6 ms·
There's something a little creepy about saying there's nothing wrong with the American education system by only looking at those in the US of European descent a
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
There's something a little creepy about saying there's nothing wrong with the American education system by only looking at those in the US of European descent and excluding all others.
Controlling for exogenous variables is "creepy"?
African Americans (and Asians) are excluded from comparison simply because Finland doesn't have them. Similarly, when comparing the US to Asian schools, the author excludes whites as well. The point here is to compare like to like.
- cletus 16y agoAnd you don't find the idea that in terms of education potential, the author's assumption that there is something fundamentally different about Americans of Asian, Caucasian or African descent just a little bit creepy? Like I said: I totally buy into the immigrant argument (including the language barrier) but to only compare Whites from the US to Europe (for a supposed "like for like" comparison), you're going beyond language and culture and introducing race as a variable. And no this isn't some kind of crypto-racist accusation. I just don't see how you can reasonably differentiate between someone of Chinese descent whose ancestors came here in the 19th century to build the railroads to someone of Irish descent who came here a century ago.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoAnd you don't find the idea that in terms of education potential, the author's assumption that there is something fundamentally different about Americans of Asian, Caucasian or African descent just a little bit creepy? That's not an assumption, it's just a possibility the author is attempting to control for. I just don't see how you can reasonably differentiate between someone of Chinese descent whose ancestors came here in the 19th century to build the railroads to someone of Irish descent who came here a century ago. The simplest way to reasonably differentiate between them is to look at them: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Irish_Americans.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Irish_Americans.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_American http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_American You seem to be asserting that allowing for the possibility that cultural or biological factors might affect educational outcomes is creepy. Is that an accurate assessment?
- borism 16y agoAfrican Americans (and Asians) are excluded from comparison simply because Finland doesn't have them. Oh yes, Finland has a lot of Africans and Asians (just not proportionally as many as the US "melting pot"). So your editorialized title should have been: After correcting for demographics, US whites fare better than EU/Asian schools and that my friend was pretty racist editorialization (if it makes any sense at all to compare apples to oranges)!
- anigbrowl 16y agoAnd what bearing would these visual differences have on education, pray tell?
- btilly 16y agoPeople don't only have stereotypes about others. A lifetime of people looking at you and reacting to you causes you to perform differently. Performance can change surprisingly quickly. Researchers have found that reminding people of their ethnic identity before they take a test will affect their performance on the test in accord with racial stereotypes. (Asians improve, blacks get worse.) While it is politically correct to try to be colorblind, reality doesn't cooperate. You can be PC and pretend those effects aren't there. Or you can be intellectually honest and honestly look at how big an impact they have. (That said, we can and should reduce the size of those effects. However we can't even begin to have a proper discussion of how to do that as long as we shoot the messenger that tells us that the effect is there.)
- yummyfajitas 16y agoHopefully not much. The visual differences simply demonstrate that they are separate and mutually distinguishable groups. The numbers quoted in the main article demonstrate that these groups do differ in some characteristics which affect education, although they don't illuminate which ones in particular.
- endtime 16y ago>And you don't find the idea that in terms of education potential, the author's assumption that there is something fundamentally different about Americans of Asian, Caucasian or African descent just a little bit creepy? Actually, I find creepy your suggestion that this is creepy. It's obviously true that there are differences between ethnicities, both genetic and cultural, and the notion that we should pretend this isn't the case is a bit Orwellian.
- rue 16y agoYou're right, there are no African-Americans or Asian-Americans in Finland… There are some African-Finns and Asian-Finns though.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoNot enough to make a difference. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Finland http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Finland
- borism 16y agooh yes, there is more than enough to fuel anti-immigrant sentiment in finns. I'm sorry, but I live nearby and know those things.
- chc 16y agoYes, but that doesn't necessarily mean they're enough to influence education statistics. It could mean, for example, that Finns are just easily riled up in general.
- rue 16y agoStatistically, probably not much of a difference if you subscribe to the theory that there would be. I was just correcting the implication that there were none.
- endtime 16y agoEthnic groups in Finland, from Wikipedia: Finnish 93.4% Finland-Swedes 5.6% Russians 0.5% Estonians 0.3% Roma 0.1% Sami 0.1%
- cromulent 16y agoThe Finland-Swedes are essentially Finns anyway, so you are talking about 99% homogenous population. I moved to Finland a couple of years ago and have two kids at school. The key differences I see (compared to Aus) are: - later start (7 years old grade 1) - hot lunches - every kid gets the same education, almost no private schools, no advantage in going to a different school - multiple languages are taught - teaching is quite a prestigious and reasonably well paid occupation - lots of small schools (they scale wide, not high, from a hardware perspective) Of course these are basic observations, not a study. I have no idea how they get such good results, but they do.
- healthyhippo 16y agoAfrican Americans and Asians Americans are people. I heard that Finland has people (though I'm not really sure). So, their school systems seem comparable. Because after 1st generation immigrants, race is more linked to identity within a society. Asians perform better on tests when they are reminded beforehand of their heritage because it reinforces their own stereotype of themselves. African Americans perform worse. There are racial subgroups in most diverse nations (including Japan) that have the same effects going on, despite the fact that to a foreigner there would be no appearance on But to say that in some way African Americans are "comparable" to people in Africa, or to say that of non-1st-generation Asian immigrants, doesn't really seem fair. Frankly, on a more personal note, I found this analysis to be structurally unsound. What I take away is that America spends more money on its schools than any country vs. Luxembourg, but doesn't have the highest test results. So throwing money at the problem may not be the right way to fix it. Or it may have some impact, but its going to be like running water through a leaky fire hose. We haven't developed the right educational system yet. A lot of smart people are working on this issue, and probably the right solution is to throw more money at them specifically.
- ghostDancer 16y agoI see that the problem is not the money but how to use it, the main problem is deciding where to put the money in and i think you're right , and i also think that there are different problems in different parts of the USA. In Spain,being much smaller than USA , they don't have the same problems in a school in the center of Madrid than in Barcelona or Bilbao, different problems need different solutions, but it must be a nightmare to find solutions for each area in a country as big as the USA
- djacobs 16y agoBased on race alone? I can understand culture being an important factor. But not race.
- tkahn6 16y agoFactoring out race is the easiest way to factor out culture. Would you not agree?
- anigbrowl 16y agoNo, not at all.
- tkahn6 16y agoOn a large scale, what would be an easier way to control for so-called "black culture"?
- borism 16y agoall purchasers of the pants which size is 120% wider and 120-150% longer than wearer requires.
- raleec 16y agoincome. As noted elsewhere in this thread, many of the ascribed self-defeating attitudes are endemic to indigenous (>1 generation) lower socio-economic strata across the 'racial' spectrum. Yes, there are vestiges everywhere, I'd start there.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jberryman 16y agoComparing light-skinned Americans with light skinned Finns is not comparing "like to like", it is making an arbitrary comparison based on false assumptions. "race" as we tend to think of it isn't a very scientific concept.
- m_myers 16y agoNot scientific, no. But many people self-identify by race and model their behavior on those who look like them. Not all. But many.
- jberryman 16y agothat has no bearing on the discussion of the validity of comparing people who look alike but live in different countries. a white finn might look like me, but i have no idea how i would go about modelling my behavior on them.
- m_myers 16y agoHmm, that's not what I meant to communicate. And now that I try to rephrase it in my head, I see that you're right about the relevance (or lack thereof). I was trying to say that there can be a difference between, say, blacks and whites (and Asians and...) even though they aren't "races"; but of course that doesn't have much to do with the subject in this comment thread.
- cdavid 16y agoControlling for exogenous variables is not creepy, but I find the focus on "ethnicity descent" a bit weird when it is the sole parameter being checked. For example, how does this study make sure that there is no other explanatory variable hidden in the country of origin (like e.g. household income) ? He mentions that the US spend a lot of money on education, but since he removes a big part of the students in each country, conclusions are much more difficult to draw: I would expect the money spent per student to be significantly different depending on demographics, for example. Also, the text uses all encompassing categories with straw man arguments about PISA tests comparison. For example, I can tell you that when the scores went out last year and was discussed in French news, nobody was bragging about how smarter we were compared to the US given how bad the results were for France. He makes some interesting points, but it is hidden within too much authoritative argumentation, which weakens his analysis IMO. IOW, I think it is an interesting starting point, but it is too crude to make any conclusion, especially the ones he is trying to draw.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoControlling for exogenous variables is not creepy, but I find the focus on "ethnicity descent" a bit weird when it is the sole parameter being checked. I'm guessing it's less creepy when you take into account that it's just an easily googleable factor. By the way, the fact that you exclude lots of students is irrelevant, as long as you keep enough to be statistically significant. That's true even when he throws away all non-asian students in the US. As for household income, that's an even shadier factor to include, since the US is significantly richer than most European nations. Holding income equal, you'd be comparing our 60'th percentile to Sweden's 40'th percentile (numbers made up, but something along those lines).
- cdavid 16y agoThat it is googleable does not make it relevant. I don't understand how excluding students is not relevant when discussing about money spent per student: the point is indeed to keep enough to be statistically significant, but w.r.t. what is measured. If money spent by student varies significantly within different demographics, systematically ignoring some demographics alters the validity of the comparison. Maybe it does not, but that needs to be controlled, otherwise it is nonsense statistically speaking. As for household income, I was not suggesting to use raw numbers, it should of course be normalized, e.g. something like purchase parity, although there may be better ways to do so. It seems difficult to argue that this is shadier than anything related to ethnicity which has no clear definition that I know of.