7 ms·
“I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: 1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is
by teddyh 7y ago
“I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies:
1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works.
2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it.
3. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things.”
― Douglas Adams, The Salmon of Doubt
- whatshisface 7y agoDoes that mean someone born in 2008 will think C++ is simple and elegant?
- philipov 7y agoNo, the claim is that it's ordinary and just part of the way the world works.
- golergka 7y agoGood point. I think it should be rephrased in basis of personal familiarity: people who learned C++ before they were 15 indeed think that it's simple and elegant.
- mianos 7y agoI am both a Python programmer and a C++ programmer. I have programmed professionally full time in one or the other for years at a time. I think C++ is now a much better language than when I learnt it first (cfront). In particular C++11 really fixed a lot of the memory issues with shared_ptr and std:: algorithms. It is a better language now if you are doing anything larger than then a program that takes more than a few weeks to write. On the other hand, I love python for everything else and some of the new stuff is great but making a new way to print strings over and over tells me some people have too much spare time or not enough real work to do. In my opinion formatting a string to print a debug statement should be as concise as possible whereas a lot of these fancier formatting systems are better suited to stuff that ends up staying for use by other people. Luckily there are ways to use ye olde printf style formatters in both for those times.
- 59nadir 7y agoC++ might be "better" now (I doubt it, to be honest, it just has more features that try to fix the issue at hand; that you're using C++), but it will never, ever get simpler or simple enough. They'd have to remove something like 75% of the language to end up with something that approaches simplicity and even then there are languages that would undoubtedly do those remaining 25% much better. I stopped writing C++ at some point in 2008/2009 but I still keep track of it to some extent and I'm continually surprised by the nonsense that is introduced into the language. The whole RAII movement, for example, is just one massive band-aid on top of the previous mistake of allowing exceptions, etc.. It'd be mostly fine in the long run, but you have all these people using like 15% of C++ and complain about it all day long, making their libraries not usable from stuff that understands C (most of which have drastically improved on the whole paradigm). There's a solution here and it's not using whichever arbitrary percentage you've decided on of C++, it's realizing that there are way better languages with real interoperability in mind to talk about lower-level things.
- stakhanov 7y agoIt's wrong to frame this as resistance to change for no reason. See my other comment. I see some of this stuff as repeating mistakes that were made in the design of Perl. ...but there are quite few people around these days who know Perl well enough to recognize the way in which history is repeating itself, and that has at least something to do with age.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- knome 7y ago"resistance-to-change for-no-reason" vs "resistance-to change-for-no-reason" :)
- mr_crankypants 7y agoBoth of which, it's worth noting, are painfully obvious and uncharitable strawmen.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DangitBobby 7y agoThis is possibly the best example of the ambiguity of language I've ever seen. Two contradictory meanings expressed in the exact same phrase, and both of them are valid in the broader context.
- ByThyGrace 7y agoJeez. What number of people who read the same phrase with either of those two meanings then continue to form opinions and even make decisions based on the resulting meaning?
- mr_crankypants 7y agoMe, I am old enough to know Perl, and I've got plenty of one-line skeletons in my own closet. And it more-or-less entered the world already vastly more TMTOWTDI-y than Python is after 3 decades. FWIW, I tend to think of comparisons to Perl as being a lot like Nazi comparisons, only for programming languages. And I do think there's some wisdom to the Godwin's Law idea that the first person to make a Nazi comparison is understood to have automatically lost the argument. It's just that, at this point, Perl is both so near-universally reviled, and so well-understood to be way too optimized for code golf, that any comparison involving it is kind of a conversation-killer. As soon as it shows up, your best options are to either quietly ignore the statement in which the comparison was made, or join in escalating things into a flamewar.
- bacon_waffle 7y agoThe point #1 is expanded on in Feral by George Monbiot. Basically, we have a tendency to see the outside world we grew up with as the way things naturally should be, ignoring that previous generations may have changed it to be that way. That sheep-grazed pastoral landscape is easy to view as a thing worth preserving, but to an ecologist it might be a barren waste where there used to be a beautiful forest.
- mehrdadn 7y agoI don't think it's just >35-year-olds who find what's going on in Python against the natural order of things?
- orangecat 7y agoConversely, some of us oldsters think the outrage is way overblown.
- tachyonbeam 7y agoI'm 34 and I don't like this, so it's definitely not only those above 35. Jokes aside, I would say I'm a minimalist and this is where my resistance comes from. One of the things that I dislike the most in programming is feature creep. I prefer smaller languages. I like the idea of having a more minimal feature set that doesn't change very much. In a language with less features, you might have to write slightly more code, but the code you write will be more readable to everyone else. Said language should also be easier to learn. IMO, the more complex a system is, the more fragile it tends to become. The same is true for programming languages. Features will clash with each other. You'll end up having 10 different ways to achieve the same thing, and it won't be obvious which direction to go. Furthermore, I did my grad studies in compilers. I've thought about writing an optimizing JIT for Python. I really feel like CPython is needlessly slow, and it's kind of embarassing, in an age where single-core performance is reaching a plateau, to waste so many CPU cycles interpreting a language. We have the technology to do much better. However, the fact that Python is a fast moving target makes it very difficult to catch up. If Python were a smaller, more stable language, this wouldn't be so difficult.
- Scarbutt 7y agoFurthermore, I did my grad studies in compilers. I've thought about writing an optimizing JIT for Python. I really feel like CPython is needlessly slow, and it's kind of embarassing, Many have tried and failed, Google and Dropbox to name a couple, and countless other attempts.
- tachyonbeam 7y ago
- ineedasername 7y ago* Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works.* Yep, I entered the Python world with v2. I eventually reconciled myself to 2.7, and have only recently and begrudgingly embraced 3. Being over 35, I must be incredibly open minded on these things.
- dual_basis 7y agoI am an example which supports this notion. I've done some Python programming about 10 years ago but then took a break from programming altogether for the last 9 years. Last year I got back into it and have been using Python 3.7, and I personally love all the most recent stuff. I hate having to go back to 3.5 or even 3.6, and I end up pulling in stuff from futures.
- tialaramex 7y agoForewarned is forearmed. I headed into adulthood watching out for such mirages. For example: Making sure to listen to pop music enough that it does exactly what pop music is supposed to do (worm its way into your subconscious) so I don't wake up one morning unaccountably believing that Kylie Minogue was good but Taylor Swift isn't. My understanding of Python will probably never be quite as good as my understanding of C, but I can live with that.
- owl57 7y agoHow do you know to listen to Taylor Swift or whatever? In the last century it was easy to be in sync: you could just watch MTV. Is there something keeping the notion of pop coherent these days?
- joshbode 7y agoNot exactly pop, but there are some great weekly music podcasts that I listen to to hear new music, which tend to be a little more indie pop/rock/${genre} than pop :) - Music That Matters: https://omny.fm/shows/kexp-presents-music-that-matters/playlists/podcast.rss https://omny.fm/shows/kexp-presents-music-that-matters/playl... - KEXP Song of the Day: https://omny.fm/shows/kexp-song-of-the-day https://omny.fm/shows/kexp-song-of-the-day - All Songs Considered: https://www.npr.org/rss/podcast.php?id=510019 https://www.npr.org/rss/podcast.php?id=510019 - KCRW Today's Top Tune: https://www.kcrw.com/music/shows/todays-top-tune/rss.xml https://www.kcrw.com/music/shows/todays-top-tune/rss.xml
- freehunter 7y agoApple/Google Music or Spotify or Pandora all have pop playlists that play the current top 100 songs on rotation. The Billboard Hot 100 also lists popular western music if you just want a list to review on your own. I’d argue it’s easier now to stay in sync than even when MTV was popular. MTV you needed a cable subscription and be sitting at a TV, now SiriusXM or Apple/Google/Spotify can stream it right to your phone laptop or tablet, and regular FM radio will play it on the local Top 40 station.
- voldacar 7y agoNo, those aren't really the reasons for my reaction. And if I told you my age, you would probably switch your argument and say that I'm far too young to criticize ;)
- cameronbrown 7y agoExcept that Python existed before I was born and I still appreciate the concept of 'Pythonic'. The language should stay true to its roots.
- throw2016 7y agoThis 'resistance to change' catchall argument puts everything beyond criticism, and it can be used/abused in every case of criticism. It seeks to reframe 'change' from a neutral word - change can be good or bad - to a positive instead of focusing on the specifics. Anyone making this argument should be prepared to to accept every single criticism they make in their life moving forward can be framed as 'their resistance to change'. This kind of personalization of specific criticism is disingenuous and political and has usually been used as a PR strategy to push through unpopular decisions. Better to respond to specific criticisms than reach for a generic emotional argument that seeks to delegitimize scrutiny and criticism.
- teddyh 7y agoTrue, but this was not “specific criticism”. It was a general dismissing criticism without details, and so can be refuted with a similarly detail-less answer. A detailed criticism deserves a reasoned and detailed answer, but vague criticism gets a generic rebuttal.