4 ms·
> There is no pay difference no matter what project you work on I've heard that you'll get raises for working on new things. That's why Google launches so many
by vbezhenar 7y ago
> There is no pay difference no matter what project you work on
I've heard that you'll get raises for working on new things. That's why Google launches so many new projects (and closes so many of those projects) and that's why old projects are constantly rewritten/redesigned instead of just imprpoving and bugfixing. I don't like it as a user, I want to use the same interface for 50 years and I want all bugs to be removed, rather than learning new interface and new bugs every few years.
- nostrademons 7y agoYou get promoted by shipping stuff (at least, when I was there). You get a raise by getting promoted. So there's an indirect connection between launching things and getting more money. I think that the OP's referring to a phenomena at different big companies where certain divisions get paid more because management deems that division more important. That creates a dynamic where everybody tries to get into that division, and the ones that can't end up bitter, demoralized, and resentful (and hence unproductive). Connecting pay to tangible accomplishments rather than where you are in the company avoids that dynamic, though it does create the one you've observed where everyone is hunting for tangible accomplishments.
- MarkMc 7y agoI'd say failure to align financial incentives is a bigger problem than jealousy of colleagues in the staff cafeteria. Zoom has crushed Google Hangouts and is now a $27 billion company, yet the Hangouts team are still rewarded with sweet Google stock options.
- nostrademons 7y agoArguably both alternatives lead to the big company getting crushed in emerging markets. If you pay for performance in hot emerging markets you cause resentment in all the other divisions, which leads to them underperforming (which is often a more dangerous problem, since this includes the slow-growing cash cow divisions that finance the fast-growing emerging markets). If you don't pay for performance, everybody gets complacent, and you miss out on new markets to hot new competitors. I spent 5 years at Google hoping the intrapreneurship thing would work. AFAICT it doesn't, and eventually I came to accept Paul Graham's conclusion that big companies are constitutionally incapable of innovating and that's why he makes lots of money funding startups. In my observations the biggest problem isn't even compensation: it's that there are too many roadblocks to launching things and trying things out in a big company, too much incentive to be risk-averse, and too little feedback from the market itself with too much feedback from irrelevant decision-makers within the organization. The flip side of fixing those is that it radically increases both the failure rate and the rate at which the company pisses off outside people, both of which would be fatal at Google's scale. IMHO the way Google does compensation is the best I've seen, it's just that "the best" will still result in good companies getting crushed by upstarts. So just accept that and try to create a good working environment while the company continues to print cash.
- UncleMeat 7y agoThis is misleading. It is true that people are rewarded for impact, which usually means new systems. But this does not necessarily mean new products from an external perspective. I know a lot of people who have been promoted really high based on stuff that they have led that has zero visibility to external users but ends up being worth oodles of money (or whatever metric you are trying to impact). Zillions of product launches seems to arise from a combination of a largely bottom-up company with a ton of employees and a culture of building things themselves rather than using existing solutions.