4 ms·
If I understand correctly, you're suggesting that animals could react to stimuli that we would consider painful by following the same behaviours that they would
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
If I understand correctly, you're suggesting that animals could react to stimuli
that we would consider painful by following the same behaviours that they
would if they felt pain, not because they feel pain but because they have been
programmed to follow those behaviours in response to those stimuli?
I find this unlikely. The set of stimulus-response behaviours necessary to
avoid every possible danger that might arise in an animal's environment would
be immense. It seems much more economical to "program" behavious that avoid any
painful stimulus (e.g. by setting some "pain threshold" and programming the
animal to avoid anything that causes a sensation of pain above that
threshold). This is particularly so for insects that have a limited number of
neurons in which to store their stimulus-specific programs.
- hackinthebochs 7y ago>by following the same behaviours that they would if they felt pain This is taking the claim I made too far. My point was that reacting to noxious stimuli does not a priori require the conscious experience of pain (which includes a suffering component). When it comes to analyzing sets of possible behaviors, that provides more evidence with which to decide between nociception and pain. I do think that most "animals" (excluding insects) probably experience pain due to, as you said, the varieties of possible behaviors being too large to be merely reflex based. But it's not obvious to me that this holds for insects.
- Retric 7y agoThey would have to experience some negative stimulus to avoid it. Disagreement with the term pain does not remove the resume that learned avoidance requires detection of a negative stimulus. Further, while we separate negative stimulus into say thirst and pain, the fact you can torture people with either means the difference is ethically more semantic than meaningful.
- hackinthebochs 7y agoThere is a distinction in biology between sensory perception of noxious stimuli (nociception) and the experience of suffering in response to noxious stimuli. The distinction is in higher order brain processing. An organism does not need to experience suffering to react to noxious stimuli: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withdrawal_reflex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withdrawal_reflex
- Retric 7y agoWithdraw reflex does not mean learning. You can see this in cases where the withdrawal reflex is repeatedly triggered without learning.
- hackinthebochs 7y agoWithdraw reflex also doesn't preclude learning. We see learning in all sorts of reflex arcs that get over-triggered and thus become downregulated. So the fact that the fly "learned" to be more sensitive to noxious stimuli does not rule out a reflex mechanism at play in its behavior.
- Retric 7y agoDown regulated withdrawal reflex is the opposite of avoidance behavior. It’s effectively increasing an organism’s tolerance for putting it’s limb in fire. So, no what you’re describing does not mean learning to avoid stimulus. Learned avoidance behavior really requires a negative perception not just a neutral reflexive one.
- hackinthebochs 7y agoI'm not sure why you're giving my comments such an obtuse reading. My example was to show how learning can happen in a reflex network, thus undermining your claim that learning indicates conscious experience. The issue here is regarding the capabilities of a reflex network. I have established that learning can happen in such networks, as shown by common examples. You have not established that learning avoidance behaviors requires conscious networks.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> My point was that reacting to noxious stimuli does not a priori require the conscious experience of pain (which includes a suffering component). Like Retric says, this leaves open the question of how noxious stimuli (thanks) lead to avoidance behaviours, if they are not unpleasant. My explanation is that the unpleasant sensation of pain makes the animal try and avoid the stimulus that causes the pain. What is the alternative? Edit: also, why most animals but not insects? What is different about insects?
- hackinthebochs 7y ago>this leaves open the question of how noxious stimuli (thanks) lead to avoidance behaviours, if they are not unpleasant. It triggers networks that are designed to cause avoidance behaviors, for example the withdraw reflex[1]. Reflex networks do not require any conscious experience of the stimuli that triggers the specific action. >why most animals but not insects? What is different about insects? The size of the set of possible unique behaviors, complexity of brain, existence of higher order brain processes. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withdrawal_reflex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withdrawal_reflex