3 ms·
You touched on something there that has been a pet peeve of mine for ages. People dismissing treatments like accupunture wholesale because there’s no scientifi
by jcims 7y ago
You touched on something there that has been a pet peeve of mine for ages. People dismissing treatments like accupunture wholesale because there’s no scientific evidence for Qi. So what? It’s the effect we’re interested in, not the explanation.
- crispinb 7y ago"People" might do that, but science certainly doesn't. Theoretical plausibility guides research, which is reasonable (there's no point in amassing prior knowledge if you don't use it). But empirical evidence is the determiner. And empirical studies of acupuncture have been a mixed bag - mostly it seems not to work, and where it does, sham treatments do just as well. Homeopathy is worse, but acupuncture is up there as a 'treatment' with a very poor empirical base. [an aside: I worked for a while in an fmri lab alongside a guy who did acupuncture reasearch. He was the most ideological researcher I've every come across in any field - flatly refusing to accept the validity of any data (even when collected by himself) that didn't support acupuncture's use. As someone now living in Australia's hippy zone, I find this a very recognisable & alarming trait of the 'alternative' health field.]
- bedobi 7y agoIf acupuncture had an easily and consistently replicable effect it would have been incorporated into medicine, even if we didn't understand how or why it worked. (just like paracetamol and any number of other widely used drugs and treatments we don't really know how or why they work)