4 ms·
But that's most port standards that have ever existed. What can a device do with a parallel port? A serial port? A SCSI port? A Firewire port? Who knows? It's
by derefr 7y ago
But that's most port standards that have ever existed.
What can a device do with a parallel port? A serial port? A SCSI port? A Firewire port? Who knows? It's up to the device. It can certainly send signals over that port, of some kind. But what kind of signals? Up to the device. The host can hopefully probe a device-class out of the client and stand up an appropriate driver to talk to it.
A CD player has a 3.5mm audio jack. Pop quiz: does it support SPDIF? In fact, is it line-level or phono-level output? (An important question to avoid blowing out your equipment!) Answer, in both cases: who knows?
You find a random CAT-6 drop in the wall. Does it contain Ethernet? Does it contain Power-over-Ethernet? Does it contain both? No way to know without asking someone or plugging it in.
Or, for a slightly more interesting example of a "port": what can a random peripheral board do with a motherboard's PCI-e (or PCI, or ISA, or any historical equivalent) port? Well, whatever it likes. Does anyone expect every PCI card to be simultaneously a network card, graphics card, sound card, RAID card, etc., just because those are all things PCI can carry? Of course not. PCI-e is a single port, and a single protocol (sort of), but that doesn't mean it's a single set of exposed capabilities.
- beefalo 7y agoI think one of the things that makes USB-C particularly problematic here is that "plug it in and find out" can be harmful to devices since devices can draw 100W of power through the port.
- cesarb 7y ago> since devices can draw 100W of power through the port Devices can only draw 100W of power, which is 5A at 20V, after negotiation; before negotiation (or if negotiation fails), only 5V is available, like in the older USB connector types.
- jazzyjackson 7y agoWell that's the spec but I've personally had a Google Pixel melt its own charging port when plugged in with a cheap USBC cable off amazon.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThere's a difference. In most of those cases, you can expect to pull out any fitting cable for that port and the device will do what it's meant to do. There was a little confusion with 3.5mm jack, but the plugs were trivially inspectable (you could count how many connections they had). With USB-C, whether or not a device will do all, some, or any at all of its functions, depends not just on the device, but on what you're connecting it to and which one of the countless types of cables you happen to have, all of which look identical to someone who's not an EE with appropriate equipment. Makes me think, maybe I should start selling USB-C cable testers, because if old USB taught me anything, is that you can't trust cable manufacturers to not lie, even if the cable standard is as simple as it gets.
- JohnFen 7y ago> But that's most port standards that have ever existed. That's also the problem that USB solved. Until USB-C came around.
- dTal 7y agoI feel like there's some confusion over peripheral support, and host support. What can I do with a serial port? Everything. I can talk to every device that ever used a serial connection. Sure, I might need to write a driver, but that's really a separate issue. There's absolutely no problem with "your serial port does not support <gibberish> so you can't use this particular mouse/printer/random industrial equipment". With your PCIe example, again - I don't expect every card to do everything. But I do expect every card to work on my computer's PCIe bus.