7 ms·
But it's the other way around. Can you distribute a native application on macOS without Apple's blessing? No, you can't (not when Catalina will be out anyway).
by flohofwoe 7y ago
But it's the other way around. Can you distribute a native application on macOS without Apple's blessing? No, you can't (not when Catalina will be out anyway). And Windows is closing the "gap" really fast too. Try distributing a native installer without the browser or SmartScreen bringing up a scare-dialog-box.
Until OS vendors are willing to provide a safe sandbox to run untrusted code in, and untangled from a non-technical curating mechanism which has all sorts of conflicts-of-interests of what's morally acceptable and what's not, WASM is the next best thing to an open, yet secure, platform.
Desktop Linux aside, the web is currently the only open platform for distributing software outside of the interests of a single "platform owner". Google may close this "loop hole" soon, so I'm not too optimistic for the future, but today, that's what it is.
- FpUser 7y agoI am partially an ISV and we provide pure native application for Windows at the moment. No UWP/.NET/APP_STORE/WHATEVER . It is digitally signed and distributed by downloading from our web site. So far no problem. Since we've been in business a number of years there are no any browser/OS/Antivirus level warning boxed during downloading and installation.
- jakobegger 7y ago> Can you distribute a native application on macOS without Apple's blessing? No, you can't. I've been running the Catalina betas, and running non-notarized apps only requires right clicking instead of double clicking. If that's too much of an obstacle for you, you probably shouldn't run the app. Gatekeeper on macOS is a technology designed to protect careless users. It makes it slightly harder to shoot yourself in the foot. It doesn't prevent you from doing it, though.
- 0815test 7y ago> Until OS vendors are willing to provide a safe sandbox to run untrusted code in Thing is, "safe" OS-sandboxes are not safe; "local" privilege escalation vulnerabilities are still pervasive. Until OS's are safe enough that I can run `sudo -u nobody untrusted_binary` and not even think about the possibility of it taking over my system, something like the WASM sandbox (perhaps extended with WASI and other optional mechanisms) will always be needed.
- danieldk 7y agoThe the browser sandbox is just another sandbox, as we have seen with targeted attacks on Firefox two weeks back. Why is everybody so insistent on running untrusted code?
- bitwize 7y agoBecause the Web won't work without running untrusted code.
- idle_zealot 7y agoThe Web of hyperlinked documents would still work. But webapps would not be able to run arbitrary code the moment they were navigated to. Perhaps there should be a clear user-visible distinction between an HTML document with some styling and a full-blown application (that happens to use DOM for layout).
- wtetzner 7y agoWho gets to decide which code is trusted?
- danieldk 7y agoBut it's the other way around. Can you distribute a native application on macOS without Apple's blessing? No, you can't (not when Catalina will be out anyway). Yes you can: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/unsigned-apps-catalyst-app-signing.2183873/#post-27437170 https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/unsigned-apps-catalyst-... WASM is the next best thing to an open, yet secure, platform. So, instead of walled gardens with signed and checked applications (bad). We have to run untrusted and unchecked code of vendors who run code to track your movements around the web and in their applications? (Even worse) Desktop Linux aside Maybe we should make Linux an acceptable platform for more people rather than optimizing for proprietary web applications that you don't even own a copy of anymore.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> Maybe we should make Linux an acceptable platform for more people rather than optimizing for proprietary web applications that you don't even own a copy of anymore. Won't ever happen for two reasons: 1) The Linux Desktop community would have to admit that there are better ways to do things, and 2) They'd have to agree on what those things are. 20 years of Linux Desktop history show these things to be impossible. Theoretically, a new community could spring up and put a new userland on top of the Linux kernel, like Android did, but it would seem like the people who have the interest in doing such a thing (like myself) lack enough time, talent, and/or ability to organize sufficiently to pull it off. Not to mention that we'd all have to agree too.
- ScottFree 7y agoI lack the talent, but I'm definitely interested. Have you taken a look around Casey Muratori's handmade.network? Or interacted much with the guys who watch Jonathan Blow's livestreams? They make much the same point you do about taking the linux kernel and creating a new userland around it. Anyone who's interested in working on something like this, email walkinginalinuxuserland@lj3.me. The least we could all do is keep in touch, right?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
- nerdponx 7y agoI recently switched to desktop GNU/Linux full time outside of work, and I have to say it's really damn good now. Mind you, I'm using a Lenovo laptop, so it's among the best supported hardware you can buy for the purpose. But the fact that there aren't more boutique computer makers selling GNU/Linux systems installed by default is an interesting statement on the industry. I'm sure ultimately it comes down to the availability of software like Microsoft Word, but ironically having so much stuff move to the cloud is a boon in this case. With so many web-based apps available, nontechnical people can switch from Windows to a well-configured GNU/Linux system and not notice much of a difference. With that problem out of the way, a hypothetical hardware vendor can focus on building sane defaults, a good user experience, and good documentation (good for users, not developers). Then if and when it works out and marketshare ends up in double digits, more non-web software will start to become available anyway, and/or a lot more corporate money could start flowing into established projects like LibreOffice. Obviously the Chromebook was a thing, and you can buy System76 machines today, but the former was too extreme and the latter is probably too expensive for grandma just checking her email. I assume the reason it doesn't exist it is because the logistics and economics of the hardware don't work out. But I wonder if it will become feasible some time in the near future.
- tracker1 7y agoBeyond that, with flatpak and wasm application sandboxes, it will only get better. Wasm, provided some UI primitives and OS-like primitives get baked in, will give a common runtime for UI apps everywhere without a full browser. WASM+Canvas or WASM+WebGL can/will go a LONG way. I would say, that enough OS primitives should be present so that as an example SQLite3 can compile and run, and you can get a compatible file out the other end.
- Razengan 7y ago> Can you distribute a native application on macOS without Apple's blessing? No, you can't Yes, you can. You have always been able to. > (not when Catalina will be out anyway). Yes, you will be able to. I just downloaded a music tracker/MOD player from the Mesozoic (well, not quite) and it runs fine on Catalina Developer Preview 4. I can understand the confusion – I had the same concerns while watching this year's WWDC's Platforms State of the Union – but please do not spread FUD, or accept it as true without credible sources. Apple does require developers to update their old apps now and then, and that may not be convenient for some devs, but I feel it's overall good for users, and they don't force anyone to distribute via the App Store only or give Apple a % of their sales. In fact, a few companies have withdrawn their products from the Mac App Store, like Sketch and Coda and others.
- tracker1 7y agoRunning an unsigned app is a bit of a pain... though, imho probably worth it for the modest improvement in security.