2 ms·
"Google's core search/ads is hyperprofitable, which has nothing to do with productivity of the current workers and everything to do with accumulated spectacular
by rahimnathwani 7y ago
"Google's core search/ads is hyperprofitable, which has nothing to do with productivity of the current workers and everything to do with accumulated spectacular R&D that created the amazing product that it is today."
Your gripe seems to be that the definition of labour productivity (output, i.e. revenue, divided by the number of people) is flawed. Intuitively you are correct, because a layperson wouldn't consider either of the following to be true:
1) An engineer becomes 10x as productive when they move from an early stage startup to a FAANG job.
2) A labourer doing job X in a company became twice as productive from one week to the next, because 50% of his colleagues (doing job Y) were just fired and replaced with machines.
I share the same dissatisfaction with the label (although it's a useful measure, it's something different from how it sounds).
However, this dissatisfaction doesn't have any bearing on whether Baumol's cost disease exists. As you say, it does.
If labour is the dominant cost for most companies in the economy, then labour productivity is a natural thing to measure, and natural thing to optimise. If, on the other hand, labour is a small proportion (e.g. due to automation, monopoly/network effects, etc.) then it starts to look special, and more just like any other input (e.g. electricity or copper).