4 ms·
> First of all, what if you lose access to your email address? Now you can't access your service anymore? Isn't this basically already true for all of the serv
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
> First of all, what if you lose access to your email address? Now you can't access your service anymore?
Isn't this basically already true for all of the services that require two-step authentication?
I'm not saying this is a good state of things, per se, but at this point I've basically accepted that I can never change my email or phone number.
- itcrowd 7y ago2FA could be via email, but is often with SMS / app on phone. There is a backup mechanism here with printed one-time-use numbers. This is not friction-less nor optimal in my view, but there is some backup. The proposed login mechanism has no backup. Email address hacked, expired (new job, graduated from uni) or forgot password? You're out of luck.
- anderspitman 7y agoNo explicit backup, but I think you're also assuming Google-level lack of customer service. If someone contacted me telling me they lost control of their email, there's a lot of steps I could take to help them out short of telling them tough luck and them never being able to access their account again.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoThis actually strikes me as a quite dangerous mindset! A lot of "hacked" accounts happen when someone tricks customer support. How, exactly, would you verify the customer's legitimacy?
- gshdg 7y agoBy asking them their mother’s maiden name, of course!
- itcrowd 7y agoTrue. And I don't want to be overly pedantic with the implementation details. I like your proposal to remove passwords and prevent phising in general and I'm trying to give some honest feedback on what I think is wrong with this auth system. The title of this post is "Tell me why this auth system is a bad idea", after all, not "Tell me the good parts of this auth system" ;) I guess a question I would have for you is: name a few companies to which you would like to pitch this auth system. (e.g. your first few customers if you turned this into a startup or something)
- anderspitman 7y agoYou should definitely be using 2 different forms of 2FA with important services like your email address, and one of them should not be SMS. Personally I use a phone app and a hardware key.