4 ms·
I'd love to see how this applies to store brands and shelf placement in retail stores as well. I've noticed this comment constantly pop up on Amazon antitrust
by gamblor956 7y ago
I'd love to see how this applies to store brands and shelf placement in retail stores as well.
I've noticed this comment constantly pop up on Amazon antitrust discussions. It's not the same thing.
Retail stores buy the products they put on their shelves, at wholesale prices. They then mark up the prices to a retail price charged to the end buyer when they resell the products to the end buyer.
For store brands, the store still pays for the goods up front, but they're usually just buying white-label products from suppliers that don't need to make up for marketing expenses, and so the wholesale prices are cheaper.
There is no competitive concerns here because the product maker has already been paid for their goods.
Amazon isn't being investigated for the products it buys from its suppliers. It pays for those and so it can do whatever it wants. It's being investigated for the products it doesn't, i.e., the "Marketplace" of third-party sellers where Amazon is using its internal data gathered from the third-party sellers to compete with them. There is a competitive concern here because Amazon controls the marketplace and is using its market position to compete against these third party sellers.
There is no comparable analog to the physical/retail world because such an arrangement doesn't exist in the retail world.
Contrast to ebay or etsy, which are all third-party sellers. No competitive concerns there, because they aren't trying to compete with their own sellers.
- jklinger410 7y ago1. Many retail agreements are much closer to Amazon Fulfillment than you might realize. I know Best Buy, for instance, starts new relationships with a "pay as you go" scheme. Meaning we would ship them a pallet, they would literally charge us a warehouse fee, and then pay us as the product sold, and refund us the warehouse fee upon a complete sellout within a certain time frame. We had to sell our way into a classic wholesale to retail relationship. 2. I am aware of how store brands work, thanks. Amazon does this with Amazon Basics brand, which is a point of contention in the monopoly. It is identical to a store brand. If a retailer buys whole-sale white labeled products to compete against yours at a competitive rate, that is competition. Please try again at hand-waving that away. 3. Walmart, Kroger, Trader Joe's, Whole foods, all use data they have gathered from selling products to determine which white label brands it wants to create and compete with other products. There is a competitive concern here because these retailers control shelf space and promotional material and uses their physical retail space and sales data to compete against brands. Walmart more-so than all the others. I think I am building a pretty good comparison here.
- gamblor956 7y ago1. That arrangement isn't similar to Amazon Fulfillment at all from a legal perspective. Best Buy is just using the warehouse fee as a gatekeeper to filter out low-value/low-scale products. They have limited shelf space and relatively low turnover. Best Buy is in the business of selling products in its stores, but not in the business of marketing them unless they're the type of products that bring people into the stores (i.e., doorbusters). They rely on the product makers to do the bulk of the marketing, especially for new products where demand is not known. Key factoid: they refund the warehouse fee if the product actually sells. 2. Yes, but it's not comparable. Amazon isn't being investigated for competing against the likes of Champion or Under Armour. They're being investigated for competing against third party sellers (which might or might not be their own brands) by promoting their own products against their competition. Again, you don't seem to understand this basic point: the product maker's income comes from Amazon buying the product, not the end customer. If Amazon launches a white label brand, that's not an antitrust violation on its own. It's also fine to use data from selling Product X to sell the white label brand. Antitrust law rewards competition. It's even fine for Amazon to promote their own products over competing brands, since those brands have other sales channels they can use and they've already been paid for their product or are contractually obligated to get paid for their product. The problem is when Amazon promotes their own brand over other products in unfairly competitive ways, such as in search results for those competing brands' products. (Example: if searching for Lululemon brought up Amazon's peak velocity as the first few results). This is still a weak example of antitrust because Lululemon's already been paid by Amazon. But if you replaced Lululemon with Cococyle, an upcoming brand that sells through Amazon's marketplace, you'd have a clear antitrust violation. 3. There is a competitive concern here because these retailers control shelf space and promotional material and uses their physical retail space and sales data to compete against brands. Walmart more-so than all the others. No, false. There is competition here, but it's not unfair competition because the brands have already been paid for their products. Also, the brands have a very strong defense: they can simply pull their products from the store. (This strategy has actually been used many times to fight off store brands and it's the reason store brands and generics are given lower-shelf placements.) Most people go to grocery store for the branded products, not the white label products. TJ's is pretty much the only store on your list where they opposite might be true. Again, for emphasis: competition is fine. What matters for antitrust is unfair competition, and none of the stuff you've cited is unfair.
- hartator 7y ago> Retail stores buy the products they put on their shelves, at wholesale prices Not necessary. And often you have clauses saying suppliers will buy back unsold inventory.
- djakjxnanjak 7y ago>Retail stores buy the products they put on their shelves, at wholesale prices. They then mark up the prices to a retail price charged to the end buyer when they resell the products to the end buyer. Why is this difference salient? This process of selling, reselling and markup recurs for years. Economically the outcome is the same as the store charging a fee like Amazon, just with the payments split up and time shifted. If you doubt that the same power imbalances exist in brick-and-mortar, read about how Walmart squeezes suppliers.