5 ms·
I think it is possible to make way, way better search engine because Google Search is no longer as good as it used to, at least for me. I can no longer find an
by mrtksn 7y ago
I think it is possible to make way, way better search engine because Google Search is no longer as good as it used to, at least for me.
I can no longer find anything remotely good quality, I discover new and quality stuff from social media like Twitter and HN.
The search results seem to be too general and too mainstream. Nothing new to discover, just a shortcut to the few websites like Reddit, StackOverflow for more techie thing and Wikipedia and the few mainstream news websites for the rest.
I usually end up to search HN, Reddit or StackOverflow directly as the resulting quality is better as I can get easily specific. Getting specific is harder on Google because it just omits or misinterprets my search query keywords quite often.
- nostrademons 7y agoThe reason for that is because Google's building for a mainstream audience, because the mainstream (by definition) is much bigger than any niche. They increase aggregate happiness (though not your specific happiness) a lot more by doing so. It's probably possible to build a search engine for a specific vertical that's better than Google. However, you face a few really big problems that make this not worthwhile: 1) Speaking from experience, it's very difficult to define what "better" means when you don't have exemplars of what queries are likely and what the results should be. The reason search engines are a product is that they let us find things we didn't know existed before; if we don't know they exist, how can we tweak the search engine to return them? 2) People go to a search engine because it has the answers for their question, no matter what their question is. If you had a specific search engine for games, and another for celebrities, and another for flights, and another for hotels, and another for books, and another for power tools, and another for current events, and another for technical documentation, and another for punditry, and another for history, and another to settle arguments on the Internet, then pretty soon you'd need a search engine to find the appropriate search engine. We call this "Google", and as a consumer, it's really convenient if they just give us the answer directly rather than directing us to another search engine where we need to refine our query again. 3) Google makes basically 80% of their revenue from searches for commercial products or services (insurance, lawyers, therapists, SaaS, flowers, etc.) The remainder is split between AdSense, Cloud, Android, Google Play, GFiber, YouTube, DoubleClick, etc. (may be a bit higher now). Many queries don't even run ads at all - when was the last time you saw an ad on a technical programming query, or a navigational query like [facebook login]? All of these are cross-subsidized by the commercial queries, because there's a benefit to Google from it being the one place you go to look for answers. If you build a niche site just to give good answers to programming queries or celebrity searches or current events, there's no business model there.
- mrtksn 7y agoSure, they have a business reason to do exactly what they do but I think as people grow up they specialize and the general stuff that fits everybody becomes useless. Google tries to personalize search results but that so far yielded echo chambers, not personalized discoveries. I can't get better products by searching Google, I can get the best-spammed products or most promoted products only. The fact that I am getting low-quality service and Google is printing money means that there is a place for good a good service and if that service cannot emerge due to Google's practices, it probably means that the regulators need to take action. Or maybe the search is dead, long live social media. The gist is, I am not happy with a service but the company that makes that product makes a lot of maney. Can't tell if I am an anomaly or if other people feel the same way because Google is a monopoly and maybe the regulators should make it possible to compete with Google and see if there's a space for a better service. Yes yes, I am the product but I am the product only if I am happy with the stuff I'm getting in return.
- Yhippa 7y agoEverything turns into an echo chamber eventually.
- bryan_w 7y agoHow would google's practices stop me from creating a search engine? Keep in mind when Google started, Yahoooooo! Was the big player and Google overtook them by simply being better
- tripzilch 7y ago... in return for you being the product? Haha. I don't think Google sees their end of that "transaction" being an actual transaction. You're an individual, and Google doesn't deal with those.
- altcognito 7y ago> It's probably possible to build a search engine for a specific vertical that's better than Google. Funny, I don't disagree with this, but my perception has been that Google seems to detect when I've switched roles from one type of programmer to another. I don't know if that's organic from the topics I'm looking up or not, but if I'm looking up a generic string search, it seems to return whatever language I've been searching for recently. (very recently in fact) My point is, it seems like the search engine intuitively understands my "vertical" already. Maybe it's just because developer searches are probably pretty optimized.
- tills13 7y agoI see comments like this all the time. Am I alone in that search results, for me, have gotten significantly _better_ since a couple years ago? I can't help but think it's partially due to people using tools _specifically designed_ to make Google's job harder (FF SandBoxes, uBlock, etc) and not understanding the implications of using them... and then blaming Google for returning "bad" results.
- jammygit 7y agoI get a lot more seo spam than I used to, but the results are still quite good. I think we should give google some credit for that at least. Like, a lot more seo spam though.
- tills13 7y agoPeople have gotten really good (i.e. it's their full-time job) at "gaming" Google. That's not to say Google is fallible - every search engine is game-able depending on its algorithm - it's just that these people are _very_ clever.
- ben509 7y agoThey don't even need to clever as much as persistent, because of the selection effects.
- marcescence 7y ago> specifically designed to make Google's job harder "Better search" doesn't necessarily mean "more personalized search."
- karolg 7y ago> Getting specific is harder on Google because it just omits or misinterprets my search query keywords quite often. I have this problem too. Google often thinks that I made a typo and presents me results for things I didn't searched for or care about and I have no way to force it to search for things I really want.
- tripzilch 7y agoThis is exactly when I switch to brain damage mode querying. You like fixing typos Google? Have some typos. You like figuring out what I really mean Google? Here, I'll formulate my query like a deranged toddler on PCP, best of luck! Maybe it just feels more successful because it lowers my expectations. But at least you get to mash the keyboard like a maniac, do no corrections, press return and watch it just work. It's kind of like watching Google do a "customer is always right" squirm.