6 ms·
Certainly what environment you have should be a sort of organic / self developed / self serving kinda system. Make it your own. I do think when folks talk abo
by duxup 7y ago
Certainly what environment you have should be a sort of organic / self developed / self serving kinda system. Make it your own.
I do think when folks talk about little perks and the environment they're not talking about how having the right kind of cake, or three kinds of cake vs two kinds of cake available (just a generic example) is important. What they are really saying is "I see this company has put some resources into making this environment better, and that reflects their values and makes ME feel valued." Heck even if you don't eat the cake it is a sign.
It's akin to the story (I can't find it) where a company stopped providing free soda (or maybe they stopped subsidizing the price, I forget). The engineers were very upset, but it was just soda and god knows they could afford it.... but really it wasn't soda, the fact that management thought it was worth their time to pull resources from soda of all things was a very worrisome sign that indicated the company's values and possibly their future. Soda was the canary in the coal mine.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- VBprogrammer 7y agoI used to work at a company where each team member got a budget of ~£15 a month towards a team lunch which was typically saved up and spent once every 3 months. The bright spark who thought they could cut some costs by removing that perk probably cost the company 10x that just in the time people spent grumbling about it (it was eventually reinstated). While I think the reactions are a bit OTT (see my comment down thread); it's certainly true that companies do a very poor job of evaluating this kind of decision. One of my key indicators for when it's time to start brushing up my CV is when people spend an inordinate amount of effort trying to save a few quid on stationary when these things are rounding errors on the companies bottom line.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoActually I rejoice when companies cut bad, frivolous things like soda that negatively impact health and use aluminum; which is sometimes not recycled. Plus it's difficult to resist temptation when constantly working around food that's unhealthy yet very sweet and 'free'.
- cruano 7y agoYeah but you cut sodas and get fresh fruit, I absolutely agree that you shouldn't aid bad habits but just cutting that stuff hints at something else than "helping you be healthy"
- eanzenberg 7y agoMore realistically, if the company is cutting little bits here and there (soda, coffee, etc.) then it usually means tough times ahead. If a ~$1k monthly expense will make or break the budget, it's time to jump ship.
- duxup 7y agoThat and / or you've got penny pinching management and if penny pinching is what they think of as valuable use of their time ... you don't want to work with those folks.
- snoman 7y agoPrecisely because they're spending mental energy on how to cut $1,000/mo instead of spending that energy on how to bring in $1,000/mo. Then you get both.
- cgriswald 7y agoI've seen perks in place because the boss liked it, didn't have to pay for it personally, and almost certainly wrote it off as a business expense. That's also a sign.
- duxup 7y agoYeah I worked at a place where the leadership team would go out and golf in the afternoon ... often enough that you notice it. Generally I don't think much about those things, but it was often enough after awhile that it was "Yeah I'm stuck here and they...." Pretty easy for everyone in the office to sort of "check out" when it becomes a visible issue.
- mgkimsal 7y agoa colleague told me of a 'remote-only' company which ... cut mobile hotspots for 'on call' engineers. "no no no, this isn't a cost cutting measure". But the 5 people who were expected to rotate being 'on call' 24/7 - who had previously been able to schedule some 'away' time knowing they had hotspots - suddenly couldn't. The hotspots were ~$60/month, maybe? So, cutting $300/month, but still requiring the 24/7 rotation - this was a big morale hit. Oh, and later they gave every - (60+ people) a half-day 'off' to spend 'reducing your monthly bills' - they all got an email detailing how to call your cable company to save $10/month on your cable, and scripts to use to reduce your cell phone bill, etc.
- lwb 7y ago> It's akin to the story (I can't find it) where a company stopped providing free soda https://steveblank.com/2009/12/21/the-elves-leave-middle-earth-%E2%80%93-soda%E2%80%99s-are-no-longer-free/ https://steveblank.com/2009/12/21/the-elves-leave-middle-ear...
- duxup 7y agoThank you! HN users are so good at remembering these things for me ;)
- gopalv 7y ago> It's akin to the story (I can't find it) where a company stopped providing free soda It's a memorable one, because it was "soda is now 50 cents". https://steveblank.com/2009/12/21/the-elves-leave-middle-earth-%e2%80%93-soda%e2%80%99s-are-no-longer-free/ https://steveblank.com/2009/12/21/the-elves-leave-middle-ear... Though free soda at work-place will probably sound like a cigarette tin at the receptionist, when a company switches from growth to cut-costs, it is a clear indication that there's a transition towards "dead wood" clearing layoffs. And the more successful the first round of layoffs are (and they should be, because the hiring process isn't perfect), the more likely there will be more ... etc.
- gwbas1c 7y agoI remember joining a major company right after it went public. I was shocked at how little oversight there was at spending. There were also a lot of people who just weren't pulling their weight in the company and soaking up the freebies. About a year later, the CEO was fired and we had a less than AWESOME quarter. We needed to do some cost trimming, like all well-run businesses need to do. (The obvious thing to do was to scrutinize costs, and offer a few people a generous severance.) I was shocked that a bunch of employees (and my manager) rallied around getting rid of free soda. It was like they just wanted to extend the free ride for everyone, so they suggested the most obvious way to feel pain instead of finding something to get rid of that we didn't need.
- duxup 7y agoCost cutting is such a weird thing as it is often so superficially measured. I worked at a company that slowly but surely cut travel options in order to limit travel costs. Except for the sales group.... the group the traveled the most. After a couple quarters they hilariously sent out an email noting that travel costs were not going down fast enough, insinuated that people weren't watching their expenses close enough, and if everyone didn't do a better job that they'd have to limit the sales travel budget too. I suspect the person who sent the email couldn't / didn't think critically about what message they sent everyone else in the company. Needless to say the costs didn't drop. Even more amusing they decided that car rentals were too expensive, so they banned car rentals (but not for sales). I was to take a taxi or public transit wherever I went. The results was that it cost about 3x as much in local travel costs when I traveled. I actually accounted for it all, wrote up a report with charts about how a car saves the company money on my trips. I was told not to tell the travel team anymore as their management didn't want to hear it.
- dtech 7y agoCost cutting is the source of the most ludicrous penny wise pound foolish decisions in the world. Spend $25k year on a SaaS? Throw it out and create an internal system. Nevermind that 4 people spend a month building it and you now 0.8FTE maintaining an inferior and buggy system. Employee costs are going on the big pile and aren't as directly measured.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- JohnFen 7y agoOn the other hand, there are companies that decide to put effort into little employee "perks" like that rather than putting effort into improving the things that really matter, because it's cheaper and easier to stock a soda machine than to solve institutional problems. For this reason, I don't consider the existence of stuff like that to be a reliable indicator of anything at all. When a company does this, it neither impresses me nor puts me off.
- duxup 7y agoI think institutional problems are really another issue entirely.
- rightbyte 7y agoNot really, I belive it's important. I worked as a teacher and we had to the handle coffee machine ourselfs. Every week there was a coffee teacher and we put money in a jar. Alot of energy and frustration was caused by this and most likely no money saved for the school.
- HelloNurse 7y agoThe comparison is with companies that put effort into actively annoying employees with cost-cutting measures and general disregard. For example, if you aren't impressed by free snacks you would be impressed by a strict policy of no food in the office with no place to eat.
- wpietri 7y agoI totally agree on the make-it-your-own bit being important. An awful lot of places are unable/unwilling to think about their environment holistically and from first principles. So execs cargo-cult the visible things from successful companies. The classic example for me is the ping-pong table. Can they be a useful way to get cross-team interaction and bonding that increases the company's ability to solve cross-cutting problems? Sure. But they are often bought because that's what startups do. E.g., the photo recently going around Twitter of the ping-pong table marked with "NO PLAYING BEFORE 6 PM".
- duxup 7y ago> the photo recently going around Twitter of the ping-pong table marked with "NO PLAYING BEFORE 6 PM" I love how that completely sends the opposite message. It is convenient though, it makes it clear that the management team (as a team, maybe some are ok) has no ability, or can't be bothered to imagine how other people think / respond / feel.
- pjc50 7y agoOh God, my previous employer did that. We had a ping-pong table, because it was trendy. We had an open plan office, because it was trendy. And, because the person making decisions wasn't thinking of actual development, we had the ping-pong table in the open plan office. Open warfare broke out between the people who liked playing it and the people who were driven mad by the noise while trying to get work done. It was the most successful team destroying exercise I've ever seen. It was banned and reinstated at the whim of conflicting managers. Eventually someone discovered silent ping-pong balls and order and harmony was restored. A few months later I quit for a 15% pay rise.
- filmgirlcw 7y agoA former colleague of mine worked at Time Magazine in the late 1990s, before and after the AOL Time Warner merger. He said, “when AOL got rid of our Snapple, we knew it was all over.” (And for context, the salary/job stability for someone at Time Magazine in 2000 is very different than in 2019. As in, the pay was very good and there was job stability.) Similar to the soda story — it’s not that the employees can’t afford it themselves, it’s what it represents about not just the changing culture at the company, but of the financial realities. I once worked at a place where they suddenly started to decrease the snack budget (but didn’t say anything —- we just got fewer snacks and in fewer quantities each week). In hindsight, it was an indicator of some of the financial issues happening at the company. Ironically, after some layoffs (followed by the voluntary exodus of ~20% of the company), the snacks came back full blast as an attempt to raise morale, but by then it was too late.