4 ms·
Similar issues can arise with police body cameras. Seattle's initial attempt to use body cams had to be stopped because all of the footage was available under s
by tzs 7y ago
Similar issues can arise with police body cameras. Seattle's initial attempt to use body cams had to be stopped because all of the footage was available under state open record laws, and someone was filing requests for all of it and putting it up on YouTube. This was a massive violation of the privacy of numerous people caught on those videos. Police go into people's home, often uninvited and on short notice, and can easily see intimate and private details of those people's lives.
At first Seattle tried editing the footage before release to redact parts that might violate the privacy of anyone other then the officers and alleged criminals. I don't remember how many officers were involved in the initial body cam deployment, but it was enough that they generated so much footage that they didn't have the budget to edit it. I remember at one point they were even asking hackers for help with automating some of this.
A couple years or so later, they resumed using body cams. I'm not sure how they dealt with the privacy issues.
- halbgnarf 7y agoFor some morbid reason I love those accounts of random law trolls, thanks for sharing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pfranz 7y agoI wish I had more concrete information, but I remember hearing about one police department treating bodycam recordings in public and in private places differently for this reason. I imagine the officer would tag it when they left their shift or offloaded the footage. In general, I've heard reviewing the footage is a huge undertaking and an unexpected burden. I wouldn't be surprised if, like many backup systems, they're not often tested and found to be insufficient when they go to pull a video...but, then again, they also deal with evidence which has similar requirements.
- wpietri 7y agoThis strikes me as such a good opportunity for putting the cognitive surplus to work. I would totally volunteer to review and tag police footage for my local PD. Given the popularity of cop reality shows, I'd think plenty would.
- tick_tock_tick 7y agoI mean tons of people would just to creep on their neighbors which is not what body cams are meant for.
- wpietri 7y agoSure, but I think it's possible to set a system up like that so it's reasonably hard to misuse. E.g., I have to sign up, sign an NDA, and get trained in person. Then I'm not just given full access to untagged video, but I'm treated like a Mechanical Turk worker: I get assigned a video, tag it, appropriately, and move on. And if I leak stuff inappropriately or misuse my powers, I face criminal charges for privacy violation.
- dmitrygr 7y agoor do it cross-towns. you only get to tag things from random towns that are >= 50 mi from you. and they might do yours
- djakjxnanjak 7y agoA system with enough manual control that the officer has the task of tagging and offloading the footage sounds like a system where inconvenient footage will be mysteriously deleted.
- pfranz 7y agoI feel like that's being addressed as body cams get rolled out. I've heard about procedures to address faking damaged equipment and other excuses for "missing" footage. Cruisers have had video for awhile now, so it's not completely new.
- logfromblammo 7y agoThe privacy issue is that an agent of the public is intruding into private spaces. The body cam footage is just revealing in a more obvious and exploitable way that the problem already existed. Whatever the body cam sees is already being recorded by the mark I cop eye. I imagine that the privacy issues would be less severe for the recordings where cops knock, present a warrant, and then enter to execute it, because that is the due process instituted for the public interest breaching into private spaces. Agents of the public should be doing their duties in public. As for the automating, I'd use glyphs easily recognized by machine vision to mark different areas in the cop shop. Stencil-paint a glyph on the walls of the bathrooms and locker rooms, and the camera can automatically tag that video as not immediately available for public release, and blur an area surrounding the glyph for automated redaction. If people are concerned about body cam video of themselves being released automatically without redactions, they can put up glyph stickers in their homes, or wear glyphs on their clothing. A public-private toggle switch on the cam might help, but is susceptible to bad user input or insufficient usage training. Without some kind of explicit marker, AI may never be able to determine the transition points between public and private spaces, and certainly could not deal with adversarial attacks against that classifier. At worst, over-glyphing or inappropriate wearer inputs could exhaust the video-review resources. But I think that it is in the public's interest for all calls to the emergency lines to be public, regardless of the potential privacy issues. Instead of having the 911 call center employees worried about covering their asses in case they make a mistake, support them with good training, checklists for the most common issues, a second tier of higher-trained crisis managers to join in for non-routine calls, and maybe an on-demand pool of expert support, such as the psychiatrists, lawyers, or explosives disposal technicians. Leaving the postmortem analysis of an emergency only to officially authorized people allows cover-ups or deceptive re-framing to happen.
- cgriswald 7y agoMy neighbors left their apartment door open and did not respond to my knocks or my voice. I called the cops, because I wasn’t going to enter the apartment. The cops entered the apartment and found my neighbors in bed. Whether they were asleep or in the throes of passion, I don’t know. But if the cops had had body cams, it would have been captured. I’ve heard a story about the cops being called by neighbors because someone was screaming for help. Turned out the lady of the house was doing the screaming. She was tied up in bed and the husband was in costume and collapsed on the floor having a heart attack. These were both legal entries into private places. I think most people would agree these are things the public doesn’t need access to if they are captured by body cams.
- baddox 7y agoI'm not sure I fully understand the issue. Don't police body cameras serve most of their purpose if they are available as evidence in legal cases? As far as I know, the evidence in evidence rooms is not by default available to the public, though it may end up being disclosed as part of a legal case. If the problem is that prosecutors are protecting police unfairly, then publishing body camera footage isn't really going to help unless it's enough to cause significant public outcry. After all, there are plenty of instances of publicly available videos of police doing things where the public doesn't believe the legal repercussions are sufficient, and there is public outrage, and it doesn't matter.
- Retric 7y agoThe issue is freedom of information act requests where disclosing this information in mass outside of court cases.
- baddox 7y agoRight, I'm asking why all body camera footage would be subject to such requests, or why the requests wouldn't be subject to significant redaction for obvious reasons. I am all for police transparency, but I don't see much function in having all body camera footage public as long as the footage is easily obtainable for any legal case.
- Retric 7y agoThey defaulted to bing public. Government workers needed to follow the law, and there was no blanket exception given for this kind of footage, thus the issue. By comparison 911 calls are public in many areas, so they likely made an accurate legal assessment.
- closeparen 7y agoOpen records principles accommodate time delay much more often than they accommodate total opacity. You can probably FOIA the police files on old cases, including details of the evidence.
- lostmsu 7y agoWhere can I download that data from? It seems like it might be a good source for self-supervised machine learning on video.