2 ms·
Interestingly, the fuselage fragment picture looks like the windows were rounded. Also, while I have read the story about the Comet many times before, I vaguel
by perl4ever 7y ago
Interestingly, the fuselage fragment picture looks like the windows were rounded.
Also, while I have read the story about the Comet many times before, I vaguely recall one telling of it that noted the problem wasn't simply due to square windows, but some other contributing factor, an adjustment to the design that caused extra stress on top of the corners.
It kind of seems like common sense that engineers wouldn't have been as oblivious as the standard telling implies.
Most disasters don't happen from anyone being dumb per se, but from the interaction of different people or groups who lack the full context of what the other is doing, and I believe that was the case here.
- stcredzero 7y agoI vaguely recall one telling of it that noted the problem wasn't simply due to square windows, but some other contributing factor, an adjustment to the design that caused extra stress on top of the corners. An opening on the top for a radio receiver was improperly riveted, instead of being glued. The rivet holes caused stress concentration, which resulted in metal fatigue and eventual failure and explosive decompression. When this root cause was discovered, it was also realized that the window corners also caused stress concentration.
- WalterBright 7y agoNot rounded enough. There are formulas for the stress on an inside corner, and the larger the radius, the lower the stress rise.