3 ms·
What retaliation have they faced from Google exactly?
by dmix 7y ago
What retaliation have they faced from Google exactly?
- jakelazaroff 7y agoFrom this article: > In an email to colleagues, Whittaker said her Google manager told her to "abandon [her] work on AI ethics" and blocked a request to transfer internally. From the aforelinked Guardian article: > In the letters, Stapleton said that two months after the walkout, she was demoted and “told to go on medical leave” despite not being sick. The demotion was reversed after she hired a lawyer, she said.
- cobookman 7y agoThe manager feedback was posted in an internal mailing list. It said no such thing. manager asked her to focus on her day to day job. Her ai ethics work was not aligned to the job she was hired for.
- bancars 7y agoDo you have proof of this?
- cobookman 7y agoIf you are a googler. View the ethics-discuss group. And search for Meredith's post where she discloses her managers performance review.
- cobookman 7y agoSry. Source was from a blind thread. Not an internal thread. Mixed the two up https://us.teamblind.com/s/5YFH3CqL https://us.teamblind.com/s/5YFH3CqL
- joshuamorton 7y agoThis is not correct. Her day to day work is/was in the AI bias and ethics space, even within google.
- xyzzyz 7y agoWhy do you think so? Do you have a source of any of her supervisors saying that?
- jakelazaroff 7y agoNot sure why the burden of proof would be higher for this claim than the preceding one.
- xyzzyz 7y agoBefore I left Google, I looked her up, and none of her ladder, none of her supervisors, none of the other reportees of her immediate supervisor etc. had anything to do with AI ethics. She was originally hired as a Program Manager on Google Docs. In this light, I view your statement as requiring some backing.
- fao_ 7y agoSo provide some evidence. I could easily say I worked for XYZ and say the same thing you have. I worked for the White House as Press Secretary and got an email from Trump drunkenly claiming he ran someone over. I worked as senior advisor to the Shadow Health Secretary in 2020 and helped leak internal communiques covering numerous malpractice suites. Blah blah blah. It's all words until you show evidence. It's hypocritical to demand evidence from someone else without showing your own. If you don't have any to show, then that's your problem, not theirs.
- joshuamorton 7y agoMy source is the same document that the other poster mentioned. When did you leave? Because you know, people switch jobs, and her role at Google at the time of leaving was leading the Open Research Institute, which you might imagine has nothing to do with drive. But no I'm not going to share confidential information just because you don't believe me.
- cobookman 7y agoSry. Source was from a blind thread. Not an internal thread. Mixed the two up https://us.teamblind.com/s/5YFH3CqL https://us.teamblind.com/s/5YFH3CqL
- AdmiralAsshat 7y agohttps://www.wired.com/story/google-walkout-organizers-say-theyre-facing-retaliation/ https://www.wired.com/story/google-walkout-organizers-say-th... >In a message posted to many internal Google mailing lists Monday, Meredith Whittaker, who leads Google’s Open Research, said that after the company disbanded its external AI ethics council on April 4, she was told that her role would be “changed dramatically.” Whittaker said she was told that, in order to stay at the company, she would have to “abandon” her work on AI ethics and her role at AI Now Institute, a research center she cofounded at New York University. >Claire Stapleton, another walkout organizer and a 12-year veteran of the company, said in the email that two months after the protest she was told she would be demoted from her role as marketing manager at YouTube and lose half her reports. After escalating the issue to human resources, she said she faced further retaliation. “My manager started ignoring me, my work was given to other people, and I was told to go on medical leave, even though I’m not sick,” Stapleton wrote. After she hired a lawyer, the company conducted an investigation and seemed to reverse her demotion. “While my work has been restored, the environment remains hostile and I consider quitting nearly every day,” she wrote. Both are now gone.
- duxup 7y agoIf you don't like the ethics council... and you protest it, and then they disband it ... that would involve a dramatic change if your role was on it. Retaliation or not, there would be some change. So any change, not sure I buy is/isn't retaliation.
- knd775 7y agoI don't believe she protested the AI ethics council.
- duxup 7y agoI'm pretty there was some protest surrounding the ethics council.
- SolaceQuantum 7y ago
- medecau 7y agoMaybe read the article? > Google soon nixed the board. > Whittaker said her Google manager told her to "abandon [her] work on AI ethics" and blocked a request to transfer internally.
- cobookman 7y agoShe asked to be moved to RMI. No hiring manager in RMI wanted her on their team, and she didn't complete the ladder transfer process. Instead demanding a forced transfer. Could be wrong here, but that's how it was presented internally by Meredith herself.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cobookman 7y agoSry. Source was from a blind thread. Not an internal thread. Mixed the two up https://us.teamblind.com/s/5YFH3CqL https://us.teamblind.com/s/5YFH3CqL
- dmix 7y agoI’m surprised Google’e executives would direct their managers to prevent what their employees are doing politically in their spare time...
- bougalou 7y agoThey weren't. Meredith was employed full time at Google and using all of that time to work on AI Now. It was her work time.
- joeyrideout 7y agoIANAL, but nothing I've read in sibling comments and other threads fits the legal definition of retaliation. Realigning priorities in a way that the employee doesn't like, sure, but not technically retaliation from a legal perspective. EDIT: To clarify, Google's reaction isn't the disqualifier, it's that the employee's action of staging a political walkout isn't legally protected since it conflicts with contractual duties and isn't a typical case of utilizing good faith channels for whistleblowing illegal activity. That type of channel is typically what's protected from retaliation. Not to mention working with someone accused of a crime isn't illegal. Association is a freedom and lobbying to change it is purely political.
- Bootvis 7y agoThat is besides the point. If Google retaliated in any way it's bad.
- BonesJustice 7y agoIt depends on which protections you're talking about (note: IANAL either). From what I can gather, it's true that the organizers may not be covered under laws protecting employees who report concerns internally or file EEOC or OSHA complaints. However, any activities related to collective bargaining (which may absolutely include organizing and participating in protests) are legally protected under the National Labor Relations Act, and would not be affected by "contractual duties" or "utilizing good faith channels for whistleblowing." Whether the organizers were covered by the NLRA is another matter; those with direct reports are likely excluded by the 'supervisors' exemption, which has been expanded over the years to cover pretty much anyone in a managerial role. For those who are covered, Google's actions could absolutely meet the legal definition of retaliation. As an aside, the legal standards for what constitutes 'retaliation' are not the only ones that matter. They may manage to avoid a lawsuit, but they will suffer harm to their reputation regardless. I, for one, could not care less whether the law allows them to retaliate against the protest organizers. To me, this is just one in a long line of reasons why I scratched Google off my "short list" of potential employers.
- joeyrideout 7y ago