3 ms·
Exactly; I don't think many folks deny Google has had a bit of an issue with shutting down widely used products after they stagnate, but this was none of the ab
by jchw 7y ago
Exactly; I don't think many folks deny Google has had a bit of an issue with shutting down widely used products after they stagnate, but this was none of the above. It was a beta that had "10,000+" installs according to Play Store, which I am guessing that places the active users a fair bit lower.
Products like Blog Compass are not new. Google has probably had hundreds of these smaller, more experimental products that got canned after a while, like Sidewiki (remember that?) but until relatively recently it's never been used as a sign that Google is unreliable; in hindsight most of them made sense. If I had to guess, I think the continued soreness from a few big ones like G+ and Reader have just left many jaded.
I mean I was bitten by the G+ shutdown, but honestly, looking for things to complain about is really worse than just beating a dead horse. In other words, you may as well just complain about the one that really frustrates you, since I doubt anyone here actually used Blog Compass.
Disclosure, I am a Googler, had no idea what Blog Compass was until today.
- JeremyBanks 7y agoQuit
- dang 7y agoBesides being unsubstantive, that crosses into personal attack. We've had to warn you against that before. Please don't post like this to HN. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- itronitron 7y agoI was wondering this yesterday and maybe you can answer, what do most Google employees do during their workday (given that so many products that people used to work on have been terminated)?
- jchw 7y agoA few thoughts. (Needless to say, this is all personal opinions and not those of my employer.) - Products that are doing well have more folks working on them, I assume. - There is plenty of mobility at Google and no shortage of things to work on. - The churn rate of products is probably lower than the perception, at least relatively speaking. I perceive Cloud as being pretty stable. - There’s a lot of tooling that is not specific to any unit or product, like Bazel for example.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoSaying that people are looking for things to complain about is the exact reason that people dislike Google. The problem isn't you, it's that the entire company feels the same way as you do, that users of Google products are just looking for reasons to complain when their favorite app gets shut down. It's as if the company was created with no one who's job it is to think about users and it's bitterly apparent. Real people are really inconvenienced and impacted by switching services Google likes to kill off, whether it's this Compass product, Reader, Picasa, SketchUp, G+, Inbox, Hangouts, Nests, Blogger, or Android for Fuschia, or something else, it doesn't matter. Other companies don't treat unknowing users like beta testers. People choose to opt in, knowing it might fail, and take that risk. They don't get functions for something they physically installed into their house willfully broken for no reason. It's not just a few products. Try and fix something with Google DNS, go ahead I'll wait while you find the appropriate place to contact. I'm going to guess it's going to involve knowing someone at Google because there's no way to report that Google servers are breaking connectivity to websites. The entire company is like this now, no one cares about the users and it's blindly apparent.
- jchw 7y agoAh, so what you’re saying is, when people are complaining about products and/or features being removed, it’s because they actually used them. So in the vein of this article... did you use Blog Compass? I never said people should just stop complaining. I said they should complain about what is actually bothering them instead of projecting it onto everything that happens. It muddies the water at best and is dishonest at worst.