6 ms·
I have no issue with companies making profit but TurboTax is a bad product, with terrible scam-esque profit strategies, and actively preys upon the poor. Their
by vorpalhex 7y ago
I have no issue with companies making profit but TurboTax is a bad product, with terrible scam-esque profit strategies, and actively preys upon the poor.
Their "audit protection", the constant nag screens IN A PRODUCT I ALREADY PAID FOR, their push for you to upgrade (with no discount at the end if you didn't use the upgraded features), and so on. Tie that in with the "spend your refund before you get" double dipping offers, and it's a scam.
I hate TurboTax, they have no real competitors, and the federal government should make them redundant.
- mattbreeden 7y ago> their push for you to upgrade (with no discount at the end if you didn't use the upgraded features) This one actually got me this year. They force you to upgrade prior to seeing if the upgrade helps. I 'upgraded' to see if itemizing a certain thing would beat my standard deduction. It didn't, so I removed that whole section. But then I forgot to downgrade and accidentally paid an extra 30-50$ or whatever it was for absolutely nothing- something they could have easily detected. Obviously the responsibility lies on me for overpaying, but most other businesses wouldn't have taken the extra money for something I didn't use.
- henryfjordan 7y agoThe Federal Government cannot, by law, compete with TurboTax
- saagarjha 7y agoWhy, is it illegal for them to make tax filing easier (if it is, did TurboTax lobby for it?)
- acdw 7y agoIt is right now, and they did. They've been trying to make it permanent: https://techcrunch.com/2019/04/09/the-government-is-about-to-permanently-bar-the-irs-from-creating-a-free-electronic-filing-system/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/04/09/the-government-is-about-to...
- astrea 7y agoThere's a great Reply All episode (#144) about this exact article and the background, and eventual impact of it. From what I remember, the IRS had an idea to make a free filing online system but determined that the cost would be too great so they divvied up the different groups of people that qualify (people under some level of income, veterans, etc.) amongst the different companies (TurboTax being one of them) with the agreement that they would not build a competing system. I think they mention a bill that was shot down that would've maintained that agreement forever.
- ngngngng 7y agoThere are two justifications, all coming from the Republican side of things. 1) Tax filing being difficult makes people pay more attention to what they pay in taxes. 2) Tax filing being difficult makes people hate taxes, which will make them vote against raising taxes and or supporting socialism. This is all covered in an excellent podcast by Planet Money https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/04/03/709656642/episode-760-tax-hero https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/04/03/709656642/epis...
- throwaway3627 7y agoIn other countries, they have: - higher standards of living - longer life expectancies - better healthcare - higher taxes, but the money is used more efficiently and for better results than on mass incarceration or the largest military-industrial complex - very easy tax payment processes Taxes aren't universally "bad": fire departments, police departments, roads, schools. And guess what? That's "socialism." So is Social Security and USPS. The myth of anarchistic hyperindividualism (libertarianism) is a self-delusion because there are benefits to common infrastructure no individual could build themselves alone. PS: Why don't most Americans know how bad they have it? Is it their lack of passports or lack of honesty in paying attention outside of their filter bubble?
- MikeTheGreat 7y ago> PS: Why don't most Americans know how bad they have it? Is it their lack of passports or lack of honesty in paying attention outside of their filter bubble? I think it's both, now, but I think that the 'no passports' thing has been a factor for a while. When I was in middle school I wondered why many (white, middle-class, etc) Americans only speak English when so many people from Europe, etc speak several (or at least can get by). It dawned on me one day that you could start on one coast and drive clear across the continent without ever needing a second language - it's all USA the whole way. So yeah - much like the language thing there's no real exposure to anything other than our country.
- cnlevy 7y ago
- zerd 7y agoIntuit/TurboTax would love it if filing was so hard it's practically impossible, without the use of TurboTax. * In 2007, Intuit lobbied to make sure taxpayers cannot electronically file their tax returns directly to the IRS by negotiating a deal preventing the IRS from setting up its own web portal for e-filing. * In 2009, Intuit spent nearly $2 million in political contributions to eliminate free online state tax filing for low income residents in California. * Between 2001 and 2010, Intuit Inc., maker of the tax-preparation software TurboTax, spent more than $1.7 million on lobbying in an attempt to kill ReadyReturn. Proposed statewide rollout of the ReadyReturn program was defeated in the California legislature in 2006. The FTB revived it on their own for the 2007 tax year, expanding it to cover one million Californians * From 2009-2014, Intuit spent nearly $13 million lobbying. Intuit spent $1 million on opposing ReadyReturn, against John Chang, a Democrat who supported ReadyRun. Joseph Bankman, professor of tax law, Stanford Law School, and advocate of simplified filing, believes that the campaign warned politicians that if they supported free filing, Intuit would help their opponents. * On March 26, 2013, ProPublica reported that the company lobbied against return-free filing as recently as 2011. One year later, ProPublica reported that the company appeared to be linked to a number of op-eds and letters to Congress in a campaign advocating against direct tax filing backed by the Computer & Communications Industry Association, an advocacy organization of which Intuit is a member. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReadyReturn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReadyReturn
- PeterisP 7y agoLaws are designed by the government - if the executive branch cannot, by law, compete with TurboTax, then the legislative branch is free to alter the laws in whatever (constitutional) way benefits the society and explicitly delegate some agency the power (and duty!) to make TurboTax redundant.
- maximente 7y agoit'd be great if it worked this way, but it's already been captured at both a federal and at least 1 state level: https://www.propublica.org/article/congress-is-about-to-ban-the-government-from-offering-free-online-tax-filing-thank-turbotax https://www.propublica.org/article/congress-is-about-to-ban-... https://priceonomics.com/the-stanford-professor-who-fought-the-tax-lobby/ https://priceonomics.com/the-stanford-professor-who-fought-t...
- clairity 7y agoyah, businesses making money via legitimately adding value is awesome; making it via rent seeking and regulatory capture sucks. turbotax could still have a lucrative business by building on top of free filing with value added services, but no, they want government-protected profits. it's dishonorable. and it's a symptom of money controlling politics. we need to figure out how to allow politicians to be productive and contributive without money being the measuring stick proxying power.
- throwaway3627 7y agoOh my, you don't know how laws get "designed." Congress ostensibly writes the laws, but they're now often allowing outside special interests and lawyers to pass along laws for introduction nearly verbatim. Furthermore, Intuit was caught lobbying to keep the tax submission process complicated and not free.
- opportune 7y agoYeah I agree. Congress is trying to pass a law to prohibit the IRS from doing free tax returns (competing with Turbotax) but theoretically congress could just repeal that law whenever they get around to finally letting the IRS just do the tax returns right? So all the law would do is prevent an executive order for the IRS to do that
- jakelazaroff 7y agoNot exactly. The IRS has made a deal with an industry group called the Free File Alliance saying that in exchange for offering free tax filing to some subset of taxpayers, the IRS won't create competing software. Congress is working on a bill called the Taxpayer First Act that would enshrine that deal in law [1], effectively prohibiting the IRS from creating their own software. It looks like that bill has only passed the House so far [2] so it may still fail. Regardless, it would still be okay for the IRS to automatically file people's taxes and send them a return, which is the true best solution here. [1] https://www.propublica.org/article/congress-is-about-to-ban-the-government-from-offering-free-online-tax-filing-thank-turbotax https://www.propublica.org/article/congress-is-about-to-ban-... [2] https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/5444 https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/5444
- apta 7y agoWho is congress being bribed by here?
- colejohnson66 7y agoTurboTax (Intuit) and H&R Block mostly
- vonmoltke 7y agoThere is (currently) no such law.
- ClutchBand 7y agoThe Federal Government or the policy makers in control of it, seem to believe that privatizing things is an approach for making them redundant, in a way. Until we can step back from the belief that private corporations can solve every problem, we will be stuck with long-standing, and wasteful systems/situations like this.
- astura 7y ago>they have no real competitors They do - TaxHawk (who also owns FreeTaxUSA.com) is an ethical full feature tax prep software company. Federal return is free (for everyone) and state is $15 (for everyone). No nag screens, no dark patterns. You can even file your federal without filing your state and not pay a dime, no problem. The UI is good (and the UI is the whole reason I'm using tax prep software over paper forms) Been using them for like six year at least.
- lotophage 7y agoCredit Karma lets you do tax returns for free
- astura 7y agoRight, but the "free" price tag gives a lot of people a pause - the whole "if you aren't paying for it you are the product" It does use your data to advertise to you - https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/03/07/when-tax-prep-is-free-you-may-be-paying-with-your-privacy/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/03/07/when-ta... The UI also sucks compared to TaxHawk.
- TrinaryWorksToo 7y agoThat is incorrect for the tax service. It keeps your tax data separate. It is true that I get ads for my credit score
- toomuchtodo 7y agoCan TaxHawk import Turbotax data from previous year?
- clintonb 7y agoDoes TurboTax (online) allow for exports other than the PDF?
- 7y ago
- nathanvanfleet 7y agoI think the cycle where businesses can influence the government to maintain / increase profits is the part that makes me hate this company.
- quaquaqua1 7y agoI used to send my tax information directly to Massachussets via their own free platform. Sometime around 2016 they discontinued it and told me to go beg someone for free service, or pay turbotax (seriously). They told me only 2% of state filers used the website. Question-- why should I have to pay for them to tell me what I owe them? If running the platform is so much money, donate to an open source consortium who will maintain it forever for a rational price.
- selimthegrim 7y agoLouisiana has a very good platform from an instate contractor. Oregon OTOH IIRC just gives you some forms you can type into. I guess given the Cover Oregon thing I shouldn’t be surprised.
- quaquaqua1 7y agoOracle committed one of the largest frauds ever, $150m to not deliver what they said they would deliver, while deliberately misleading Oregon govt with statements like "it's 70% done, just give us money!"
- hakfoo 7y agoArizona has semi-automated PDFs. They'll generate a large 2D barcode of the data and perform some addition, but the one most critical calculation in the form, looking up the relevant tax amount from taxable income and filing status-- is "read these tables and formulas on a seperate screen and do it yourself."
- pkaye 7y agoSame thing in California. I read they discontinued the free platform because of low use.
- clintonb 7y agoSeems like a chicken-egg problem. Having been a resident of CA for nearly two years, I remain amazed by the poor UX of pretty much every online system operated by the government. FTB, BART, DMV. They are all horrible! I am not surprised the usage is low. The systems are all painful to use. I would love if CA established a department along the lines of 18F (https://18f.gsa.gov/ https://18f.gsa.gov/) or USDS (https://www.usds.gov/ https://www.usds.gov/) to improve these systems.
- wmeredith 7y agoCreditKarma did my taxes this year. Was pretty great. (No affiliation)
- k_sze 7y agoWhat if the federal and/or state government offered, to tax return software makers, a small part of the proceeds for every successful tax return, on the condition that the software remains free of charge to the users and does not share or sell user data to advertisers? Might we see a lot of good competition spring up this way?
- jakelazaroff 7y agoLet's just skip to the chase and have the IRS automatically for everyone's tax returns. The problem isn't lack of competition. It's that this industry is entirely propped up by a byzantine and entirely unnecessary process. The only reason these companies are able to reduce friction filing your taxes is that they lobby to create it in the first place.
- whymsicalburito 7y agoI've been using TaxAct for the last few years and have been happy. Pretty similar product as TurboTax, but I feel their upsells are much less pushy.