2 ms·
> Since they're so large, that creates a discrepancy between the stability you would expect from an established company, and the "kill your babies" culture they
by paulryanrogers 7y ago
> Since they're so large, that creates a discrepancy between the stability you would expect from an established company, and the "kill your babies" culture they clearly have.
Curious why they don't spin some of these out, or sell to, independent businesses. Reader looks like it could have at least been profitable.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Swenrekcah 7y agoI think they wouldn’t do that because their whole thing is to become the only software provider in the world.
- HALtheWise 7y agoThere's a lot of reasons, but at least part of the answer is technical. Most Google software is extremely dependent on a massive set of proprietary internal libraries, and it is so difficult to disentangle them that rewriting the entire thing from scratch is often easier (like they did to create Docker). I'm not sure whether it is possible to provide a contractual lease to an external company granting access to the entire Google codebase, but it certainly has enough challenges they would rather avoid it if they can.
- yoz-y 7y agoWhen Reeder died other software appeared, Feedly and Feedbin to name two. I guess that for many systems it makes more sense to rewrite them.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Curious why they don't spin some of these out, or sell to, independent businesses. Reader looks like it could have at least been profitable. Probably because of self-competition and proprietary shared dependencies; Reader, IIRC, was killed partially because it was incompatible with the way some of it's internal infrastructure dependencies were being evolved to support other services with more promising business prospects; it couldn't practically be sold off as is (and even if the infrastructure was forked, the people maintaining it wouldn't go with it, since they were being retasked.) And lots of Google products that are killed are killed in favor of other Google products with overlapping markets, so selling them off would mean Google would be fueling competition to the services it wanted to focus on. In many cases, I suspect both factors apply to individual products.