5 ms·
Ok, is interestiong, so lets eval the explossive decompression issue. What if we could lead all this air to an external compensating device in a more ordered a
by pvaldes 7y ago
Ok, is interestiong, so lets eval the explossive decompression issue.
What if we could lead all this air to an external compensating device in a more ordered and less violent way?.
I'm thinking on some kind of "external airbag", elastic membrane, rubber balloon, etc, so we would reduce the time of event duration and soften or control the disordered exit of air (and maybe to save also some valuable oxygen from being totally lost). If unfortunately the accident happens, any corpse, object or piece would be trapped in the balloon instead to be sucked out and dissapear (this is better for the family than not having nothing to bury at least).
I suppose that to implement such device, like a rubber ring window in a handful of windows and doors, wouldn't be technically defiant and could save lifes (or alleviate the harm done) until emergency landing. Would be also a inmediately visible flag for airport rescue team to go directly to the area with more possible victims.
- dimator 7y agoYou're solving a problem that doesn't exist anymore.
- pvaldes 7y agoIt seems that decompressive explosion and people killed after being sucked by a broken window is still an unprobable but lethal risk, unfortunately https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southwest_Airlines_Flight_1380 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southwest_Airlines_Flight_1380
- rtkwe 7y agoIt's not really a risk that an air bladder or anything like what OP was suggesting will fix though. It was powerful enough to break the window it would probably be powerful enough to break the bladder and the window. It's generally better to just fix the direct problem instead of a weird patch to catch the failure.
- pvaldes 7y agoA hammer will break first a glass ball than a gel ball or a rubber tire. We know how to build solid airplanes made 100% with rigid materials except in a single point (We know that rubber tires are the right way to cope with repeated landing impacts). Maybe we should explore a different way and include more deformable materials in strategic points to absorb the damage made by a possible impact. Maybe the concept of an "boxer's eyelid airbag" for windows in airplanes, would deserve some exploratory research.
- dredmorbius 7y agoVenting from multiple, engineered, locations rather than a single explanding rupture would spare the airframe from catastropic disintegration. It's still hell on the cargo and pilots. You'd need a venting system which itself would detect sudden pressure change and blow first -- effectively a pressure circuit breaker. That itself would all but certainly introduce multiple new catastrophic failure modes. Your suggestion generalises to flying an airplane's pressure hull within another pressure hull. This scales poorly in a regime where weight and payload space are highly constrained (though it has similarities to nonpressurised oil tanker double-hull design). Yo dawg, I hear you like airplanes, here's an airplane you can put your airplane in so you can fly your airplane in an airplane.... Better to design-proof against metal fatigue-induced ruptures in the first place.
- benj111 7y ago"It's still hell on the cargo" I've never been described as that before.
- dredmorbius 7y agoEngineering understatement is a niche humour genre.
- pvaldes 7y ago> Your suggestion generalises to flying an airplane's pressure hull within another pressure hull That is not the idea either
- dredmorbius 7y agoPractical remedies generally resemble ripstop designs, preventing propogation of structural failure, rather than attempting to contain the pressure. It's better to think through the problems created by sudden rupture: 1. Pressure loss and insufficient oxygen. Reducing flight levels to ~13,000 feet addresses this, emergency oxygen provides for several minutes' supply for passengers, hours for flight crew. 2. Suction through void; crew, passengers and other internal contents may be sucked into / out of the void. This can and has compounded initial structural failures through pressure-hammer effects (especially Aloha Air), and is hard on crew, passengers, and contents subjected. 3. Internal windflows. Cabin contents themselves become missiles. Securing these (seatbelts, latches, straps, etc.) minimises risks. 4. Progressive structural compromise due to venting airflow, jetstream, or air hammer. This may occur over miliseconds to minutes, and is the primary result of total aircraft loss in most cases. Designing to minimise rupture propogation is the key countermeasure. Controlled aircraft depressurisation is not itself immediately fatal if countered quickly (supplemental oxygen, reduced altitude, emergency landing). At very high pressure differentials and sudden decompression, traumatic injury is unavoidable. The Byford Dolphin incident (warning: NSFL) would be a prime example. Though the structure itself was not totally compromised. Pressurised aircraft fuselages are already designed to minimise the risk you're describing to the limits of materials and cost considerations. Double-bagging isn't practicable. Aircraft in very high-risk environments (typically military aircraft) have been unpressurised or minimally pressurised (the F-16 maintains a 5psi differential to ambient above 23k ft). Explosive decompression by enemy (or friendly) fire is a key risk.
- smileysteve 7y agoSo like, putting the whole airplane in a condom? I wonder what effect modern vinyl graphics have, my initial thought is they would slow expansion, and slow any decompression.