3 ms·
Swapping out a few hundred kilos of battery is going to require some tools and equipment. That doesn't sound like something you'd do on the side of a road. Buil
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
Swapping out a few hundred kilos of battery is going to require some tools and equipment. That doesn't sound like something you'd do on the side of a road. Building facilities for that would be quite a bit of effort. Probably installing a charging point is a lot less complicated and costly.
Also the logistics of moving tons of batteries around are going to be a bit challenging. The infrastructure for that would also need to be built and unlike charging points there's none of it anywhere. Finally, having a lot of middlemen messing around with batteries adds a lot of cost as well.
Anyway, now that in car batteries are good enough now and on track to get way better still, this seems completely redundant. There are plenty of charging points and EV owners typically install one in their homes as well. None of the infrastructure for swapping batteries exist, no standards for such a thing exists, and fixing that seems to not really solve a problem anyone actually has.
- ggm 7y agoThe only logistics are for initial supply and replacement. The battery swap points would be what we call gas stations. The batteries would clearly be designed to slide in and out in some motorised manner with a lift, And have positive latch connects. Contrast the costs of battery swap with retrofitting power reticulation to large developments, upscaling the distribution network, fitting individual charge points, and swap has good economics. I agree it's unlikely. I just think it makes more sense.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoSounds like a lot of infrastructure would be needed to swap, handle, transport and store the batteries. Also presumably at some point you'd need to charge the batteries, which means you need .... charging points. So the economics are those of charging points plus a lot of logistics and man power. That sounds like bad economics to me.
- ggm 7y agoRepurposed gas stations have most of what you need. Delivery of power to an array of chargers cheaper than reticulated suburbs.