4 ms·
How do I pay a doc for their time? I just sent emails to 35 different PIs this morning trying to find the most suitable clinical trial for my wife. I’ve learn
by jcims 7y ago
How do I pay a doc for their time? I just sent emails to 35 different PIs this morning trying to find the most suitable clinical trial for my wife. I’ve learned a bit in the process but I’m still funtionally illiterate. Both of the oncologists we are working with just look for trials out of their location. When i ask what else is out there they point me to clinicaltrials.gov and say Godspeed.
- rscho 7y agoFirst, let me say that I'm sorry that harm seems to have come your way. Second, unless you are extremely rich and can privately employ a doctor like a saudi prince would do, I do not know of any (non-forbidden) way to directly pay your doc for his time. Hopefully I'll stand corrected. Third, and that's the most important, primarily allocate your money to proven treatment. Clinical trials are not designed to help participants. Be weary of what people try to sell you. But if you've been dealing with the healthcare system for long enough, you probably know all about it already. I realize that's not very original, but godspeed nevertheless!
- geofft 7y agoAren't there a growing number of doctors who don't take insurance (under names like "cash-only" or "direct primary care")? Would you be able to buy a day of one of those doctors' time? It sounds like it won't run afoul of insurance but also sounds cheaper than having a personal physician.
- darawk 7y agoThere are a lot of doctors now that don't take insurance, and that you pay on retainer. The phrase you want to google here is "concierge medicine". It's definitely expensive, but not Saudi prince expensive.
- arkades 7y agoMost concierge practices retain the same business model. They ditch insurance, and the billing staff they hired to wrangle the insurance, and reclaim the time they personally spent wrangling insurance. They then keep roughly the same business model, charging more or less what insurance would have paid them. They spend more time with patients because (a) not on the phone fighting, (b) though the patient pool goes down, they’re replaced by not having to pay for billing staff. Very very few “concierge” practices aim for any more deviation from the standard business mode than that. If you want someone to spend 40 minutes with you rather than 15, that’s your guy. If you want someone to spend a week analyzing all your old records and sleuthing it out, that model still doesn’t support it.
- Elrac 7y agoI'm guessing that what you're saying implicitly applies to the USA. Just for a bit of perspective, I'd like to describe what this experience looks like for me as a resident of Germany, a developed and prosperous country that isn't the US! The German government mandates making public-option insurance available for everybody, and exercises some of control on drug and treatment prices. That means everybody is eligible for "standard" run-of-the-mill treatment for any illness. Referral to specialists is doled out by GPs, and there may be inconvenient wait time for non-emergency treatments. Prescribed drugs may be generic rather than top-tier. Various forms of quackery, i.e. drugs and treatments without good evidence of efficacy, are not covered by public-option insurance; examples include acupuncture and applications of chiropractic not directly applicable to skeletal motion, i.e. Palmer-esque "subluxation" treatment. Placebos are non-reimbursable here, but homeopathy is still covered in Germany so it's available for placebo use, though it's being excluded in other countries. Patients can opt for non-standard products, though, if they're willing to foot the bill personally. Anyone with, I'll say, "upper middle class income," though, can opt out of public health insurance and sign up with a private insurance of their choice. For employees, half of the cost of private medical insurance is paid by the employer. Private insurers must cover at least the same drugs and treatments as public insurance but both commodities can be invoiced at much higher rates; 2x and more is common. This makes private patients like myself very attractive to doctors and hospitals, of course, and we get all kinds of preferential treatment. Yes, this results in a 2 class society with regard to medical treatment and I enjoy the opportunity to be in the upper class in exchange for paying higher premiums. I can access any doctor of my choice, including specialists, and those doctors can recommend any product. Private insurers also won't pay for just anything but there's more leeway and of course there's always the option of paying out of pocket for anything that's not reimbursed. While medical services will typically carry a steep (usually reimbursed) surcharge, drugs mostly cost the same for everybody and will be reimbursed if they pass muster as medically necessary and effective. I've heard of clinical trials advertising for volunteers, but I think policy on those is similar to what you describe: a trial isn't a treatment option for just anyone who wants it.
- arkades 7y agoI'll answer both of your questions, spoken and unspoken: The first: an excellent question. It's hard to actually pay a doc for their time. We're all up to our eyeballs in the current system, including contracts with insurers that say things like "if this person is covered, you're bound to take what we are willing to pay, this person can't pay you extra to buy extraordinary services." It's not trivial at all to buy a doc's time. That said, the best method is to call their office and ask to speak to their practice manager. That's the person who is usually tasked with keeping an eye on finances, and has enough time and attention left over to hear things like "I need a non-clinical medical opinion, I am willing to pay for the doctor's time for an interview." That is assuming you are paying them like a consultant, and not paying them to provide an actual medical opinion for your wife. The latter gets gutted by insurance contracts (unless your insurer has absolutely no relationship with this doc, in which case, yes, you can pay them for their services. Some docs misread some state statutes as not allowing cash services for patients that aren't insured with them, which is both wrong and ridiculous.) The second: how to find a clinical trial for your wife. Honestly, our job is to keep up with clinical trials once they're published. Clinical trials in recruitment aren't on anyone's radar - there's no convenient way of finding them (inconveniently: clinicaltrials.gov) and no value to clinicians to read such a list even if it existed. The only ones we are aware of are the ones that, as you said, are recruiting patients at our location. The people that benefit from publishing trial availability most are the pharmaceutical companies that will ultimately reap a financial reward, so they try to reach out to patients directly via advocacy groups and things like centerwatch. So,if I really needed to find one, I'd: (0) Check www.centerwatch.com (a) Call major centers specializing in my issue, since they're the ones that most trials will pull into recruitment and/or they're the ones originating the trials. For cancer, that means contacting the relevant physicians at Dedicated Cancer Centers such as Dana-Farber Cancer Institute (full list: http://www.adcc.org/ http://www.adcc.org/). (b) Most cancers have patient advocacy groups, and they're often aware of major trials underway for their relevant cancer. For instance, for Sarcoma, you'd check out something like curesarcoma.org (who have a dedicated clinical trials resource page (https://www.curesarcoma.org/patient-resources/sarcoma-clinical-trials/ https://www.curesarcoma.org/patient-resources/sarcoma-clinic...).
- codingdave 7y ago
- photon_lines 7y agoI'm sorry to hear about your wife. What is she suffering from and what types of clinical trials are you trying to enlist her in?