4 ms·
> MIT received the first major Apollo contract, the only one awarded to a university, and the only one given without competitive bidding. Do these kinds of mis
by criddell 7y ago
> MIT received the first major Apollo contract, the only one awarded to a university, and the only one given without competitive bidding.
Do these kinds of mission-critical components generally go to the lowest bidder?
- ghaff 7y agoCompetitive bid doesn't have to mean lowest bidder. I've put tons of (non-government) projects out for bid because you're usually expected to do so to keep everyone relatively honest. I imagine the MIT Instrumentation Lab were the only people with the inertial guidance expertise at that time.
- benj111 7y ago"Competitive bid doesn't have to mean lowest bidder" No you have to wine and dine the right people, and line a job up for them when they retire.
- Jtsummers 7y agoWhich gets someone thrown in jail or a lot of fines these days. Not that it doesn't happen, but it's a lot harder to hide now than 20+ years ago.
- benj111 7y agoI was perhaps being slightly misanthropic. But the game keepers always seem to turn poacher. High ranking military bods end up with defence contractors. Financial regulators end up with working at banks (and visa versa), and politicians seem to end up getting various well paid consulting jobs. I suppose you could argue there are good reasons for it, I cant believe on some level these public servants aren't thinking of their career after retirement.
- datalus 7y agoI think bidding government contracts is a lot more complicated than just picking the cheapest option. There's a lot of other dimensions of validation that bids move through other than cost. For something like this, I'm sure there is stringent engineering validation. I know some initial NN research was part of a larger government project of funding research around stabilizing missiles in flight for ICBMs that was not cheap.
- silverfox17 7y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZlLmESPWyw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZlLmESPWyw
- segmondy 7y agoMIT was probably most knowledgeable about programming computers back then that anywhere else in the world.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoIt depends on the contract. Some contracts do go to the lowest bidder (the technical term that the contracting folks use is something like "lowest bid meeting technical requirements"). For those sorts of bids, it's extra important that the requirements that the government puts out are well written and thorough. Some procurements use the "best value" criteria. I think these contracts are more likely to be protested and have lawsuits filed by the losers. It's easy to say "I deserve this contract because $2 billion < $3 billion". Best value can be a bit more subjective.