4 ms·
Having 911 recordings public is one of the most insane things about this country. Why not make my doctor visits public too?
by BurningFrog 7y ago
Having 911 recordings public is one of the most insane things about this country.
Why not make my doctor visits public too?
- _jal 7y ago911 recordings are records generated by public servants, and have implications for the wider public. This is similar to court records, which are also default-public. Unless you're contagious, your health has no wider public implications. And if you are, your wishes are also going to be ignored.
- mruts 7y agoI mean it wouldn’t be right to publish a list of all the people with AIDS, right? That could have some implications for the public but it still probably shouldn’t be available.
- mnw21cam 7y agoThankfully, that particular one is hopefully dealt with by the fact that deliberately infecting someone with AIDS is punishable and hopefully deterred. The whole world doesn't need to know that a person has AIDS for that person to take necessary steps to avoid infecting people.
- BurningFrog 7y ago> This is similar to court records, which are also default-public It's hard for me to see how the trial of a rapist is similar to a rape victim calling for help. The trial needs to be public so we can monitor the application of justice in the legal system. The details of somebody's worst moments of their life needs to be public because...? If I ever need to call 911, I want to only focus on getting help fast. But as it is, I also need to think about how I'll sound if this call is being played on the news or Twitter.
- dvtrn 7y agoThe same details of a rape (and probably more details than many people even want) would very likely come up in court just the same, you know.
- qtplatypus 7y agoBut courts will anonymize the victim and can seal records.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> The details of somebody's worst moments of their life needs to be public because...? The article highlights cases where the 911 records revealed misconduct or negligence.
- Nasrudith 7y agoIt is important conceptually because it involves essentially a petition of government power and a check on abuse on both sides. If they provides absolutely horrible public service as in callously calling the rape victim a slut who deserves it and then later denied the misconduct and circles the wagons that is important. Or if the abuser of the calls isn't held accountable. Transparency vs privacy isn't a straightforward matter and there is ample room for debate and differences in opinion.
- tzs 7y agoUsing them to monitor abuse does not require making them public. It just requires making them available to those who claim they were abused, or if they did not survive their estate or whoever would have had medical power of attorney for them or someone similar.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThe same arguments apply to making my doctor visits public. At least if I go to a government employed or financed doctor.
- kbenson 7y ago
- SilasX 7y agoAh, so they should only release the contents of your doctor checkup if the doctor is a government employee, like in the UK.
- Spooky23 7y agoThey already are. At least a dozen third parties have access to most material aspects of your care. Public 911 recordings are essential as they are the a key way to evaluate the performance of the public safety services. Dispatch is public as well and should remain that way.
- efdee 7y agoUnder the same reasoning, why aren't tax filings and returns automatically made public?
- Spooky23 7y agoI think it should be. I’m a public employee. My salary is listed on a website. My investments, debts, certain assets, outside activities, and the same for my spouse are a FOIA away.
- efdee 7y agoI could understand the bit about your salary. All the others, not so much. How is this anyone's business?
- BurningFrog 7y agoA dozen professionals being able to review the notes of my doctor visit is vastly different from a video of it being public on the internet.