4 ms·
Is having someone as a student, and then they leave ... beneficial? I don't have a position on this, I'm just wondering.
by duxup 7y ago
Is having someone as a student, and then they leave ... beneficial?
I don't have a position on this, I'm just wondering.
- maximente 7y agolikely only for tenured professors and possibly universities. professors hold immense power and likely benefit greatly from someone motivated to finish + move back and earn massive sums relative to rest of population; the university i'm guessing benefits to some extent financially/prestige of said research group/professor. edit: losers are general public, whose taxes go to public universities who then train up a generation of students who won't contribute those benefits back to the country. private universities have different funding models of course, so not so clear there.
- ummonk 7y agoI thought taxpayers only subsidize in-state tuition?
- magduf 7y agoYes, exactly. Foreign students are actively recruited by universities because they're profitable: they have to pay the full fare.
- pjc50 7y ago> taxes go to public universities who then train up a generation of students who won't contribute those benefits back to the country I would be amazed if I could find a US accredited institution of higher education that offered subsidized education to non-nationals. > professors hold immense power Nothing to say about this other than "lol nope".
- ivalm 7y agoEspecially PhD students are ultra-cheap professional work force that drives forward US academic research. Furthermore, a big reason why so many return to China, is that even if you graduate in the US, staying in the US is quite hard. The environment is not welcoming in to the newly graduated US educated foreign origin PhDs.
- duxup 7y ago>Especially PhD students are ultra-cheap professional work force that drives forward US academic research. I'm not necessarily doubting it as this is not my area of expertise, but what % of students really do "ultra-cheap professional work force that drives forward US academic research"... that anyone else can't?
- ivalm 7y agoProfessors tend to act more as managers/grant proposal writers/reviewers. The vast majority of individual contributor work is performed by grad students and post docs. This work is often intellectually challenging (well, in as much as moving science forward is), so there is a strong benefit for selecting the best prepared candidates. Chinese students that come to do their PhDs in the US tend to be very well prepared/selected (especially once you look at non-ivy league research universities, it is easier to get a super qualified chinese student vs a US native student). Now, there might be a price point at which you could attract more locals to go pursue a PhD, but right now it is just not a very financially attractive proposition. PhD students typically get a stipend in the 30-40k range, but perform the kind of work that on the outside would pay 100-200k (let's say for people after masters). Similarly post docs make 40-70k range, but if they went into industry they would make 100-300k (depending on field).
- Symmetry 7y agoWell, it's a US export sector. US professors do work and foreign money flows into the US.