7 ms·
Some Traits of Bismarck (1882)
- smacktoward 7y ago> The greatest statesman of the age, he was also recognized as the most characteristic of Germans, — the type as well as hero of the nation; a combination of Luther, Goedtz von Berlichingen, and Marshal Vorwaerts If the "Marshal Vorwaerts" bit of this seems obscure, it's a reference to a common nickname for one of the German generals who had fought against and eventually defeated Napoléon, Gebhard von Blücher (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gebhard_Leberecht_von_Bl%C3%BCcher https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gebhard_Leberecht_von_Bl%C3%BC...). Blücher was an aggressive, the-best-defense-is-a-good-offense general, so his troops, whom he was always urging to move forwards, forwards, nicknamed him "Marshal Forwards."
- michalu 7y agoMarshal Blücher was an impressive figure. At the time of Waterloo he was 72 years old, right at the beginning of the encounter he instantly launched a cavalry attack on Napoleon which he led himself in the front! Think of the average 72 year old today. He got injured and pushed back, only to later save Wellington from defeat. Wellington later called Waterloo the "the nearest run thing you ever saw in your life."
- ghaff 7y ago(1882) Sorry :-) One salient thing that the article touches on in various ways that would become extremely relevant about 30 years later is that Bismarck spun an extremely complicated web of alliances and relationships that arguably he perhaps uniquely could hold together. And he wasn't around any longer when things ultimately broke down.
- dang 7y agoYear added. Thanks!
- nf05papsjfVbc 7y agoThis sounds very much like a few programmers I know/knew except that the alliances and relationships were between bits of code and/or infrastructure.
- smacktoward 7y agoBismarck also had the good sense to realize that if Germany expanded too much too fast, it would prompt the rest of Europe to join together in order to cut it down to size, the same way as had been done to Napoléon's France. The logic of Europe's multipolar balance of power would not allow any one state to grow too dominant, at least not without it having to first win a hell of a fight. Two world wars would later be fought because Bismarck's successors did not understand this fact as well as he had.
- pasabagi 7y agoIf your code base requires a genius to keep it running, it's shitty code. I don't know how much Bismark is to blame for this (probably not very), but I don't really see it as a point in his favour that the whole thing fell apart the minute he left the building.
- nn3 7y agoReplace the minute with 30 years. Also I think it was more a case of William II being a moron, and his advisors just not being very good. And I don't think for WW1 (unlike WW2) anybody's goal was to expand. It was more a case of everybody being too fearful of each other, creating a vicious circle of more and more armament, which eventually developed its own dynamic and finally spiraled out of control, leading to the war.
- pasabagi 7y agoI think instability is the natural state for a group of nations that are generally dictatorships, generally pursuing a 'realist' foreign policy. It's also been obvious since ancient history that the problem with dictatorships is that the next dictator can be an absolute moron, madman, or monster. Still, as a thought experiment, imagine what Germany could have done to avoid WW1. I think it would be hard - but I also think it would have been pretty much the opposite of what Bismark did. A good start would be to abolish or at least weaken the monarchy. Monarchy is like playing high-stakes poker where every round you take an unknown class-A drug. Another good start would be to pursue a internationalist foreign policy, try and build coalitions, trust, etc.