4 ms·
Most metals can be used to successfully make thermite when paired with appropriate metal oxides. It is a very simple thermodynamics equation that determines whi
by jandrewrogers 7y ago
Most metals can be used to successfully make thermite when paired with appropriate metal oxides. It is a very simple thermodynamics equation that determines which combos work well. The main considerations are the net energy release of the reaction, which can vary widely, and the amount of energy required to bootstrap the reaction, which can be extremely high. Classic thermite -- aluminum and iron oxide -- is a middling combo but has the large benefits of being dirt cheap and low density.
Designing exotic thermites is a literal direct application of the elementary reaction thermodynamics that you learn in basic chemistry classes. Bootstrapping ignition is a bit more involved and often multi-stage.
- DonHopkins 7y agoThe article says: "Rather, the cause lies in a more exotic and unanticipated chemical/material interaction between a plumbing valve, liquid oxidizer, and a helium-based pressurization system." How can chemical interactions be "exotic"? Or did they mean "exothermic" or "exciting" or "esoteric"? Is "exotic" a technical term, or did the chemicals simply come from a distant foreign country, and how does that affect their physical properties? https://www.quora.com/What-are-exotic-compounds-in-chemistry https://www.quora.com/What-are-exotic-compounds-in-chemistry Is there such a thing as non-baryonic titanium? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_matter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_matter >Hypothetical particles and states of matter that have "exotic" physical properties that would violate known laws of physics, such as a particle having a negative mass. I can understand why you'd want to fill a rocket with exotic matter of negative mass: to make it lighter! ;)
- asark 7y agoI'd take it to mean "not supposed to be there; from outside (the place where the reaction happened)". Webster's 1913 for "exotic" includes: extraneous. Same source for "extraneous" includes: without or beyond a thing; not essential or intrinsic; foreign.
- jandrewrogers 7y agoThe term "exotic" in a chemistry context means one of two things. First, it can mean observed chemistry that is seen neither in nature nor the lab under ordinary conditions. In other words, it is theoretically possible but the required conditions are so atypical that the expected probability of it occurring unintentionally are very small. I'm guessing this is the case that applies here. Second, "exotic" can mean engineered chemistry that is far outside the standard industrial spectrum, typically because there is a unique application with very special requirements. Industrial chemistry is all about price performance of the chemistry not absolute performance, but some use cases are more performance sensitive than price sensitive so people will design bespoke and unusual ("exotic") chemistry for the purpose. It is a curve. Everyone uses the cheapest chemistry that still does the job adequately.
- VLM 7y agoIn my lab its just another day at the office and with my suppliers and budget its boring COTS. To work with substance X, which is called "exotic", you need an upgrade beyond my lab's equipment and safety gear and training, my suppliers consider it custom work if they can provide at all, and the budget has another couple zeros. More simply, its politely described as "exotic" if you go to a conference and talk about it and people are jealous of your gear / skills / budget / risk taking. An electronics analogy is a dude who can't solder at all thinks thru-hole soldering is exotic skills and equipment. A dude good at thru-hole thinks SMD is exotic. A dude with good SMD ability thinks owning your own bare die wire-bonder is exotic. A dude with great wire-bond ability thinks working at a foundry and designing custom monolithic microwave chips is exotic. I have no idea what a custom microwave chip designer would think is exotic, probably some Area 51 stuff involving UFOs, realistically maybe working as a physical chemist or as an experimental semiconductor physicist. Those guys probably think super colliders and warp drives and fusion reactors are exotic, I donno.
- vikramkr 7y agoI know that its theoretically possible to make thermite, I'm more referring to whether it is as easy as making the aluminum version where most people could make it if they tried hard enough in their garage (assuming you arent trying to make thermite if you live in an apartment).
- ethbro 7y agoWhat are you going to use to convert titanium into a powder?
- taneq 7y agoYou can cut it with a carbide saw, presumably this makes powder? https://tmstitanium.com/how-titanium-is-cut/ https://tmstitanium.com/how-titanium-is-cut/
- jandrewrogers 7y agoThe clever chemistry way would be to dissolve it and then precipitate it. However, titanium would be significantly more difficult than most metals as it is atypically resistant to many common acids.
- smileysteve 7y agoMagnesium ferrite https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xHHZtwS9U80 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xHHZtwS9U80
- jandrewrogers 7y agoFor DIY home brew, aluminum would be the obvious choice by far. Controlling the particle characteristics would be a bit of a challenge though. Metals that burn easily, such as magnesium or calcium, are not necessarily great choices as they will be limited by the thermodynamics of the metal oxide and ease of burning does not imply optimal thermite performance. In fairness, way back when I was playing thermites I just bought the required materials. Metal oxides in particular tend to be boring chemicals and arguably the more malleable half of that equation. Of course, this was in the 1990s when you could legally buy military explosives with a driver's license and cash...
- dzhiurgis 7y agoCan you make a thermite rocket out of thermite and starlite?