6 ms·
IMO we should never teach proprietary software in any education system that runs on public money.
by adrianN 7y ago
IMO we should never teach proprietary software in any education system that runs on public money.
- close04 7y agoWhat happens on the off chance you do find yourself having no alternatives? Or worse, having a free alternative that is so much worse than the proprietary, paid one?
- adrianN 7y agoInvest some taxpayer money into making a free alternative, I'd say. Or just not teach that software. If companies require the use of proprietary software without alternatives they can pay the money to train people to use it.
- close04 7y agoI’m bot saying it’s not an option but I imagine the result is not necessarily a better one. The right tools for the job don’t necessarily have to be free or open source. That’s just the best case scenario.
- achow 7y agoInteresting. That way we have to dismantle everything - bridges, buildings, power plants,... All of these spent tax payers money for some 'proprietary' machines, 'proprietary' engineering knowledge, and others..
- adrianN 7y agoBridges, buildings and power plants are not schools. We don't allow companies to place ads in schools for good reasons. Why should we train people to use their products for free?
- celticmusic 7y agoit's a fair point worth debating. Should we as a society bankroll the marketing for companies? Imagine how people would recoil at the thought of cigarette companies having access to schools in that way. I don't know that I fully agree with the premise, but it does have merit.
- achow 7y agoBecause these products are well designed and built - 100% value for money. Many school students aspire to work in the companies which build these software, or go and work in places where these software are used and those companies expect students to know these.
- inetknght 7y ago> Because these products are well designed and built You've obviously never tried to use Office 365
- bluGill 7y agoI agree. We shouldn't teach free software either. Teach the principals behind it and the software is a detail.
- EForEndeavour 7y agoThat sounds about as useful as teaching the principles behind riding a bicycle without giving students a chance to actually practice on the real thing.
- bluGill 7y agoPractice is required or course. I've ridden bicycles with coaster bikes (pedal backward to stop) and rim brakes (maybe called something else?). I've seen disk brakes, and fixed pedal bikes - even though I've never been on either I expect that I could ride and stop one. Schools should have a number of different programs available and students should use several different ones. It is fine to have a favorite, but you should be able to use any without specific instruction. Teach students to type (QWERTY is standard enough to teach even if dvorak might be better). Teach them to save early and often. There is nothing magical about that. Spend more of the time teaching grammar, spelling, reviewing rough drafts, and the other timeless principals that will never change.
- johnday 7y agoThat's a pretty good analogue, given that bicycles are proprietary.
- EForEndeavour 7y agoWhat? The bicycle design is not proprietary.
- johnday 7y agoNot the design, no, but bicycles themselves are trademarked and sold as a product. It's a free-as-in-beer problem rather than free-as-in-freedom.
- spunker540 7y agoWhat about music classes that teach Garageband or more professional recording software like Logic or Ableton? Or art classes that teach Photoshop? Should they even be allowed to use Windows or Mac OS X? How about Google Chrome or Safari? Google search? It seems rather arbitrary to feel so strongly about word processor choice but not anything else.
- swiley 7y agoWhy are you using garage band in a music class? That sounds like using ms paint in a graphic design class.
- achow 7y agoThat is not the point. Understand what OP is trying to say. Photoshop is legitimate for graphic design - right? Should we stop teaching that at school? Or Autocad or its ilk.
- thedaemon 7y agoPublic schools should not have a graphic design class, nor a CAD class. Unless you are talking about outside of the USA and the notion that all schools are public.
- apocalyptic0n3 7y agoWhat? I definitely learned Photoshop, CAD, Dreamweaver, Office (and several PCB design software suites I no longer remember) when I was in a USA high school 10-14 years ago. My younger siblings learned far more than that too a few years later (accounting software, Eclipse, and a video editing application if I recall correctly). That's completely normal depending on what electives you take. Am I misunderstanding this comment?
- alistairSH 7y agoWhy not? We had both of those at my high school (in suburban DC) and they were well enrolled and enjoyed by those who took them. They were electives - we all still took a full load of social studies, hard science, math, etc.
- partiallypro 7y agoSo schools should stop using tools that are useful in the actual real world? Ok, sounds like a great education. Instead of Photoshop, everyone can learn Gimp, instead of Word they can learn LibreOffice. Then when they fail to get a job because they have no idea how to use an Excel spreadsheet we'll chalk that up as a win for a free society, or something. People will argue, well companies will just adjust and not use Office...no they won't. Switching costs are expensive, retraining is expensive, and let's face it Office is just better.