4 ms·
> decades of massive use for us to even realize that some of our most common over-the-counter drugs were being used in dangerous ways (e.g. aspirin can cause Re
by mistermann 7y ago
> decades of massive use for us to even realize that some of our most common over-the-counter drugs were being used in dangerous ways (e.g. aspirin can cause Reye's syndrome in children, Tylenol with alcohol can damage the liver)
Agreed, but then to some degree could this same argument not be made about vaccines?
- carapace 7y agoNo. It's pretty clear, even if the anti-vaxxer lunatics were not wrong (which they are, they are wrong, they are perniciously wrong, in the face of all evidence they are wrong), that vaccines would be a net benefit. In other words, even if vaccines did cause autism (which they do not) it would still be imperative to use them. The alternative to widespread vaccination is much worse.
- mistermann 7y ago> No. It's pretty clear, even if the anti-vaxxer lunatics were not wrong (which they are, they are wrong, they are perniciously wrong, in the face of all evidence they are wrong), that vaccines would be a net benefit. Are the "anti-vaxxer lunatics" arguing that vaccines are not a net benefit? When you refer to "anti-vaxxer lunatics", who is it, exactly, are you referring to? Are you referring to specific people (everyone within the "anti-vaxx" "community"), or are you referring to an abstract mental model, of questionable accuracy, held in your own mind? > even if vaccines did cause autism (which they do not) These sorts of comment lack epistemic humility/awareness. We do not know that vaccines do not cause autism. Science does not say this. However, this isn't to say that science says vaccines do cause autism. What causes autism is unknown. The final knowledge of an association between vaccines and autism is unknown. To some degree, the "pro-vaxx" message is based on propaganda (here I am referring to the lesser pejorative meaning of the word). Many within the "anti-vaxx" community can see this, and it is used in various ways as leverage. Which is, of course, also propaganda (the more pejorative kind - typically, but not always). This approach has been sound in the past, but there are increasing signs that it is becoming less effective. Time will tell if that trend continues.
- carapace 7y ago> When you refer to "anti-vaxxer lunatics", who is it, exactly, are you referring to? I'm referring to the old lady I met in the park while I was walking the dog who insisted that her homeopathic "doctor" had the authority to tell her that "vaccines cause autism". > We do not know that vaccines do not cause autism. I get what you're trying to say, but no. In this case yes, we do. Pick your goddamned battles wisely friend. Don't play Russian Roulette with other people's children. (One epidemic and the anti-vaxxers will be up against the wall. Or we can shame the ever-loving-shit out of them and maybe prevent the suffering entirely. It's gaoddamned insane that we even have this problem. Image search polio, image search measles. Lord have mercy.)
- mistermann 7y ago> I'm referring to the old lady I met in the park while I was walking the dog who insisted that her homeopathic "doctor" had the authority to tell her that "vaccines cause autism". You've found one person who is wrong about one thing. Is it logical/prudent to then assume all "anti-vaxxers" are wrong, about everything that they believe? Rather than assuming your ideological opponents are enemies, it might be worthwhile to put some effort into discovering their actual nature, and what their actual arguments are. As far as I can tell, your current perception is quite flawed (based on the reading I have done of conversations within the anti-vaxx community). >> We do not know that vaccines do not cause autism. > I get what you're trying to say, but no. In this case yes, we do. No, we don't. An absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. https://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/concerns/autism.html https://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/concerns/autism.html Correct, epistemically sound statement: "studies have shown that there is no link between receiving vaccines and developing ASD" Possibly correct, but epistemically flawed statement: "There is no link between receiving vaccines and developing ASD" There is a difference between these two statements. Are you able to you see it? > Pick your goddamned battles wisely friend. I do. Thanks for your advice though. > Don't play Russian Roulette with other people's children. I say the same to you in return. Based on recent news articles, the amount of vaccine cautious people, as a percentage of overall society, seems to be growing. Who is more responsible for this phenomenon - me, who recommends scientific honesty, or you, who opposes scientific honesty? > One epidemic and the anti-vaxxers will be up against the wall. I would argue that authoritarian thinking like this does not work in your favor.
- 1e-9 7y agoI place vaccines in the "absolutely necessary" category where the known benefit far outweighs the known risk. In the case of aspirin and Tylenol, I think they are most often used in unnecessary ways such as lowering fever and addressing minor aches and pains. Fever is actually a physiological defense against pathogens, which should almost never be countered. Minor aches and pains are typically useful for encouraging us to follow beneficial behavior (e.g. rest, sleep, don't move in certain ways).
- IggleSniggle 7y agoReducing fevers is a mixed bag. Yes, the higher temperature may help fight the disease (or might do nothing, totally dependent on the diseases suitability for reproduction at higher temperature). Yes, it can also damage your body if it gets out of control. And yes, sleep is also good for fighting off illness, and a fever can get in the way of that. Just because it is your bodies natural response doesn’t mean it’s going to help you. Allergies are a great example of the body taking totally inappropriate counter-measures.
- 1e-9 7y agoTrue, but cases of fever harming the body are extremely rare. The fact that mammals, reptiles, and even insects, increase their body temperature to fight pathogens suggests that fever confers significant survival advantage and that our null hypothesis should always be that it is helping us unless we have strong evidence to the contrary. I agree that sometimes (rarely) our immune system does get it wrong in a serious way such that medication is crucial (for example, anaphylaxis); however, most immune system misfires are minor and do not justify the risk of medications with poorly understood side effects and interactions. Oftentimes, there is a good alternative to medication. For example, when I have sinus congestion, I can almost always find a head orientation that allows me to breath and sleep.
- Joelexander 7y agoVaccines prevent disease and keep it from spreading. Preventing a problem from happening in the first place is and will always be the best solution. Unfortunately they're a victim of their own success. They've done such a phenomenal job people scarcely remember why we use them at all.
- dang 7y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20435466 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20435466.