend to focus to exclusion on "core" or "objective" value. If the consumer market thought like that, everyone would be buying off-brand cola. Second, I would imagine there's at least one order of magnitude more effort going into marketing optimization than there is into computer algorithms.
- nitrogen 16y agoEven after reading HN for 662 days now, I still have to force myself to concede that not everyone is motivated by product quality or code cleverness. It still feels immoral to me for a company to sell an inferior product with superior marketing, but I have to ask myself: "Who am I to argue with what people want?" Or, more technically, "Who am I to argue with the neurochemistry of the majority of the population?"
- klbarry 16y agoMarketers work does improve the actual product, in the eye of the consumer. Intangible value is still value!
- patio11 16y agoPreach it, brother! If your stuff will improve someone's life, not hearing about it is the most severe bug you can think of!
- bigiain 16y agoIf you keep thinking that way, you're doing yourself a great disservice. No matter _how_ great your algorithms are, without letting people know about it, you won't sell anything. Like everywhere else, 90% of everything is crap and "marketing" is no exception, but how many bingo cards do you suppose Patrick would have sold if he wasn't greatly skilled at some oft-disparaged disciplines like SEO and email marketing? Marketing done wrong is just as useless as all the programming done wrong you laugh at on Daily WTF. If you think you can run a profitable startup while religiously _not_ doing "marketing", I think you're wrong. I'd love to hear how you pitch that philosophy to investors though....
- jordan0day 16y agoHey, I said it was evil... I never said it wasn't a necessary evil. Obviously having salesmen is just the way the world works, and just like how libertarianism, communism, and utopian markets could all work in an ideal world, I recognize that's not the world we live in.
- dkokelley 16y agoPeople like the author of this post try to abuse my attention, and that is not OK with me. What does 'abuse my attention' mean to you? Is it unsolicited (spam) email, or just any form of marketing/promotion in general? This is an important point to address for startup founders who often rely on obtaining and nurturing attention relationships with their users.
- rorymarinich 16y agoWhen you email me, that means that you update one of the only two applications on my Dock that's programmed to show a number — and the other one is a To Do application. Is your email as important as my to-do list telling me what I've got due today? If not, don't send it. When you email me, that means you update one of the only three applications on my Phone that are enabled to show me a number — and the other two are my phone app and my texting app. Would you TEXT me this announcement? Or would you CALL MY PHONE about this announcement? If not, don't send it. When I get emails, I expect them to be from either friends or from clients. I like my friends enough to want to see the things they send to me ASAP; I want to hear immediately from clients so that I can respond to them at four in the morning (if I'm up anyway, that is). Know who I don't want interrupting my workflow? You. If you're looking to get my attention because you've got a new feature or you generally just want me to come back to you, then come up with a way to make me want your reminder. Have me become a fan of you on Facebook, so that you can push to my feed. Have me follow you on Twitter. Publish your story to Hacker News, and make sure it's good enough that I'll notice it and check it out again. Get a blog and push your updates to me through RSS. But when you email me, you're being a jackass.
- nitrogen 16y agoIf you use unique e-mail addresses like the GP (jrockway), you could funnel all potentially-obnoxious mail into a separate folder that doesn't trigger notifications. At least, that works with gmail on my Android phone. It's unreasonable for everyone who wants to e-mail you to predict that you have an aggressive notification system.
- 16y ago
- dminor 16y agoThat's all well and good for unsolicited email, but for those of us who have lists of people who have signed up to receive email from us, this sort of thing is terribly relevant. And if you're selling things online and aren't creating these lists, you're leaving a bunch of money on the table.
- patio11 16y agoI sold a few hundred dollars of BCC with an email whose subject line was "Merry Christmas from Bingo Card Creator" It went to somewhere like 1,500 teachers who had previously expressed an interest in playing educational bingo and asked for a monthly email newsletter reminding them about activities they would probably like. The content is pretty predictable: it is almost Christmas, you're busy, here's something which takes one thing off your plate for only $29.95. In what way is this abusing their confidence? P.S. For folks who are curious about possible ways to address diverse customers without compromising one's very non-diverse principles: http://us1.campaign-archive.com/?u=77a3e522d2bf02ea858d2316c&id=5501383926&e=[UNIQID] http://us1.campaign-archive.com/?u=77a3e522d2bf02ea858d2316c...
- spitfire 16y agoJust one point about your wording. " It is easy, scales to any number of players, and..." sounds very uh, odd for the subject. I'm not sure teachers are thinking about scaling and Big-O, are they? It tripped me up while I was reading it.
- sanswork 16y agoTeachers definitely have to think about scale. The number of tasks you can effectively do with 5 students is a lot larger than the number you can do with 30 students.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 16y agoLike I said, I don't doubt that it's effective. I, 0.001% of your non-userbase, don't like it. I don't care if people spam my grandma. Just don't spam me!
- wensing 16y agoI think his point is that at some point it isn't right to call it spam. Double opt-in mailing lists for a product or service that you enjoy isn't spam.
- evgeny0 16y agoThis is basically why I give everyone a unique email address, and /dev/null the address after I stop needing it. Offtopic, but what service do you use for this email redirection setup? Or do you run your own mail server? I do exactly the same thing, currently using MyDomain.com, but looking for a better alternative.