3 ms·
It seems like a consequence of the search engine monopoly is that the SEO side of the arms race only has one target. If we had many important engines with many
by smt88 7y ago
It seems like a consequence of the search engine monopoly is that the SEO side of the arms race only has one target.
If we had many important engines with many algorithms, it might dilute any particular tactic that SEO uses.
- luckylion 7y agoThey would likely work in a similar way, being susceptible to the same tactics. Imho, the main problem is that there's no deterrent. Even if you get caught doing some very black hat stuff, worst thing that can happen is to get a manual penalty. Remove the outlawed stuff, wait a month or two, submit a reinclusion request and you're back in business. If it was a "once you're caught, you're out for good" thing, SEOs would tread much more carefully.
- smt88 7y agoI disagree that they'd work the same way because Google has invested millions of person-hours into a proprietary algorithm that they share with no one. DDG and Bing often have wildly differing results for me.
- luckylion 7y agoThat's true, but I believe that they'd arrive at similar techniques if they were rivaling Google. Today, it's a Cyborg-Behemoth vs a few scrap-yard tinkerers. If Bing & DDG had the budget and manpower Google has, the results would probably become more similar - but who knows, there might be completely different approaches to search that we just haven't seen. In any case, we probably do agree that it would be very good in general if there was more competition in the search market.
- jstarfish 7y agoIt's funny, we used to go to Dogpile or Jeeves when Yahoo's results were crap and you couldnt be bothered to go search Lycos, Altavista and dozen others (and all the hyper-specialized ones). Then Google hit the scene and it gave equal or better results than the aggregators. Now Google themselves gives dodgy or inconsistent results that incentivize one to look elsewhere, but I don't think it is entirely their fault-- charlatans can crank out chum content faster than it can be analyzed and indexed. Google is doing the best the can...they have their own financial interests but they happen to align with ensuring people trust their results. The scale and nature of the web these days is very different than it was in '96. There was a competing engine popping up every year-- an endless cycle of "___ sucks, use ___ instead." But I haven't heard of anything other than Google and DDG since Cuil failed.