3 ms·
Encryption on Sia happens on the client-side, so the host has no guarantee that the file is actually encrypted.[1] For encrypted data, I think it will be simil
by mtlynch 7y ago
Encryption on Sia happens on the client-side, so the host has no guarantee that the file is actually encrypted.[1]
For encrypted data, I think it will be similar to the situation with other storage providers. If law enforcement searches your computer and discovers that you've uploaded illegal content in encrypted form to S3/GCS/Mega (especially Mega because they make it so easy to upload client-side encrypted data), then law enforcement will order the provider to destroy all copies of the data.
It will be interesting to see what happens if the provider is a Sia host. Law enforcement entities have standard processes for reporting illegal content to Amazon/Google/Mega/etc, and those companies have teams responsible for handling those requests. Casual Sia hosts currently wouldn't know how to handle such a request. The outcome might be that the compliance costs are too big for casual home users, so hosting on Sia becomes a specialized task that only dedicated companies can provide.
[1] https://lukechampine.com/irresponsible.html https://lukechampine.com/irresponsible.html
- Ajedi32 7y agoI think someone technically skilled enough to run a Sia host would also be skilled enough to know how to delete delete a specific file off their hard drive. Sia could even provide a UI to make that easy. Though if Law Enforcement has access to the client's encryption keys, I think chances are it'd be way easier for them to just issue a delete command to the Sia network directly.
- nemo1618 7y agoWe do in fact already make it trivial to remove content from your host. Law enforcement can provide a list of hashes, which you pass as parameters to a CLI command that deletes them.