8 ms·
RIM thought iPhone was impossible in 2007
- elvirs 16y agoThats why even years later they tried to replicate iPhone and failed (see Blackberry Storm)
- ugh 16y agoSo much for the frequent claim that Apple is all marketing and no new technology, I guess. Analysis like that tend to focus on single technologies like capacitive touchscreens or e-ink displays. Pretty much all the different single technologies many recent Apple products brought together existed in some way, shape or form before in consumer products. Single technologies don't make a product. Oh, and the UI matters. Having the same exact hardware with a better UI really does matter.
- bayleo 16y agoRIM wasn't the first one to be schooled by Apple in the "UI matters" lesson. Did anyone else own one of those Archos 20gig Jukebox players in 2000?
- sandipc 16y agoOr the Creative Nomad Jukebox...
- forensic 16y agowhat? the UI really wasn't very good at all on it. The old school iPod UI was superior The Nomad Jukebox was great for the tactile-feedback buttons and it's durability. It was a tank.
- sjs 16y agoIt took forever to boot. When I dropped mine and broke its disk I then swapped in a 6GB disk and it took even longer, around 2 minutes. I went back to an mp3 discman instead before getting a Mac mini in 2005, which opened my eyes to the fact that Apple made more than just pretty devices, they cared about UI and paid attention to details like having different volume settings for headphones. I then bought a 60gb iPod w/ video and haven't looked back.
- ugh 16y agoI had one of their cheap new 10" Android tablets in my hands today. We have come so far and they have learned so little (Samsung’s Galaxy Tab has much better hardware but Android just doesn’t feel right for tablets. At least not right now.)
- stcredzero 16y agoSamsung’s Galaxy Tab has much better hardware but Android just doesn’t feel right for tablets. At least not right now. And people keep wondering why there's both Android and Chrome.
- azernik 16y ago(Just a reply to the parenthetical - probably because Android hasn't been tuned for/doesn't support tablet-sized screens yet - 2.3 is the first release to be designed for tablets.)
- jbrennan 16y agoPeople keep saying that as a defence, and I agree 2.2 isn't made for tablets. But it makes me wonder: why did Samsung even ship it then?
- Samuel_Michon 16y ago"Did anyone else own one of those Archos 20gig Jukebox players in 2000?" I doubt it. The 20GB Archos Jukebox was released in October 2001. Archos' models from 2000 had 5GB and 6GB hard drives. [1] Just like the 20GB Archos Jukebox, Apple's 5GB iPod was released in October 2001. [2] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archos_Jukebox_series http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archos_Jukebox_series [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPod_classic#First_generation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPod_classic#First_generation
- tzs 16y agoI had an Archos 15 gig when the iPod came out. Although it is now long gone and I have an iPod 40 gig from a few generations ago, a nano from the tall thin era, am on my second iPhone and have an iPad, I'll say this for Archos: It still totally takes any Apple music playing device completely to school when it comes to classical music. iPods are really wrapped up in the idea that you have artists, who produce albums, which contain songs, and if you don't want to organize your collection around those three dimensions, screw you. In classical, we want six dimensions, not three: composer, orchestra, conductor, soloists, composition, and movement or piece within the composition. Yes, iPod lets you list by composer. However, that just brings up a list of songs (tracks). However, most (all?) iPods have arbitrary and small limits on how long a title can be and still allow you to see everything in it. For instance, on my Vivaldi list, I see 3 different "Concerto für Laute, Violi...". If I'm lucky, maybe I can remember that the one I'm looking for is relatively short, so the 2:06 one is the one I want, not the 3:30 or the 5:03. Let's compare to my old Archos. With the Archos, one option was to simply put a directory hierarchy on the device, and then access it via a simple file browser interface. If you hit "play" in a directory without a particular track selected, it would play everything in that directory, in alphabetical order. So, I'd rip each CD into its own directory, with each track file starting with its track number (padded with a leading 0 if less than two digits). I could then organize these directories in a tree any way I wanted. For my rock, folk, and pop, I could use artist/album. For classical I could do composer/conductor/orchestra/composition for those that did not feature a soloist. For those with a soloist, I could toss in a directory in there to organize by soloist. With the Archos, I never had to fish around to find what I wanted to find. With iPod I've sometimes spent several minutes trying to find something I know is there. BTW, I used the same organization on my desktop machine, and made sure to use a music player that would handle drag-and-drop reasonably--drop a track on it and it plays it, drop a directory on it and it plays all tracks in alphabetical order. Then all I needed was a file browser on the desktop and music playback was dealt with there, too. People have made classical work reasonably with iTunes on the desktop, by repurposing some of the fields. But that doesn't stop the suckage on iPods.
- ugh 16y agoWhile brilliant in some respects, Apple’s sometimes selective attention is also pretty well known ;-) The popular thing to do is to speculate that Jobs just doesn’t care about classical music at all and for that reason it’s neglected.
- aresant 16y agoTough to compete with Apple after they began duplicating their success in UI design to hardware, manufacturing, elegant chip design with a pointed purpose, etc. Apple's most underestimated strength is their continued march towards vertical integration - buying make the right processor company (PA Semi) and a team of 150 processor gurus to minimize power use, developing a proprietary manufacturing process to make seamless aluminum notebooks, etc, etc etc. A good read from 2008 about Apple's strategy . . . http://www.forbes.com/2008/04/24/mitra-apple-pasemi-tech-enter-cx_sm_0425mitra.html http://www.forbes.com/2008/04/24/mitra-apple-pasemi-tech-ent...
- pramanat 16y agoGood article ... looks like the author predicted something like the IPad.
- joeguilmette 16y ago"besides the Playbook much of their plans remain a mystery" Likely to RIM as well.
- joshu 16y agoMean. Probably true too.
- mortenjorck 16y agoI must sigh and agree. As lost and flailing as RIM can seem right now, though, the company seems to have its path for the next 18 months cut out for it. In theory, they finally have everything they should need–a solid next-gen OS with a cadre of engineers who understand it inside and out, a hardware division with a wealth of experience, and now a surprisingly forward-thinking and experimental UI design acquisition that could work wonders if allowed to inform the entire product design process. They just need to get them all working together. And that's the part I'm most worried about.
- joeguilmette 16y ago
- nailer 16y agoThe title is misleading. RIM thought the iPhone 2G was insanely power hungry and must have terrible battery life. As an owner of iPhone 2G I attest that was completely true. This is the first phone I'd ever owned that lasted less than two days. (Apple themselves even cited battery life as the reason they couldn't do 3G, and the iPhone 3G, when it did come out, was thicker than the iPhone 2G) What RIM probably didn't counter is that customers were willing to trade 24 hour charging cycles for an awesome user experience.
- nlawalker 16y agoI have never understood why some people find 24-hour charging cycles to be such a problem. Humans have a 24-hour charging cycle too, and while charging they are unable to use phones, so I don't see why it's such a trouble to charge the phone at the same time.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoBattery use isn't linear. If 24-hour charging cycles are required for the average case what that means is that you're limiting use for a lot of normal cases. Use the phone a bit more than average or have a long period of poor reception, and then you've exhausted the battery. Which is precisely the case today, it's trivially easy for anyone to exhaust the battery on a modern smartphone in much less than a day. In contrast, a phone that requires charging every week, for example, you'll tend to keep at a higher total charge and will survive periods of heavier usage better. That's not dismissing the fact that most people are willing to accept the tradeoffs of modern smartphone battery life, but make no mistake the necessity of daily recharging for average use is a problem.
- jolan 16y ago> it's trivially easy for anyone to exhaust the battery on a modern smartphone in much less than a day Watch a 90 minute youtube video over 3G and you're pretty much there. (On my iPhone 3G at least)
- 16y ago
- wallflower 16y ago"Imagine their surprise [at RIM] when they disassembled an iPhone for the first time and found that the phone was battery with a tiny logic board strapped to it." Step 9 iFixit teardown of original iPhone: http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/iPhone-1st-Generation-Teardown/599/1 http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/iPhone-1st-Generation-Teardow... Witness the size of the magical iPad battery in Step 22: http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/iPad-Teardown/2183/3 http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/iPad-Teardown/2183/3
- aditya 16y agoI suppose this speaks to Apple's need for secrecy too, stealth and secrecy mostly seem overrated but if you're going to disrupt a huge market, they can be pretty powerful in making entrenched competitors believe that certain things are impossible. This happens all the time, established competitors become complacent and lose the intense focus that made them successful in the first place. Apple and Netflix are two companies that are admirable in this sense. And perhaps it is because they're (supposedly) ruthless about hiring and firing.
- guelo 16y agoI don't know what the point of this article is except as some kind of Apple gloat. As far as I know everyone was blown away by the 2007 announcement, the event was a worldwide shock, it would be news if a competitor hadn't reacted strongly. Techies such as everyone here went into straight nerdgasm, the media went gaga, consumers went into gotta-have-it mode, and the entire rest of the industry went into shock and then desperate reactionary mode. The announcement was a historical event in computing and consumer electronics. But it is ancient history, 4 years ago, what's the point of this now?
- Samuel_Michon 16y ago"ancient history, 4 years ago, what's the point of this now?" The point is that 4 years after the introduction of the iPhone, RIM still hasn't managed to ship a phone that competes with the iPhone. And since they have a long way to go with QNX, I don't expect RIM to catch up in the next two years. Which raises the question: what has RIM been doing the last 4 years?
- potatolicious 16y agoIt's also important to note that Google has been able to ship a mostly-competent competitor to the iPhone, and is improving incredibly quickly. Palm, a company with vastly inferior resources and shallower pockets than RIM, has been able to also. Both of these companies were largely reacting to the success of the iPhone and got sideswiped much like RIM. Unlike RIM, though, both companies recovered quickly and were able to ship compelling products (though not all commercially successful). RIM hasn't shipped squat that would even begin to compete with the user experience on iPhone. Hell, RIM hasn't shipped anything that I'd use over the first-gen iPhone, much less iPhone 4.
- pedanticfreak 16y agoRIM has been the entrenched market leader. Abandoning all that made it successful would be equivalent to the Digg redesign. Instead of placing bets on RIM's comeback play we'd be analyzing the wreckage of RIM's sudden implosion. Google and Palm had no users. They could afford to completely change focus and abandon the existing user base.
- ankimal 16y agoThank God for the spirit of innovation and the never say die attitude.
- cubicle67 16y agoAnyone able to locate the original source for this claim? The link in the article ends up at shacknews with a 'bad id' message and I've been unable to locate the source on that site Interestingly all the sites I've looked at trying to find the source, and there's been a few, all link back to this article in electronista (except sites like apple.findtechnews.net which rip off the entire story, pic and all and then remove the source link) I guess I'm looking for a blog post or even a forum post/comment, but so far I've drawn a blank.
- breakall 16y agoI got that too. Did a search for user "Kentor" on the site and was able to get a list of his comments on shacknews, and there is a ghost of a comment from Dec 25 that says "you guys could have avoided this conversation..." and has the same comment id as the link from electronista. Looks like it was deleted, along with several other comments that appear to be on the same topic. http://www.shacknews.com/search.x?type=comments&terms=&cs_user=Kentor http://www.shacknews.com/search.x?type=comments&terms=&#...
- cubicle67 16y agoThanks. Most I can get is You guys could have avoided this entire conversation by just defining what Apple created as something more than a smartphone. ... from google. can't get anymore from google cache, but probably because I've not used it before so I don't know what I'm doing To clarify - there's now been several thousand words written across dozens (probably more) of sites and numerous comments all based upon a single deleted comment (id=24854573) by user Kentor on Shacknews.com Whilst I think the (supposed) claim plausible, I do have a bit of a problem with the way we can take a single quote and turn it into news, which tends to become treated as fact down the track; "Everyone knows RIM thought the iPhone was impossible in 2007"
- cubicle67 16y agomanaged to locate the full original quote You guys could have avoided this entire conversation by just defining what Apple created as something more than a smartphone. What we call a smartphone today is a rather different than what was meant when the term was first coined. The first smartphone was pretty much the Nokia Communicator back in the late 90s. It had data connectivity and some limited ability to run applications, and that pretty much what a smartphone was at the time. Today we take it to mean handheld wireless computer that happens to have a phone, but back then if you send a few packets you were a smartphone. I was hired by RIM in 1999 just before they began work on their first phone and spent a good number years writing RIM proprietary protocol stacks that layered on top of the then new GPRS. Coming from a two-way pager background, RIM decided that phones should have two-way push synchronization of pretty much everything that Exchange provided along with a limited WML browser. The general thought was that phones would never have sufficient power density or radios sufficient bandwidth to allow anything more. That was incredibly predictably wrong, but it's how things went down. Along with RIM was Ericsson, Palm, Motorola, and Qualcomm. Motorola came from a similar background as RIM and went on to build very similar devices. Both Nokia and Ericsson had come from phones and had decided feature phones should have far more sophisticated PDA functions. Palm started with PDAs then moved to the phones, but adamantly dismissed ideas like wireless synchronization for years making their first attempts at smart phone far more like early Nokia Communicators than early Blackberrys. Oddly enough, though Nokia made the first smartphone, which was followed by two more with RIM and arguably Palm in 20002, it was Ericsson that popularly coined the term in the mid 2000s. So the point is that all these companies were fighting over what amounts to overgrown PDAs with phones and wireless stacks strapped on. Everyone assumed power density was no where even close to what was needed for general computing, that a full featured browser and heavy duty Internet services were impossible due to bandwidth and latency. Take a look at how our Java expert groups named standards, how people at the time talked about what features smart phones should have, and its clear that no one thought an iPhone was possible. Even Danger, which eventually went on to work on to create Windows Phone 7 and Android, was just working on a better Blackberry. The iPhone did many amazing things, but what stands out in my mind was how it proved that these assumptions were flat-out wrong beyond any reasonable doubt. Apple pretty gave everyone the finger and said, "Fuck you guys we can build your distant impossible future today." I left RIM back in 2006 just months before the IPhone launched and I remember talking to friends from RIM and Microsoft about what their teams thought about it at the time. Everyone was utterly shocked. RIM was even in denial the day after the iPhone was announced with all hands meets claiming all manner of weird things about iPhone: it couldn't do what they were demonstrating without an insanely power hungry processor, it must have terrible battery life, etc. Imagine their surprise when they disassembled an iPhone for the first time and found that the phone was battery with a tiny logic board strapped to it. It was ridiculous, it was brilliant. I really don't think you're giving Apple enough credit here. They did something amazing that many very prominent people in the industry thought was either impossible or at least a decade away, and they did it in a disgustingly short time frame.
- dfhjtyjty 16y agoClick on our website: ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== "Priority, my friend!! Christmas is coming, quick to our website shopping, our web site shopping there will be something different, unexpected things to you, let you have different sense, our website wholesale various fashion shoes, such as Nike, Jordan, prada, also includes the jeans, shirt, bags, hats and decoration. All these products are our free transport, prices are competitive, we can also accept paypal j, after the payment within short time, can ship. = New era cap $12; Air jordan(1-24)shoes $30; jordan air max oakland raiders $34a€“39; Ed Hardy AF JUICY POLO Bikini $25; Christan Audigier BIKINI JACKET $25; Tshirts (Polo ,ed hardy,lacoste) $15 coogi DG edhardy gucci t-shirts $18; gstar coogi evisu true jeans $35; coach chanel gucci LV handbags $36; Sunglasses(Oakey,coach,gucci,A r m a i n i) $15; ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ====
- dfhjrtjty 16y agoClick on our website: ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== "Priority, my friend!! Christmas is coming, quick to our website shopping, our web site shopping there will be something different, unexpected things to you, let you have different sense, our website wholesale various fashion shoes, such as Nike, Jordan, prada, also includes the jeans, shirt, bags, hats and decoration. All these products are our free transport, prices are competitive, we can also accept paypal j, after the payment within short time, can ship. = New era cap $12; Air jordan(1-24)shoes $30; jordan air max oakland raiders $34a€“39; Ed Hardy AF JUICY POLO Bikini $25; Christan Audigier BIKINI JACKET $25; Tshirts (Polo ,ed hardy,lacoste) $15 coogi DG edhardy gucci t-shirts $18; gstar coogi evisu true jeans $35; coach chanel gucci LV handbags $36; Sunglasses(Oakey,coach,gucci,A r m a i n i) $15; ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ==== ==== ( http://www.etradinglife.com http://www.etradinglife.com ) ====
- Stormbringer 16y agoOne of the things that people consistently seem to forget is that the iPhone isn't just hardware. The iPhone is an aggregation of things that collectively make up either an ecosystem or something akin to it. And in most cases, the pieces of that ecosystem had been built up over a considerable time before the iPhone was a twinkle in Jobs' eyes. For RIM to duplicate the iPhone would require them to give up on a lot of long held beliefs (e.g. physical keyboard), to ignore most of the tech pundits (the pundits themselves don't like to remind us that they were busy ridiculing the very concept of a one-button phone right up to and in some cases even after it started selling like hot-cakes), to focus on the consumer instead of the business user and last but by no means least to madly start implementing and iterating on their own consumer eco-system. Now the iTunes store is by no means perfect, but if you don't have a drop in replacement for it, what are you going to replace that part of the eco-system with? I think a lot of people grossly underestimate the time and effort it takes to create a system like the iTunes store, and never mind even all the iterations in features... how about the task of sitting down with every single recording industry association in every country that your product will be sold? How about doing the same thing for movies and then telcos? You'd have to be a masochist of the first degree. On that note, one of the enormously revolutionary things that Apple did was to break the choke-hold that telcos had over the handset manufacturers. On an iPhone, you always have access to the App store and iTunes stores... on a Blackberry it is up to the telco whether you get App World at all. In any case, RIM should play to their own strengths, not Apples. RIM groks business the same way Apple groks consumers. (But of course business users are also consumers, while this 'should' give Apple a big advantage breaking into the corporate market, they consistently fail to capitalise on it. I think the difference is they have to fight for the corporate space, whereas in the consumer space everyone else is falling over themselves competing to make the cheapest (read as: least profitable, also in the sense of 'nasty'), ugliest and hardest to use devices). RIM has their own eco-system in the corporate space, mainly revolving around the BES (Blackberry Enterprise Server)... but what does that do? It encrypts your email and pushes it to you (via Canada). But is that really such a big deal now? They have a plethora of device models, with differentiation based on presence or absence of things like GPS, trackballs and cameras, and also how wide you want your keyboard to be. I'm not convinced that having so many options is helpful, but they seem to have a hard time deprecating the old ones. Lately they have been making inroads with the teenage market in the UK because they have a cheap alternative to SMS (one advantage of running your own server infrastructure I guess). But I wonder how many of those teens also carry iPods? It is easy to look at a Blackberry and say something like "oh, this is why they're failing, their camera is bad and the browser is worse". But that is overly simplistic. When comparing the iPhone to other smartphones, the iPhone has two killer features: ecosystem and ease of use. You may put out a phone that physically has all the features of an iPhone, but you get an extra 10% megapixels... and the world is not going to beat a path to your door.