4 ms·
I'm not German, but in the US I always thought it was a bit strange and concerning that we use taxdollars to train kids to use a proprietary, for-profit system.
by tombert 7y ago
I'm not German, but in the US I always thought it was a bit strange and concerning that we use taxdollars to train kids to use a proprietary, for-profit system. I understand that MS Office is (sadly) the industry standard, but how much of this is self-fulfilling, as in "it's the standard because that's what they teach, and it's what they teach because it's the standard".
You'll find similar things in school with software like Matlab; they give substantial discounts to universities for Matlab, these students because so used to it, and beg their employers to buy it, which they usually do.
Schools shouldn't be advertising vehicles for children, and I feel there should be a stronger emphasis on open technologies. Thank goodness MS can't create a proper equation editor to save their life, so LaTeX is still the standard for higher-level academia.
- beefhash 7y ago> Thank goodness MS can't create a proper equation editor to save their life, so LaTeX is still the standard for higher-level academia. Higher-level academia in STEM. Other fields are likely quite much sold on Word. I can imagine that, say, law is chock-full of people using Word.
- tombert 7y agoYeah, I realized that about ten seconds after I submitted; my mom is a lawyer and due to older standards and newer ones, they use Word for about 80% of stuff, and Wordperfect for about 20% (due to it being the standard in the federal courts for a long time).
- duxup 7y agoThe legal world is the land of the Luddites. There are very capable people too of course, but generally I've found that the legal world to contain a higher than average percentage of Luddites.
- tombert 7y agoI'm hesitant to call anyone a Luddite when I'm tacitly suggestion people use TeX, a piece of software made like 20 years before I was born :).
- duxup 7y agoHey nothing wrong with a tool that works.
- krferriter 7y agoWe could definitely use a replacement for LaTeX sometime soon. The syntax is pretty gross and the documents are difficult to understand. And if you move from using a single document to importing multiple distinct files into a main file it's quite difficult to find where a value or setting is coming from. I've found that most LaTeX documentation is merely contained within StackExchange answers, which are of highly variable quality, which is a pretty crappy user experience.
- tombert 7y agoHonestly, typically when I do “LaTeX” nowadays, I am really doing markdown for everything except equations, and using Pandoc to handle the conversion to something pretty. I think markdown is substantially better syntax than LaTeX.
- cwyers 7y agoYou'll find that a lot of businesses use Word and Excel because they have a large, large body of institutional knowledge built up in those systems, and especially in Excel, a set of business-critical files that nothing else can open properly. They aren't picking Office because it's what the kids fresh out of college know.
- zubspace 7y agoSoftware is one thing, but middle schools providing iPads to kids makes my blood boil. How on earth can you make kids work on one of the most closed down ecosystems there are? At least on windows I can install everything I want or even run my preferred OS on a virtual machine...
- saagarjha 7y agoMany schools provide computers running Windows or macOS to their students but prevent them from putting their own software on it anyways.
- zubspace 7y agoKids do not learn by taking their freedom away. They learn something by exploring their environment. Yes, you need to prevent abuse, but simply locking down their system is just an easy way out for the school admin. How would you feel about your boss taking away all your rights regarding software installation and browsing? As a dev, I'd be thoroughly pissed. Why do they question my authority? But, there are people who'd install all crapware and browse Facebook all day without any restrictions. So what to do? You give them all the power until they abuse it, then you take it away. Not the other way around.
- duxup 7y agoGenerally you don't let kids install whatever they want anyway.
- zubspace 7y agoWhy not though? Exploring, customizing and extending your operating system should be part of the learning experience. We're on Hacker News, right? I agree that you need to forbid certain websites and add some content filtering on the network. But there surely are kids able to circumvent those restrictions and most kids get in touch with 'dirty' content anyway. They better learn how to use the internet in a responsible way. Preventing them from hacking around and giving them a consume-only environment is worse I think.
- duxup 7y agoI really doubt the school is wagging the dog here. The schools job is to some extent teach what is used outside of schools. If they want to add some other things that would make sense to me, but not abandon a highly used tool. I feel like pushing another path via schools would be wonky as well. I really would hate to have schools actively try to be the arbiter of what people should use rather than reflect the marketplace.
- r3bl 7y agoI believe Microsoft isn't innocent in this at all. Every school in my city used to pirate every Microsoft product there is. I was taught how to pirate their stuff as a part of my curriculum. Now they don't, but now they're tied to Office 365 via a multi-year contract. Nobody knew they were looking to make things legal beforehand, so nobody could offer them LibreOffice installation and support before Microsoft. There were no calls for proposals or public discussions, just news stories after the contract got signed. Us who knew better were genuinely baffled by what we could have done to avoid this situation.
- duxup 7y agoMS certainly is playing the game, so is Apple, Google, etc. Still the market is what it is and I'd rather the schools follow it for the most part rather than try to lead, partly because schools are not qualified to make these decisions.
- r3bl 7y agoIn general, I'd agree. In my specific example, I don't. The title I've gained in high school is "computer technician". Not everyone needs to know the alternatives, but people with my title are in the perfect position to lead the way. The alternative (as in, MS products in general) is pretty much just bashing our heads against the wall repeatedly and crossing our fingers in hope that a reinstall would fix things. MS products work fine if our goal is to have returning customers. If it's someone closer than that (and willing to actually listen), they end up with Ubuntu (+ Skype), and the problem goes away permanently.