3 ms·
> Also people forget that the creepy stuff Google does is super useful. For the same reasons you’re exalting them, I have non-technical friends who asked me ho
by latexr 7y ago
> Also people forget that the creepy stuff Google does is super useful.
For the same reasons you’re exalting them, I have non-technical friends who asked me how Google knows so much about them (and suggestions on how to avoid it) because they found it too creepy.
I don’t think people forget Google’s results are useful; some just think they’re more creepy than valuable. You seem to have picked your side in that (im)balance, and other people prefer the other side.
There’s also the relevant consideration that no matter how useful they may be, they should have no right to impose themselves on you. By this I mean that one should be free to refuse their creepiness, understanding the price is their usefulness. Yet, Google is the subject of privacy violations all the time, and they are caught time and again lying about what they collect on users.
- lostctown 7y agoI wish interfaces were more straight up about their intentions and made it easier to implement account level partitions. For work I love Google's magic tracking effects, but at 1 am, hell no.
- mjevans 7y agoIt would be immensely useful if Google understood that normal people have multiple facades that they use in different contexts. Probably several professional (which project / component was I working on again), private but family friendly (planning gifts for relatives, etc), and private but clearly out there (stuff you don't want to shock 60 year old parents / young kids / etc with) profiles. Also, for incognito stuff, it'd be nice to have read-only basing on stock profiles related to various activities or people.
- arwineap 7y agoYou can have multiple identities in chrome[0], even guest identities. [0] https://support.google.com/chrome/answer/2364824 https://support.google.com/chrome/answer/2364824
- lostctown 7y agoRight. I'm just saying it should be clearer. Ex: I want to have a list of accounts, netflix style, that I'm presented with on an empty chrome window. If in fact multiple identities don't merge data implicitly in anyway than this is just a UI issue. But I have a hard time believing google truly partitions everything in a multi account setup.
- reroute1 7y agoIt is actually possible to operate without relying on Google or any other big tech firm. Who is forcing you into these privacy dilemmas? All of their services are a choice you are making. You don't need to accept any of it if you don't want to.
- latexr 7y ago> You don't need to accept any of it if you don't want to. Tell that to the people who had their privacy violated by Street View[1]. And the people who specifically disabled location services on their Android devices but were still tracked[2]. Or all the people who have no idea what Google Analytics is and never consented to it, but are profiled by it everyday. > All of their services are a choice you are making. I do my best to avoid privacy invading companies, and as a technical user I find it tiring and know I deal with consequences (e.g. broken websites). It perplexes me that comments like yours still pop up. We’re not the only segment of the population that exists; non-technical users are the majority, and they have the same right to privacy as we do, with a modicum of transparency. If even technical people are regularly tripped by privacy invasions we didn’t know about, what chances do non-technical users have? [1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/13/technology/google-pays-fine-over-street-view-privacy-breach.html https://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/13/technology/google-pays-fi... [2]: https://qz.com/1131515/google-collects-android-users-locations-even-when-location-services-are-disabled/ https://qz.com/1131515/google-collects-android-users-locatio...
- reroute1 7y agoStreet view is debatably invasive. I understand this might seem hand wavy to someone really concerned about privacy issues, but 1.generally speaking I would think VERY few people care about an image of their property being on street views. 2. It's not really illegal to take pictures so even from a legal standpoint it seems like a gray area. 3. I understand there can be individual reasons for not wanting this, but it seems to be a very large net positive. And I would apply that statement to most other tracking and data policies they have. If they are lying about how their services track people, that is definitely grounds for concern. The transparency can definitely be improved, but still these are people with Android phones and people using Google Analytics. No one is forced to use these things they are free to use any other service or create their own. And my attitude is out of pragmatism and how I think privacy issues should be handled. I don't have any problem with the way Google uses my data so I don't care to fix a non problem. And I don't see it as their responsibility to change a way of business when anyone is free to use any other service or create their own, since I don't find it offensive.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI don’t think people forget Google’s results are useful; some just think they’re more creepy than valuable. You seem to have picked your side in that (im)balance, and other people prefer the other side. Just as a general observation without taking either side: People routinely fail to recognize both sides of a particular thing. It's why we have sayings like "You don't know what you've got til it's gone."