8 ms·
Immigration Bill Could Change How Silicon Valley Sources Foreign Talent
- fickleycurious 7y agoWould it sail through Senate though ?
- paulgb 7y agoText of the bill: https://congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/1044 https://congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/1044
- kkarakk 7y ago>It also removes an offset that reduced the number of visas for individuals from China. i foresee a chinese tesla within a decade that costs a fraction of the price
- conanbatt 7y agoThat would be fantastic!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tomschlick 7y agoEspecially so when they steal Tesla's IP https://electrek.co/2019/03/21/tesla-chinese-startup-xpeng-stole-autopilot-source-code-former-employee/ https://electrek.co/2019/03/21/tesla-chinese-startup-xpeng-s...
- rtkwe 7y agoPretty sure that would happen regardless of any immigration changes on the US side. All Tesla really is is an all electric luxury-ish (-ish in the case of the model 3) car.
- filereaper 7y agoThese types of Visas typically require that you do graduate studies in a US academic institution to be considered "high-skilled". Nothing against this but I've seen many folks add another post-graduate degree just to tick a box.
- LordFast 7y agoWhich should lead to more demand for professors I assume, but since academia is tenure tracked and therefore isn't very elastic, then it leads to I guess bigger class sizes and more administrative bloat driving up program costs, which in turn drives up loan borrowing? Just guesses. I'm very curious as to the feedback loops created on the overall system.
- gervase 7y agoYep, that's pretty accurate. It also drives degree inflation in the job market: "Why would I hire a BS student when I can get an MS or even PhD for the same price?"
- BeetleB 7y ago>These types of Visas typically require that you do graduate studies in a US academic institution to be considered "high-skilled". I don't know that the word "high-skilled" is used anywhere in the actual law(s). There is "skilled" (EB-3) and "advanced degrees" (EB-2). The latter will usually require an MS degree.
- conanbatt 7y agoThe scariest word a law could ever have is "Fair". I truly believe that if Americans understood how the visa process worked, they would be appalled, even if they are hard nationalists. It's simply not rule of law, its crazy expensive and its just plain dumb. It would be easier to propose a special tax to foreigners that goes directly into the pockets of americans and remove all the restrictions altogether. Foreigners would gladly accept a 10% surtax for alleviating the ridiculousness of immigration law. Add: foreigners already pay surtaxes, but get no credit for them.
- AlexTWithBeard 7y agoYour prayers have been heard by the UK government! https://www.gov.uk/healthcare-immigration-application/how-much-pay https://www.gov.uk/healthcare-immigration-application/how-mu...
- jdsully 7y agoTo any American immigrating to the UK £400 for healthcare is a steal.
- mywittyname 7y agoWhat's amazing is I figured this was £400 per month and I agreed. Then I clicked the link and discovered it was per year. Socialized medicine can't get here fast enough.
- blunte 7y agoThe titles of bills are largely irrelevant, especially in the last decade or so. As for taxing incoming foreigners to give to Americans, that's not what most Americans want. What most Americans want (and i don't mean the white nationalists) is to not lose their job to a same or less skilled person for less pay. Having fully experienced the dotcom implosion and subsequent H1B and outsourcing fest, I can attest that the only two groups that gained were the tech companies who lowered their expenses and the handlers/harvesters who brought people from their countries to the US, kept half of their hourly wage, and packed them 6+ to an apartment.
- digianarchist 7y ago"The bill also establishes transition rules for employment-based visas from FY2020-FY2022, by reserving a percentage of EB-2 (workers with advanced degrees or exceptional ability), EB-3 (skilled and other workers), and EB-5 (investors) visas for individuals not from the two countries with the largest number of recipients of such visas. Of the unreserved visas, not more than 85% shall be allotted to immigrants from any single country." That is a welcome change.
- oblio 7y agoI'm not from the US, nor planning to move to or live in the US: isn't this a blatant move to block Chinese and Indians? ("two countries")
- fhrow4484 7y agoCurrently the limit is 7% per country, as described in the second paragraph of tfa. If 85% is a "blatant move to block" people from those countries, how would you describe 7%?
- belltaco 7y agoThe current system is unfair to Indians and Chinese, so they are trying to fix that with the bill. At the same time, they put in that text to make it so that people from other countries who are already in the queue are not adversely affected, so it eases in the transition over two years so that people from other countries applying in the next few months don't have to wait for decades.
- wil421 7y agoThe motive is to level the playing field so to say. China and India have the largest populations. India (and US) staffing companies have been abusing the Visa system and the eager Visa applicants for some time. I’ve personally seen it with IT Contractors getting pointless mail order Masters just to meet the Visa requirement. I do not see this as part of the ongoing China/US trade “issues”.
- simonebrunozzi 7y ago
- hourislate 7y agoHere is another take on the bill... https://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/technology/452194-fairness-for-high-skilled-immigrants-act-exposes-silicon https://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/technology/452194-fa...
- belltaco 7y agoThat's such a bad take with so many inaccuracies that I don't know where to start.
- repo001 7y agoThanks for this. The original article seemed too much like a PR puff piece. “a significant portion of the lobbying done in favor of” the bill “was bankrolled by tech companies.” Why any IT professional would trust in the big lobbying tech companies to act in their interests is beyond me.
- yahelc 7y agoThe author, Virgil Goode, is best remembered for this incident. It may help in understanding his motivations in opposing high-skilled immigration. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quran_oath_controversy_of_the_110th_United_States_Congress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quran_oath_controversy_of_the_...
- manas666 7y agoI would like everyone answer few questions to define what is fair and what is not: 1. Is it fair for high-skilled Indian-nationals to wait 10+ years for a GC? 2. Is it fair that indian consultancy bodyshops overwhelmed the IT market and H1B quota and then brought down the wages of IT professionals via C2C, 1099, OPT/CPT, fake resumes and other tricks? 3. Is it fair that indian GC backlog will delay GC for other nationals, in case the 7% limit is lifted? I would say since Indians enjoyed getting the majority of H1-Bs, they should also bear the consequences of hitting the country limit. Otherwise, it would only benefit Indian nationals only at a cost of other nationals. I am not even talking about nurses and other professions that will be harmed by this bill.
- belltaco 7y agoNations don't get visas. Individuals do. Punishing or rewarding people on the basis of where they were born instead of their own skills is wrong. Regarding #2, the body shops are able to get away with it because of the long GC backlog for Indians. Hence companies like to hire Indians precisely because they will work for them for a long time without pay hikes because of the GC backlog, compared to hiring Americans or workers from other non-backlogged countries. This bill will take that away and equalize everyone's footing. You know the body shops and staffing companies hate this bill right? >Is it fair that indian GC backlog will delay GC for other nationals, in case the 7% limit is lifted? Yes, it is. It's called first come first served. That's like asking if it is fair that people who got into the queue at the DMV before you get to go to the counter before you. Yes, it definitely is.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoBut its fairer - its certainly not fair that one country take the lions share? What about some bright young kid from Saharan Africa doesn't get a fair chance at a H1b Visa. And you could argue from a realpolitik view that allowing more sub Sharan h1b's would act as a counter to the Chinese Belt and Road would be a good policy
- triceratops 7y ago
- jimbob45 7y agoThe government would toss me out a job if someone else wants to come in the country that can make them more money. It feels pointless to stay pledged to one country when someone from another country can just get an H-1B visa and take your job in a matter of months.
- conanbatt 7y agoYou are confusing the government with your employer. Also, you would also be out of a job if all the tools you use as a programmer would have to be made by americans and not imported from cheap overseas labor.
- jimbob45 7y agoH-1B is a government program. They are the ones that decide if it stays or goes. The employer has no choice but to use the program if they wish to not fall behind their competitors.
- conanbatt 7y agoUnder your model it is you who is now employed by the government at the expense of your employer. Your employer wants to hire someone else but cant, so the government is preventing both your employer and this other person to work together. A priviledge is not a right.
- davidf18 7y agoThe reason that there is so long of a wait for people from India is because they aren't applying to other countries and working there. There are many, many countries that the Indians could apply and get work, but instead they are focused on the US. For example, Canada, Japan, Germany, UK, France, Italy, Taiwan, Hong Kong, and many, many other nations need programmers. One has to examine this obsession with the US when there are so many opportunities throughout the world to work as programmers. The import of cheap Indian labor simply lowers the wages of American citizens and takes jobs away from American citizens. There are so many countries throughout the world they could work including their own country of India.