4 ms·
Google works like crazy to hire all of the smartest and the best people, but do they really need them? Billions and billions in shareholder value could be extra
by whatshisface 7y ago
Google works like crazy to hire all of the smartest and the best people, but do they really need them? Billions and billions in shareholder value could be extracted by hiring a bunch of mid-tier Java programmers and having them farm Ad Words for the next decade, until the first competition shows up.
- ulfw 7y agoMany great people are hired not necessarily to move Google forward, but so that they don’t move a Google-competitor forward.
- dmurdoch 7y agoThis makes me think about something. I don't work at a FAANG company, nor have I ever been to SV, nor do I know anyone who works at one of the many enormous tech companies around SV. In the TV show Silicon Valley they have characters who sit around unassigned doing nothing at the Google-like company in the show. Does this actually happen? Are there people hired at these companies who just don't have a project? Its entirely feasible that Google could afford to do this just to create a dearth of engineers in the area.
- colonelpopcorn 7y agoI seem to remember reading an article on "rest and vest" employees. Here it is: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14943146 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14943146
- ulfw 7y agoWhat happens is that some people work on projects that never see the light of day because they’re not fully thought through or fully staffed or really as important enough. But they can still spend years working on them. The show is (by design) over the top. But there is a piece of truth in it. That’s why it’s funny for everyone who has been at these companies because everyone can see real-life resemblances. Before someone downvotes me: I am implying that SOME people are like this. By no means the majority or god-forbid everyone. Resting till vesting is a real thing though.
- lallysingh 7y agoThe number of PhDs writing basic JavaScript was astounding.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- asark 7y agoI have, in the last year, twice been hired then found myself way under-utilized because the company wasn't really ready to do anything with me, or the thing they hired me for fell through, or whatever. A few years ago I was brought on to a mid-sized business software company as part of an acquisition, and in the short time before I ran away was used at maybe 1/8 capacity in the most anti-productivity low-wall-cubicle open-floorplan office I've ever experienced. Organizational/planning/managerial waste of expensive developer time is real and huge. I'd be surprised if companies the size of Google didn't do similar things some of the time, and if their management's a little more clueful than average they might even make such light-weight or non-assignments official and highly visible to make them easier to account for.
- oldmanhorton 7y agoGoogle has been implicated in this in the past (though I disagree that fuschia is solely a retention program): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17569631 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17569631
- justaguyhere 7y agoWoah, it must feel great to have so much money to do this kind of "defensive" hires!!
- wastedhours 7y ago> until the first competition shows up Their worry is that competition will be started by the people they've not hired and kept on the bench. I'd imagine a large amount of their top-level hiring is driven by taking minds off of the market, more than optimising their output.
- spamizbad 7y agoMicrosoft used this strategy successfully for a while.
- brlewis 7y agoWith all the good Open Source stuff coming out of Microsoft lately, I think the people in charge of keeping them on the bench are slacking.
- KirinDave 7y agoThis couldn't ever work. Folks that smart want to do things that are real.
- wastedhours 7y agoIt has worked, perhaps not for long, but outweighted sums of cash to play with a nice side project or work on an actual "at scale" thing whilst you vest some shares probably appeals to a lot more smart people than we might imagine. Salaries are also deductible, so they get the talent in their pool, off the market, adding a small % of value, whilst also being able to offset taxes on record profits. It's a pretty nice win-win for them.
- gizmo686 7y agoReal != profitable. Google can offer academic style oppurtunities at industry style salaries. Eg. Fuchsia OS might have been started because Google saw a bussines oppurtunity in writing an open source capabilities OS. Or, it might have been started to keep smart OS engineers from leaving the company.
- coliveira 7y agoThey're not hiring these people because they need them, but because they want to avoid other companies from hiring them and doing something big and disruptive.
- majani 7y agoGoogle's stock price would drop sharply if they went into maintenance mode right now. One of the main reasons they command the crazy high valuation they do today is because they remain on the cutting edge of the latest technology, which demonstrates an ability to adapt to the ever changing winds in their sector.
- dlp211 7y agoGoogle does not have a crazy high valuation. They trade at a forward PE of around 24 which is well within a normal valuation for a maturing growth company.
- 0815test 7y ago> by hiring a bunch of mid-tier Java programmers Replace Java with Go (not much of a change, all things considered!) and that's exactly what Google seems to be doing. It's a big problem for them in the long run because it does mean accruing a mass of technical debt that will not necessarily be easy to get rid of. You'd expect "smart" folks in a tech-oriented enterprise to do better than that, especially if they're unutilized otherwise, but it can't be easy to do that sort of management at Google scale.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoDo you not think that other companies hire all of the smartest and best people? Does Amazon, which runs N% of the worlds internet traffic not apply?
- paxys 7y agoAnd what happens when the competition shows up? IBM, Oracle, VMWare, Cisco, RIM, ebay etc. were all where Google is now, and by the time they realized they couldn't compete any more it was too late. Google can only counter these threats by keeping the smartest people in the industry employed and happy.