3 ms·
I’m of the opinion that US Companies (or companies operating in the us) selling software/hardware that is designed for the purpose of violating human rights or
by olliej 7y ago
I’m of the opinion that US Companies (or companies operating in the us) selling software/hardware that is designed for the purpose of violating human rights or the terms of the US constitution should be taxed at 100% of their international profits.
If you don’t believe the human rights or the US constitution are of any value you shouldn’t get to use those protections to profit. Move your company to China or wherever, and operate in the constraint you enforce on others.
- saagarjha 7y agoIs a computer or general purpose device shipped to China that someone uses for surveillance something that would qualify?
- olliej 7y agoIt’s not expressly design for that purpose - but censored search engines, search engines that report searches, software designed to spy on everyone, routers that intercept and report content people read, software managing concentration camps, etc all would. Much like the numerous suits against IBM for supporting the holocaust and the gratuitous human rights abuses in South Africa. Most of which were dropped due to the threats of delaying payments or the amount of time passed. The only way to stop companies from supporting human rights abuses is to remove their revenues from such. Google has demonstrated that given the choice it will happily support human rights abuses, while making use of the resources available in the US due to the existence of the constitution.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> Google has demonstrated that given the choice it will happily support human rights abuses You appear to be confusing Google with Apple. Google does not do business in China proper. Apple does and has handed over the keys to access any Chinese user's iCloud data at will.
- olliej 7y agoNo, it really didn't - it put the servers in china, much like in the US data is held in the US, and increasingly the EU data is held in the EU. The decryption keys are held on user devices. Apple never has access to those keys. By design. It's a very google-centric mindset that insists a company needs to have access to your data to be profitable. Apple's security white paper goes into great detail to explain how it ensures proper encryption of data, they have spent years working to remove all data that they have access to.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> The decryption keys are held on user devices. Apple never has access to those keys. You are confusing iMessages with iCloud. The keys to decrypt everybody's iCloud mail, iCloud drive files, photos, calendar, app backups, etc. are held on the server. By design. For Chinese users, these servers are now controlled by the PRC. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2018/02/5-things-you-need-to-know-about-apple-in-china/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2018/02/5-things-you-... The distinction for iMessages is also not relevant in practice. Whoever controls the keyserver (China) has the ability to wiretap all iMessages conversations. (Lie to Alice about Bob's public key, read the message Alice encrypted for Bob, and then encrypt with Bob's public key and send on to Bob.) https://www.lawfareblog.com/iphones-fbi-and-going-dark https://www.lawfareblog.com/iphones-fbi-and-going-dark I don't understand how Apple employees can justify working there knowing that they are directly helping the Chinese government find and disappear dissidents. They have not even tried to protest.
- cronix 7y agoWhat if those same companies are helping to power the NSA illegally collecting and storing data on Americans without a warrant? Is that different to you? Where in this Constitution you elude to does it permit that? I can show you precisely where it doesn't...
- olliej 7y agoNo. But it's also illegal for them to do that, and it's disgusting that the elected officials of the government continue to allow it to do so. Of course it's also only able to do it because for-profit companies are being paid for their assistance. I would argue that makes them criminals (knowingly aiding a criminal attack), and as such they should be charged with those crimes. The US government basically pleads sovereign immunity to violations of its own criminal attacks on US citizens, so charging the companies that assists them with those crimes, and also removing their profit motive, would hopefully kill off the NSA, ICE, and the DHS's continuous violations of the constitution.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> What if those same companies are helping to power the NSA illegally collecting and storing data on Americans without a warrant? What if those same companies were making nuclear bombs and blowing up large cities? Neither happens, so I cannot understand your point.