4 ms·
As opposed to something holistic but still scientific. By “holistic” I mean that western medicine divides specializations too much and anything that doesn’t fit
by alkonaut 7y ago
As opposed to something holistic but still scientific. By “holistic” I mean that western medicine divides specializations too much and anything that doesn’t fit one box just falls outside everyone’s field. Generalist doctors aren’t very holistic either - they tend to just treat very common things or refer to a specialist.
Example: if you have abdominal pains, you will be referred to a gastrointestinal specialist. After some tests and maybe a gastroscopy they will diagnose or rule out the common things: ulcers, celiac disease etc. This is what modern western medicine excels at. They find and cure the likely things quickly. They can often rule out the dangerous things like cancer.
But now imagine for a second that the abdominal pain actually was a manifestation of a back disc issue. Few gastrointestinal specialists would find that and say “I think your back is the real problem and the gut pain is just a secondary symptom”. And you have already been referred as far “down” in the specialist chain as you can.
This is when people start fumbling after alternatives.
Note that there is nothing “non western” about having a more more holistic (less narrowly specialized) perspective on medicine, it’s just something that is hard so doesn’t get much attention. Perhaps the traditional specializations should be restructured? We are now seeing some headway such as the connection between gut bacteria and mental health for example.
- crispinb 7y agoSure - agree with all of this. That's more to do with institutions than 'western medicine' as a science. Most science disciplines are similarly imperfectly implemented when they hit the real worlds of politics, inertia, profit, tribalism, etc.
- kirrent 7y ago> But now imagine for a second that the abdominal pain actually was a manifestation of a back disc issue. Few gastrointestinal specialists would find that and say “I think your back is the real problem and the gut pain is just a secondary symptom”. What are you talking about? Referred pain is well known and any doctor and especially any specialist will have studied and be familiar with common and likely referred pain pathways in the same way that they're familiar with other common interactions between systems. If you're struck with left arm pain while seeing an orthapedic surgeon, they'll make sure that you're not having a heart attack rather than trying to rule out orthapedic causes first. In your example, assuming an uncommon referred pain that your gastroenterologist is not familiar with, what more do you want from them than ruling out a gastrological cause? It's incredibly useful information that you and your primary care physician will be able to use to help track down the real cause. And if, after consulting multiple specialists, your primary care physician has no more ideas for pursuing the root cause of the issue, they'll help manage your chronic condition in consultation with a pain specialist and psychologist if required. Bottom line, doctors think more holistically thank you realise. To the extent that isn't sufficient, the medical system as a whole should be treating the patient as a whole. If that's not happening because of a variety of perverse incentives that's the fault of how we structure and pay for our healthcare systems and not the fault of western medicine.
- alkonaut 7y ago> what more do you want from them than ruling out a gastrological cause? I just want to get rid of the abdominal pain - I really don’t care about whether the cause is actually gastrointestinal. I want to rule out illness, that they are good at. If the referred pain isn’t a known condition such as a herniated disc or anything else that shows up on a test o image - then they are usually not concerned at all (no illness - job done). And even if it is a known/visible cause outside their specialization, they are extremely bad in my experience at both recognizing and “referring sideways” to another specialist. I live under a single payer system so the economics probably don’t factor into it, but I think the siloed thinking at specialists requires that the generalists take a holistic perspective, but in reality they cure tonsillitis and point to specialists. Somewhere I feel there is a gap.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoI'm not sure there's a huge distinction between "how we structure and pay for our healthcare systems" and "western medicine." As for the holistic view - there's a difference between check-list diagnosis (left arm pain -> possible heart attack) and what is effectively personal medical research, which may require knowledge of everything from diet to sleeping habits to emotional stressors to historical infections and illnesses. (That's a very short list, and not in any way exhaustive.) There are limited professional incentives for doctors to dig into patient history with that level of detail. It's not a matter of specialist referrals, because some problems can be caused by multiple minor factors interacting with each other. Or they may have very generic symptoms, like fatigue, with a ridiculously huge number of possible causes. Or the causes still aren't understood. Medicine is an example of a huge market failure. Not only is it the single biggest cause of personal bankruptcy in the US, but most people have had personal experience of obvious delayed diagnosis or outright misdiagnosis. An effective market - rather than a "rational" one - could easily support a much larger number of doctors and supporting medical professionals, including non-corporate researchers. The effect on "western medicine" would be a dramatic increase in effectiveness.
- crispinb 7y ago> I'm not sure there's a huge distinction between "how we structure and pay for our healthcare systems" and "western medicine." Given that different 'western' nations structure and pay for their health care systems entirely differently, there must be, mustn't there? Or are you conflating "Western medicine" with "US medicine"? Indeed you are: > Medicine is an example of a huge market failure.
- Retric 7y agoThat’s kind of like complaining because programmers don’t know every language. GP’s refer to specialists because medicine is such a huge body of work. Keeping up with even a small field takes a lot of time. Someone that tries to keep up with and more importantly remember everything is not going to succeed let alone have time to help you. Sometimes the next step is to take these results go up the chain and try again not hope the wrong specialist can still solve your issue. It’s not a perfect system, especially if you actually have multiple independent unusual issues at the same time. But, that’s life with imperfect humans.
- crispinb 7y agoIt's really more like wishing a consultancy would employ a competent project manager. The thing about systems is that they're designed (even if only by refusing to design and calling it 'market driven'). Some work better than others. I've certainly seen the difference in the small number of countries I've lived in - some do a much better job of coordinating services between generalists & specialists than others. But this has nothing to do with 'western' medical science per se, which is the primary modality of each of those varying systems.