4 ms·
Seems like the caller's interest should trump that of the victims' families, and doing so could make the system safer. If you are taking drugs with someone and
by gumby 7y ago
Seems like the caller's interest should trump that of the victims' families, and doing so could make the system safer.
If you are taking drugs with someone and they look like they are dying it should definitely be safe for you to call 911, even if you are participating, or are somewhere you shouldn't be, or don't have a visa, or whatever.
If you break into a building, perhaps to steal, and your companion falls and breaks a limb you should definitely be able to call 911 (bad luck for your companion who will surely be arrested though).
A person's heart stops, you call 911, the try CPR and they die anyway (well, they're already "dead" if you're doing CPR). You shouldn't have any liability.
Grand juries and review boards could still confidentially review 911 calls for cases like this, where the family fears malpractice by the first responders.
==
This is no different for why TSA should not screen for drugs or anything but weapons that could threaten a flight; why people not already in the court system should not be arrested in courthouses (or nearby). Why people who are here illegally should get vaccines and drivers' licenses. What seems "unfair" can actually promote the public welfare.
- wool_gather 7y ago> A person's heart stops, you call 911, the try CPR and they die anyway (well, they're already "dead" if you're doing CPR). You shouldn't have any liability. There's already some kind of provision for this in many places; it's known as a "Good Samaritan law". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Samaritan_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Samaritan_law
- FireBeyond 7y ago> If you are taking drugs with someone and they look like they are dying it should definitely be safe for you to call 911 In Washington state, this is how it is, and there are education programs, and statutes to this effect, telling kids/anyone "If you call 911 because you think your or your friends life is at risk because of alcohol or drug use, neither you nor they will be arrested for that".