8 ms·
The Rise and Fall of French Cuisine
- taiwanboy 7y agoI could be starting a food war here but I dare declare that California has the best cuisines in the world because 1.) for many of the ethnicities, california usually has the largest immigrant communities, outside of the native country. Therefore the dishes can be much more authentic and cater to the native crowds. As opposed to a Greek restaurant in Tokyo, or a Thai restaurant in Paris. When I lived in Japan I often missed my Vietnamese pho. And when i lives in Paris I often craved for my Mexican burrito. 2.) it doesn’t have any food history, and therefore no codified rules on how and what cuisines should be ( as opposed to French cuisine, like mentioned in the article ). Therefore we have Californian sushi, Korean tacos, Japanese pastas, Korean hot dogs, and so on. Fusion and innovation is alive and well 3.) fifth largest economy in the world that helps to support diverse and vibrant restaurants, farms and foodies 4.) real focus on vegan cuisines. If you were a vegan you would be blessed to live in la or sf. You would be able to not just be able to get vegan but also Vietnamese vegan, Thai vegan, American vegan or Japanese vegan cuisines. If you tried backpacking through Asia or Europe as a vegan you would know how hard that is. Michelin guide recently released a California guide and California is now on the map as a foodie destination. Even though it only has 90 Michelin restaurants as opposed to Japan’s 230, I have way more fun dining in la or sf than Tokyo due to the diverse ness and casualness of the cuisines. (But Tokyo will always have a place in my heart on how perfectly executed a single ingredient/dish could be)
- umeshunni 7y ago4. Fresh vegetables, meat and dairy from nearby farms. When I moved here from the Pacific Northwest, I was surprised as to how much fresher and tastier the fruits and vegetables here were compared to Seattle.
- JJMcJ 7y agoThe Central Valley, where most of the US's vegetables and fruits come from, is just hours away from the Bay Area, so it's fresher than anywhere else. Even imports, Mexico, Chile, New Zealand, usually arrive in California and so are freshest here.
- Xcelerate 7y ago> Fresh vegetables, meat and dairy from nearby farms. You'd think so, but I've found so many bad fruits and vegetables at Safeway and Whole Foods in Redwood City that I've pretty much given up on getting my produce from there. Local family run markets like Sigona's and Draeger's are much better quality, even if they are a bit more expensive. I'm not sure how the big supermarkets manage to screw up the relatively short supply chain from farms that are just a few hours away.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- CriticalCathed 7y agoPoint 3 (lots of newly rich wanting to experience fine things) combined with a tentative point 5 lots of local agriculture leading to fresh vegetables are what convince me this is largely true. 1, 2, and 4 are all done better on the east coast, in my opinion.
- BlackJack 7y agoI think you want to say California has the best restaurants/food vs. "California cuisine is the best cuisine". Of course SF/Bay has some of the best restaurants in the world with French Laundry, Atelier Crenn, Benu, Saison, etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_cuisine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_cuisine California cuisine is a food movement that originated in California. The cuisine focuses on dishes that are driven by local and sustainable ingredients with an attention to seasonality and an emphasis on the bounty of the region
- contingencies 7y agoGood points. I rank Bangkok world #1 food city, however. Has the immigrant communities but also a broader range of produce (including tropical), more authentic cuisine, lower costs, more dynamism, broad socioeconomic spectrum, etc. Did a food crawl there a couple of years ago, happy to do an HN one! Plenty of vegan and vegeterian options.
- jtms 7y agoI’d be hard pressed to argue with you - the street food alone blows away almost everything else anywhere
- solidsnack9000 7y agoThis is sadly not true, and I think your final sentence is a clue about that. One problem faced by California is the importation (from other states) of HENRYs (high-earning-not-rich-yet) who neither understand the fresh-and-local CaliFrench or CalItalian aesthetic, or any other cuisine either. It’s led to a lot of restaurants springing up that pretend to offer the same kind of fresh experience, but are really just terrible. The Grove in the Bay Area is an example of such a restaurant. Ultimately, it is educated consumers that lead to great food — without the demand side of the equation, the supply side whithers. Tokyo surprises not only by offering excellent traditional Japanese items like sushi, onigiri and hashed beef, but also by having pancakes, pizzas and little selections of bratwursts that are world class. This is not because of a diverse population — there are no Italians behind the counter making the pizzas — but because of a very picky and educated consumer base that demands wholesome and authentic food. California’s consumer base isn’t really growing in the right ways, and the downstream effects of that are food that ultimately worse, even as the packaging of “California” gets better.
- isegrim 7y agoI concur! Similarly, Taiwan is stellar when it comes to experiencing the microcosms of Chinese cuisine(s)—Fujianese, Cantonese, etc.
- dwighttk 7y agoToo many “fall of”s in the title
- _nhynes 7y agoWell, the article does end on a positive note, so maybe we’re nearing the winter of the fall of French cuisine ;)
- Syzygies 7y agoYes, it's distracting. I imagine a review on nymag's site, explaining the "immediacy" that comes from mods leaving such obvious errors unfixed. Or, a discussion of roads and traffic. Build bigger roads, congestion gets worse. Mods didn't sign up for this, grammar police! If they fix this one, we'll all get lazier about checking our titles, and the situation gets worse not better. This could be explained by the Lotka–Volterra "preditor prey" equations? No, make a mistake in a title, you have to wear it. Like leaving a baseball pitcher out there, behind 16-3, to "take on for the team".
- dang 7y agoHow'd we miss that? That was a "Paris in the the Spring". Fixed now, thanks! (Submitted title was "The Rise and Fall of Fall of French Cuisine")
- djrobstep 7y ago> Australians had established Italian coffee bars and you could finally get a decent cappuccino. A fun parallel here to the classic startup story where the megacorp stagnates while ex-employees leave to create a startup that does it better and eventually beats the megacorp at its own game. Italian immigrants brought a love of coffee with them to Australia, but that's developed into a culture and standard of coffee that's better than the original, that's now being exported back. I live in Melbourne, and was surprised on first visiting Italy and France that the coffee was utterly inferior. Same with the US: There's certainly decent coffee to be found, but you have to seek it out, rather than taking it for granted as ubiquitous everywhere.
- tvanantwerp 7y agoI think I first heard the idea via Alton Brown that, if you want a really good {cuisine X}, don't go to the place famous for it. The source location, once famous, will get a bit lazy and not put in the effort like they used to. Example he gave: don't go to Buffalo for Buffalo wings. Example from my own experience: don't go to the famous Philly cheesesteak places in Philly for a good Philly cheesesteak.
- rbritton 7y agoI think this is absolutely correct. The cheesesteak I had at one of the allegedly original places was the worst I’ve ever had anywhere. A fast food cheesesteak is better. Similarly, Seaside is a major beach/ocean tourist destination in Oregon. It has some of the worst seafood restaurants I’ve ever been at, and I think laziness is the reason.
- barry-cotter 7y agoTyler Cowen’s guide to finding good food in America boils down to “If there’s something about this restaurant that makes it more pleasant that isn’t about the food that’s weak evidence the food isn’t that good” If the interior decor is good, or the location is convenient or in a hip neighbourhood, or the wait staff are young and attractive, or the service is impeccable they have something going on that isn’t just about the food. If the only thing they’re selling is good food then it’s going to be good because there’s no other reason to go there.
- primroot 7y ago> “But isn’t the point to taste the chicken?” Furious and foreign, I replied: “No! It’s just the opposite! Cooking is about messing with the chicken! Cooking is about adding flavour!” One cannot blame people for wanting to add flavor to the meat of a sick animal. I feel sad for her never having had the chance to taste a happy chicken. No amount of cooking can compensate for the lack of good ingredients. Natural ruin can be fertile soil for human creativity.
- mensetmanusman 7y agoThis reminds me of an article describing how bad restaurant food in San Francisco is getting because housing inequality is so high that all the food-prep workers are getting pushed out of the cities. You can’t have head chefs commuting four hours a day to cook you fish... I could believe this is happening in Paris as well.
- i_am_nomad 7y agoI’d love to read that article if you could tell us where to find it (seems like it might be tricky to Bing for it).
- devoply 7y agoButta boom butta bing. How about calling it Boom? Nope it will be Bing.. But boom is so much... I have made up my mind.
- mensetmanusman 7y agohttps://thebolditalic.com/why-sf-restaurants-are-suffocating-795392211c66 https://thebolditalic.com/why-sf-restaurants-are-suffocating... NYT also reported on the topic.
- i_am_nomad 7y agoThanks!
- 7y ago
- lanrh1836 7y agoPerhaps I made some classic tourist mistake, but when I was in Paris last year I felt like every mid-priced French bistro was extremely mediocre and overpriced. Menus all the same and food did not taste fresh at all. Wine bad too.
- Bayart 7y agoThere are tons of great places, just not along tourist-channeling roads. It's honestly just a function of rent. You can't be on a really nice spot and give good value in Paris. It's impossible. But yeah bistro-type place tend to be pretty mediocre in particular, they're much better in Lyon for example. Just ask someone who lives there next time, you'll get appropriate feedback. They know "the good places". Actually do that for every major city you're going on vacation to. It works the same everywhere.
- bayonetz 7y agoDepends on who you ask though. You have the equivalent of Applebee’s lovers in every country who will tell to go there. You also need to ask them some foodie shibboleths or you’re going to have a bad time.
- Infernal 7y agoDo you have recommendations for foodie shibboleths? The only one I can think of off the top of my head would be how they order their steak.
- isegrim 7y agoSteer clear of the fashionable, and pick their brains about simple foods. How carefully do they cook their pasta? what is their favorite family of cheeses? brand of tahini? etc. In my experience, when one obsesses about food, one sweats the small things that make a difference, and delights in them. Terroir, in other words.
- defterGoose 7y ago
- jillesvangurp 7y agoMy parents lived in France for a while after they retired; so I've been there many times as a visitor. They lived pretty far from Paris in the country side. Things have changed a lot in the past decades in France. For one thing, the French have somehow been enthusiastically embracing the north american concept of strip malls with huge super markets and fast food outlets with such names as Pizza Hut, Burger King, etc. as well as a few local variations of these. Most smaller cities have these at the edge of their town and the local retail sector has been struggling to compete. The food in these supermarkets is still pretty good but the food in these fast food outlets mostly isn't. The french are the proto-snobs; they pretty much invented the notion of snobbery and their cuisine is a big part of it. But it's an invented tradition and it's a very recent thing (at least their cuisine is). And indeed it is past it's glory and lot of the lower class French are growing up eating the same kind of junk food that everybody else is getting obese on. However, you could do worse in the French country side than going to some family run place that is frequented by the locals (as opposed to hordes of tourists). You'll be eating pretty decent food generally. This still exists and people are fiercely traditional when it comes to this stuff. But it's not as widespread as it used to be. But buying local produce is a thing and generally it is pretty good stuff given the climate and farming standards. The reality of food in France and elsewhere is that it is rooted in a long tradition that is based on history, people moving around and importing their traditions, and people discovering ingredients. E.g. tomatoes and potatoes are relatively recent additions to European cuisine and yet considered staples of local cooking across Europe now. For example, if you go to Italy, there is history dating back to the Roman era and earlier in some cases. Written history in this part of the world dates back more than two millennia. And Iran, formerly known as Persia, and formerly part of misc. historical empires has many thousands years of history. These places have interesting dishes that have been around in some form or another for thousands of years. And you can get them from all over the world in most decently large cities across the globe these days. Including Paris. I think this is pretty awesome. I love that you can go to the middle of nowhere in the Netherlands and find a few locals that are passionate about sushi or something similarly foreign and find a few decent places serving it. This was not a thing when I grew up in the eighties.
- baud147258 7y ago> some family run place that is frequented by the locals I ate in a restaurant like this in Normandy, not far from Camembert (yeah, it's also the name of a village) and we had a pretty good time. All the patrons were from the area and the cousin who showed up that place knew some of them. We even scored a few free drinks.
- hprotagonist 7y agoI’ve been in europe on travel and business for the past few weeks, and this may be entirely provincial and American of me, but the best meal i’ve had in a week was the €20 moroccan takeaway for four I had for dinner last night. The classic continental cuisines are good, and i’ve found good examples of them, but good lord i want something with hot sauce. Then a salad. And maybe a decent bagel.
- bsaul 7y agoFrench cuisine in Paris can be really good, but you need to know a few tips : - price doesn’t mean quality or taste or fresh. More often than not, location is almost the only thing that drives price. But even that could be random (some hipster places of the north of paris are both dirty, expensive, in a crap neighborhood, and not that good at all). - you need to find the right balance between hipster and tourist trap. If you’re in a very touristic area, favor extremely small restaurants ( 10 tables), where you feel that the owner is still passionate about his food, and can still get fresh ingredients. - if there are « plat du jour », pick in that list. Best is if there are only plat du jour and nothing else. - some touristic area are great for food, others are an absolute expensive crap, and they can be 200 meters away. Le marais is great, some streets of the 10th are great, but bastille is awfull. It can be pretty hard to guess from the outside. - finally, look at the menu. It’s really the best way to tell, but it requires experience. Too many meals is a bad sign, style (hand made, or nice font, or simply good looking and stylish) is also a good sign. Indication of things beeing hand made are also a good sign. All in all i’d say it’s pretty similar to french language : there are more exceptions than rules. Go look for something with an authentic feel ( as in you can feel the effort that was put in designing the place, and the owner’s personality), but try various things to build your intuition. Needless to say, quality of restaurants can change a lot with time. The good thing about all this, is that « knowing good places to eat » has real value in Paris, and after you found your first gem you’ll understand why parisians talk about restaurants with such passion when they meet.
- seszett 7y ago> French cuisine I'm French and I have no idea what "French cuisine" is. When picking a restaurant we would decide which kind of regional cuisine we'd like (when opting for French cuisine rather than something foreign). I don't live in Paris so it might be different, but I don't really think so. My favorite French-cuisine restaurants around my place were either Flemish, Breton or Réunionnais, but I don't know where I would go for "default French cuisine". Maybe some kind of tourist bistrot, but... well they feel like they're really just for tourists. Some of the luxury restaurants don't seem to have a regional identity, but they're above my means.
- 7y ago
- jinushaun 7y agoDining in Paris is a land mine for exactly the reasons stated in this article. You can’t really pop into a random restaurant in Paris and expect a good meal. I’ve been burned too many times in the past that every visit to Paris and France involves days and weeks of research for food that is better than mediocre. (Paris is usually the cheapest way to get to Europe which is why I go so often) Maybe it’s the proliferation of tourist traps. Maybe it’s stubbornness of sticking to the same old cuisine. It does feel like visiting a gastronomical museum.